SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 3 - Behind the AP Scoring Process: Dr. Andrew Daily on Modern History Education and AI
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe interviews Dr. Andrew Daily, Associate Professor of European History at the University of Memphis and veteran AP World History Reader. Dr. Daily shares insider knowledge about AP exam scoring, the evolution of history education, and how artificial intelligence is transforming the classroom.
Key topics include the shift from content memorization to critical thinking skills in AP exams, strategies for teaching effective writing in the digital age, and practical approaches to integrating AI as an educational tool rather than a threat. Dr. Daily also discusses the challenges facing K-12 education, the importance of curiosity in learning, and predictions for the future of higher education.
This episode is essential listening for AP teachers, students preparing for history exams, and anyone interested in the intersection of technology and education.
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. All right, Dr. Daly, welcome to the Supported Learning Podcast. How are you, sir?
SPEAKER_01Good, Joe. How are you tonight?
SPEAKER_00I am doing well. Thank you for joining us. So just yeah, no, I appreciate it. Uh, just a little background for our audience. Dr. Daly is a professor from the University of Memphis in European history, and he is also an APU world history reader for the exam, meaning he actually reads and scores the LEQ portion of the AP world exams. And how long have you been doing that for?
SPEAKER_01Uh almost over seven years now. Um, but I well, I mean, I guess if you add it all up, it's more like 12, because I did it when I was graduate school, took a few years off, and came back to it uh about seven years ago. So and this year's kind of exciting. I'm gonna be a table leader, which means I'm one of the people who reads the answers and comes up with the rubrics.
SPEAKER_00So is the the chief score, is that gonna be like some of that input, is that gonna be from you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. My understanding is like the table leaders are you get there early, you read the the answers, and then you help kind of come up with the you help the scorers kind of come up with the baseline rubrics for the tests.
SPEAKER_00So awesome. Okay, cool.
SPEAKER_01So that's we'll dive into that meet as yours.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um well, so I mean, yeah, I guess let's just start for the audience that you know that don't know you. That was that a good enough intro, or am I missing any accolades?
SPEAKER_01No, not missing any accolades. I mean, I could I could plug my book that's coming out in a couple months.
SPEAKER_00Plug your book, we'll plug your book. Yeah, it's a podcast. Plug your book. What do you got coming out?
SPEAKER_01Uh, with a collaborator of mine from University of Georgia, we're publishing a critical edition and translation of a of a Caribbean play from the 1970s. So um it'll be coming out Liverpool University Press in May, I think.
SPEAKER_00So is it Hamilton the Caribbean version, or no? Is that it's not the remix? No, definitely not Hamilton. Gotcha. So there is music, though, and there's the anyway. So really, yeah. Gonna get a Broadway deal. Call it more well. There you go. So I guess, you know, let's just take back, uh, take us back to like what what uh what was the initial interest in history? Like what what gravitated you towards trying to become a good idea?
SPEAKER_01That is a really good question. Like, why would someone become a professional historian? Um I think it was a it was a couple fold. I was it was always a subject I was really good at in school um and was always interested in, but I would really think I would say it was my grandparents. So my my mother's parents, um, you know, my my grandfather was from the United States. He was born and raised uh outside Cincinnati, and he kind of experienced sort of the full gamut of what we might call American history in the 1920s, 30s, and 40s, right? So he had to live through the depression, you know, um, he had to, you know, while he was in high school, he had to work a job to help support his family. And then he was, you know, he was drafted during the war, fought in Europe. That's where he met my grandmother, who was from Birmingham in England. Um, and so, you know, I think their story was so tied up in the history of the middle part of the 20th century that I was always fascinated by that. And you know, he used to tell me stories like he himself was a great um, you know, storyteller, right? And you know, a recounter of the past. And so that kind of got me on that path.
SPEAKER_00That's so cool. That's what your grandparents got you. That's that was kind of like my journey too, because the uh I uh so my grandfather I'll say fought in World War II, although he was 17 at the time, and he brags about being smart enough in the Navy to test into signalmen, which was like a very important position. So he worked the flags, the signals on the ship that like the land the landing craft would move in and out of repair. So um he was that role, he was in the uh 1944, he was 17, he was in the Pacific. Um, but my actually love for history didn't start because of stories from him, which I knew very little of, but he used to have an awesome VHS collection of just World War II movies and and and westerns, right? So the first one, because I love trains, I love planes growing up, Von Ryan's Express with Frank Sinatra, that kind of triggered it, and then there was The Great Escape and all these classic 1970 World War II movies. Um, and then fast forward to like the modern version of World War movies, like, well, that war was nothing like that, like it was much more, much, much more horrible. But um, yeah, so I guess why why did you get grab why'd you gravitate towards European history of all things, though?
SPEAKER_01I mean, that is a really good question. You know, when I when I went, I think actually, and this maybe will speak a little bit to some other things I might mention, is it was a professor in college. Uh it my I had a professor in college, his name was, or his name is, he's he's retiring this year actually, uh, Dr. Ben Westwell, and he was, you know, he was actually a medieval historian. And he was like one of those historians out of central casting, right? He was just like a great, like compelling, interesting lecturer. He could, you know, he he knew multiple languages, he could, you know, translate passages out of Latin, like in his head, and it was just, you know, I was starstruck, right? So um Yeah, I think he pulled me into it. I mean, I'd always been interested in history. I thought about majoring in history in college, but I didn't know that I was gonna become a professional historian probably until I met him and you know, basically wanted to be him. And that pulled me into European history. I gravitated out of the early period into like, you know, the later period, but um, that's definitely why I decided to study European history. That and I was uh, you know, I wouldn't say fluent, but very good at French already. So I kind of already had that on in my head. Okay. Oh, yeah, you're fluent in French. That's awesome. I wouldn't say I'm fluent, but I I uh I am yeah, I have a good knowledge of French.
SPEAKER_00Okay, cool. Yes, like uh my history I was um I I had I went into teaching, but I had some really awesome history professors. That kind of like I wasn't gonna, I was gonna go for pre-law and then I switched. Uh, but I was lucky enough that that the the dean of the department retired. He actually taught my favorite history teacher in high school. And it was his and he was like an expert in Nazism and Holocaust. So it was just he was he was great. He was also central, had wore three piece suits, had the pocket watch, half British. It was pretty cool. Um, yeah, no, for sure. Um so um you're an associate professor?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I'm an associate professor. Okay.
SPEAKER_00And um I guess like how did that so how did you end up in Memphis? How did that that role evolve?
SPEAKER_01That's a great so I you know I'm actually originally, as I tell my students, and many of them are from California, like emerging from California. I grew up in San Francisco. I didn't know that. Yeah, I grew up in San Francisco. And um, you know, we did move to Oregon when I was seven. Sorry, we moved to Washington State when I was 17. I went to college in Oregon. I've been all over. But I, you know, when I was looking for graduate schools, I got pointed in the direction of this woman who was teaching, uh, who teaches at she's retired now too, but taught at Ruckers in New Jersey. And so that's where I did my doctorate. And I came to Memphis, they offered me a job. Um, you know, I didn't finish my dissertation at a really kind of inopportune moment um for the job market, as they call it in my profession in 2011, right? So it was after the crash. And you know, in retrospect, it actually wasn't that bad, it's even worse now. But you know, I I offered a job, I came down here. Um I've been here, you know, I just realized I've been here 14 years now.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I mean to get in at that point, because I around that time I was looking to go back for my master's and was either gonna be in teaching and education or in history, and my my the Dr. Dunn, who I you know loved, he was like, if you were my son, I would say go into get a master's in education teaching because you're you're there's not gonna be a lot of jobs, like it's just a declining field, it's kind of sad.
SPEAKER_01Um, my friend calls us, he calls us the lifeboat generation, and that like you know, the ship went down, but we managed to get to the lifeboats, but we had a lot of friends who drowned, right? Like it's a terrible analogy.
SPEAKER_02That's terrible.
SPEAKER_01It's a terrible analogy, but he's he's right. It's like you know, we know people from graduate school are friends of ours who were never able to find a job, and it's just gotten worse since. So, but yeah, I know. That's a whole nother conversation, I'm afraid.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, we can kind of get into that. Um, I guess is that that too much feedback if I put that fan on just because it's a little hot, but um so you teach undergraduates, uh, you research decolonization. I guess, you know, I know you're a professor, but you've always been working with with kids in AP prep as well. What is like one part of education that whether it's K-12, higher, higher ed, whatever, that I guess you wish we would rethink or redesign when it comes to teaching decolonization, teaching decolonization or colonization in general, because it's like colonization bad, decolonization good, and it's it's still, I think, taught through like the lens of black and white. But what is your opinion about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I I think you know, I agree. I think one of the things is that you know, the way we teach it often has to be, I mean, it it's inevitable when you teach anything, is you've got a sort of it's hard to get into the nuances of things when you're trying to teach, you know, um a huge amount of history in a small apart small amount of time, right? Like most of the time we teach decolonization, it's being taught in the context of these large survey courses, right? So you get maybe one day or two days out of a semester to actually talk about it, right? So you can't get into the nuances of it. But yeah, I mean, I think if you you drill down and you look, like colonialism is extremely complicated because it was always about you know, it's this the story I tell my students about India, right? Is that at the height of the British Raj, right, in the 1930s, there were only something like a hundred thousand British people in India ruling over 250 million Indians, right? So at some point there had to be some degree of buy-in, right, from the population, right? And so, you know, part of the interesting story about decolonization is why do why does that buy-in disappear? Like, why do people change their minds? Why do people decide that, you know, in some cases it's more obvious, right? Like the colonial regime is more cruel, right? Um, but in other cases it it becomes the question of like, well, why do they decide that they don't want to be part of this empire anymore? Like, what switches? Why is it that all of a sudden, you know, they're not interested in in that kind of approach anymore? I mean, in that kind of uh existence anymore, right? Um and I think, well, you know, if you're saying like, you know, you asked me a question earlier about like how I'd redesign things and and and you know, what I see as sort of some of the faults, I think I think that's where like you know schools have moved away from. I don't know about at the high school level, although I get this impression as well, but particularly at the college level, we've moved away from this idea of learning from a bunch of different types of disciplines, right? Um back in the 70s and 80s, that was all the premium, right? But now, you know, people don't people who take history don't also take classes in literature or political science or philosophy or languages, right? And so you're not learning all the different aspects of kind of that, yeah. History can teach a lot. That's one of the reasons I like history, right? Everything's got history, right? Um, but it helps to sometimes have those different skill sets from different sort of uh disciplines.
SPEAKER_00I mean, so do you teach the intra-level courses as well to some students?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I teach actually, I mean, that's one of the reasons, you know, I I sought you out, right? Is I teach the intro-to-world history, right? And I think part of what I like about tutoring, what I like about what we do uh here is that you know, I've been dissatisfied with the level of preparation among a lot of my students, right? And and I think being able to, it's been really helpful for me to see like what actually is taught in the AP curriculum. Um I can tell you it's it's a lot different than when I took the AP test back in the 90s. And it's a lot better. It's a lot better. Um, you know, the the skill sets that are being taught in the AP history courses are really excellent in terms of preparing students from college for college.
SPEAKER_00And so for me, I feel like if they're taught though.
SPEAKER_01If they're taught, yes.
SPEAKER_00So what they require is good.
SPEAKER_01You know, I no probably not a single one of the students I work with is ever gonna come to the University of Memphis and learn from me, but I do feel like I'm kind of paying it forward in the sense that like they're gonna end up in someone's history class at some point, like in college, you know, hopefully not introductory because they got a four or five on the test, right? But yeah, right, right. End up maybe in an advanced history class, and they're gonna have a set of skills um that their teacher is really gonna appreciate that they have when they get into that classroom, right? And so I I kind of that's what I've enjoyed about it.
SPEAKER_00So that's awesome. I I do enjoy that too. I guess. Oh, are you in the uh American Historical Association?
SPEAKER_01I am and I'm not.
SPEAKER_00Not paying a membership or whatever.
SPEAKER_01I I I let my membership lapse about two years ago because I hadn't been to a conference in a while. I should really probably sign up again, but yeah, I let my membership lap.
SPEAKER_00So I um I was invited. Um actually my next guest after you, I um I'm speaking, Craig Perrier. Um he's gonna be on the podcast here soon. Um we we taught, we taught, we did a three, a three-speaker panel like presentation. Um, it was with another professor from Pitt um about she talked about history and scale and identifying scale. And um I think Craig talked about globally centered, globally like how to how to teach from the lens of a well rounded like global citizen. Right. Excuse me. Um, and I presented on basically, and this was a K16 presentation, so it was meant to be for teachers and for professors, and just you know, I was so impressed by the IB curriculum because the IB curriculum is all writing in those assessments, like, and it really just takes any type of uh even if you teach it pure, you're you're avoiding putting any type of bias in the way you teach it because of your exploration of historiography and how you have to look at all sources. So I like that because it's like, oh, during the Cold War, America did some bad things. Russia was like, yeah, but like everyone gets the context, which is a lost skill, right? Contextualization is such a lost skill now because we're during the last couple of years, we're tearing down statues of Thomas Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln and George Washington in the same lens that we're tearing down statues of Confederate generals. Um, but what I thought was what IB is centered around is the assessments of writing and allowing the students to develop the argument. And I and I've seen AP history, a lot of the APs move towards more argument-based writing. But as teachers, as history teachers, as history educators, I just I mean, I love my college I went to, but I think in terms of preparation and especially preparing to teach kids writing, we're not we're not writing teachers, right? We don't come out with that skill. We usually become history teachers because we love history. We either loved our teachers or loved our professors, and we love talking about history, but we're not really gifted with the skills or taught the skills of how to actually teach those fundamental things. Have you seen that matriculate up? Have you seen a decline of kids' writing of thought over the last X amount of years?
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's I mean, it's it's so complicated because I think it's it's you know, it's it's it goes back, as you said, it's a case through 16 issue, right? Like, you know, it's about how we structure our educational system, what we put priorities on at lower levels. And then, you know, if you're thinking about you know, the ideal of an education is you're building, building, building, building, right? You're building a platform up, you know, and adding the more complicated things as you go, but um, you know, the shift towards like test-based learning, you know, has damaged the ability of people to read and write. And, you know, I would say if you ask any college professor, they would tell you that this is a huge problem, right? And there's of course other issues beyond that, right? I mean, about you know, social media attention spans, things like that. But um, you know, I I do think, you know, um, yeah, we're not, it's an old joke about PhD, right? It's like you get a PhD and you're gonna leave and you're gonna spend half your time teaching, and you spend maybe like one percent of your PhD career learning how to teach, right? Like um so, you know, um yeah, it's a bit of a problem. I think I'm actually again, I think I'm what I'm impressed about with the AP exam, you know, having now like sat with it for a couple of years and is the way in which it's actually now moved towards teaching a skill set more than like just content. Like no, no, there's content still important, don't get me wrong. Yeah, right. Foundational. But like the kind of questions they ask you on the test these days about like, you know, just basic things about like, can you understand a historical argument? Uh, do you understand that history is a set of interpretations, right? Like, you know, we don't have time machines, we can't go to the past and see what actually happened. Like, we're using these traces that we have to tell a story, and so people can interpret the same document different ways. And so I think it's really interesting to me that they've moved in that direction. And I think it shows they've really thought through about what they're doing. So, um, and I think it's one of the real benefits, I think, for students now of taking AP, right, is because they're getting uh a real leg up on their fellows who are not taking that kind of class because those are the skills you're gonna need in college. Um, whether you, you know, major in history and you major in something else, like that set of skills is something that's gonna be extraordinarily useful for you across whatever it is you plan to do as a as a college student, whatever you plan to do, you know, in the rest of your life.
SPEAKER_00So well, and that's why I think you know, we don't we don't share that enough with our parents about unless you're doing AP seminar and AP research, AP literature, AP language is not really set up to create to teach you how to write argument argumentative based essays, but history does. And so when you're in college, you're writing a lot of research papers. If you don't get that skill from somewhere, you're going in underprepared 100%. And then kids are probably getting crushed, I assume, on how they do it. But let's um This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supported tutoring.com to find the support your student deserves.
SPEAKER_01Let's talk about AI because it is uh segue is immediately into AI, I think.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I think because like all right, so ChatGPT is what, like maybe a year old, maybe?
SPEAKER_01At least in terms of like being maybe two, I'm not sure in terms of ubiquity, I'd say two years old, right? Maybe a year and a half.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so it was so funny because like in my high school, we were like teachers were talking about it. There was one teacher, computer science teacher was like warning us, hey, AI is coming, like it's and then it was like within its instant, it was here, and kids were cheating with it already. So, like, um, you obviously are in humanities. Um, how do you see this as a shift in the way kids are engaging, students are engaging with historical thinking, research in the coming years? Because is there gonna be a need for research if we have AI? Like, what is how disruptive will this be to this profession?
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's interesting. So, you know, I we've had a lot of conversations with my colleagues about this. I've had a conversation with a friend of mine who he's not an AI researcher, but you know, he's a tech guy. Like he thinks about this stuff a lot. And I think, you know, I think part of it is, you know, what AI or what the models of AI that we actually have right now and what they do has maybe been overhyped, right? Um, you know, they're not actually thinking machines, right? It's it's a really excellent web crawler and you know amalgamator of information, right? Um so I think one of the things I keep trying to tell my students, right, is like, okay, you can use AI, right? Like but you know, the thing about right research and writing, in particular about writing. Is that writing is a form of thinking, right? Like you don't come up with the thoughts fully formed in your head and then just reproduce them on the page, right? As you're writing, you're actually revising, rethinking, sharpening your argument. So if you're using AI, like, okay, I can't stop you, but you're not thinking, right? So like what are you getting out of any class in college if you're doing that? You're just punching the information in, right? But so you know, the fear I have, right, is it becomes a replacement for thinking, right? It becomes a replacement for people then rely on it to basically do not just basic thinking, like in terms of like how do you sharpen like a computer code or how do you solve this like mathematical equation, but you know, questions that don't have a yes or no answer, right? Questions that are interpretive, questions that are about balancing two sets of information in which there's not a clear answer, right? Because one of the things binary code can't do is it can't handle nuance and contradiction, right? Like so, but then the other thing is I think we need to, as teachers, need to think about how we can use it as a tool to our advantage, right? Because I was talking to a friend of mine who was saying that she was sort of uh she had done an observation of like how her stud, she had let her use students use AI, right?
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01Did an observation of how they used it, and they were using it almost like they were using it in what I think the original idea of it was was as an assistant, right? Not as a replacement, but as an assistant, so that like they could test their arguments with it, right? And then it would help them see like where their weaknesses were. It could help them, you know, fact-check information, right? It could help them fix citations, right? Like, you know, yes, students are cheating with it. Like, let's not deny it, but you know, students were cheating before there was AI, and there'll be students cheating after there's AI, right? Um but they were actually using it like uh as a sort of an aid, right? And and and I think if we can think about it as a way to help them sharpen their ideas, right? But also I think what we really have to teach them about, right, is just sort of skepticism, right? Like here's a tool, but it's still just a tool, right? It's not a deity that tells you the truth, right? It's it's a tool. And any tool, you need to be aware how you're using it, and you also have to be aware how the tool is using you, right? And so um, yeah, I think there's, you know, it's a it's a it's an interesting moment. I think there's, you know, we're all worried about it, right? Let's not pretend we're not, right? But I think, you know, there's ways around it, or there's ways to harness it to our advantage, or to use it as a, you know, we love those words, teaching moment, right? Use it as a teaching moment. So it doesn't have to be our enemy. It's definitely it's definitely made things a lot more complicated, I'll put it that way. But so I mean, I don't know what your experience with AI is or we have teachers that are scared of it.
SPEAKER_00We have teachers that don't think it's their role to help students learn it.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00Um, and some teachers are integrating it well. I just I mean, honestly, what we're doing in the business with AI and what we're trying to develop, because we're actually long-term trying to develop an AI tutor um that can assist. It's it's so disruptive. I mean, um, I know you've heard of ChatGPT. Have you heard of Claude?
SPEAKER_01Yes, and I I hear about much better things about Claude than I hear about ChatGPT.
SPEAKER_00Claude is amazing. I just I'm working with um our social media person trying to like create some new like web pages and stuff, and I literally took images of our new brand, like put it in the cloud, put Google Docs in the Claude, and like I need you to create web pages in my our platform Go High Level, and it did it. Like within 10 minutes, I had five web pages built. It was and like that is unbelievable. She's like, I'm gonna lose my job. I'm like, no, I need you to like polish it. I'm like, no, this is just to save you time because we need to get stuff done. But uh yeah, it's it's super disruptive. It's it it's I I and I but I do see it of like there's no verification of the information, it's an advanced language model, and so like we're just we're not we're not if we don't know those arts of critical thinking, we're just taking it for its word, and we're not actually we're just okay, we'll go with it. And it's like, no, this is actually actually false.
SPEAKER_01Right. Part of it is like, you know, people call in hallucinations, right? But it's not a hallucination, it's like it's only as good as the data set it's trained on, and there's all we all know on the internet there's a lot of garbage. So, you know, and so it's you know that's why I've heard better things about quad because they use a different approach, if I understand it correctly. I'm not a completely person, but they they use a different model than the chat GPT.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I think the the role, because I'm thinking like my dad's my dad was a lawyer, my dad's still a lawyer. And if you hook this up to if you could train it and hook it up to the entire like legal knowledge of mankind, and it could search the entire every legal decision ever made, every legal interpretation, and basically within seconds you could have a legal case and how to how to even though it's still yeah, even though it's still judged, right? Unless we replace that with a robot. But um I just think of like, well, what's the role of lawyer? What's the role of paralegals? What's the role of lawyers gonna be? But you're still gonna have to learn how to prompt it, right?
SPEAKER_01It's not gonna and that's it's still with the one of my friends is made, right? Is like it's you still have to learn how to ask the questions, right? And you know, actually when we teach our students, that's one of the things we always say to them, right? Is like one of the most important things is the questions you ask, not necessarily like, you know, that's maybe the hardest part is coming up with good questions.
SPEAKER_00So do you think I'm not gonna say necessarily college, but do you think K through 12 does a good job of teaching kids how to ask good questions? To be honest, it's okay.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_01No, and it's not really the fault of the I would agree with you. It's not really the fault of K through 12 teachers, I would say, because You don't think? Well, I mean it depends, but I mean I don't it has to do with incentives, right? Because so much of this has been replaced with like each to the test, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, yeah. But do you think the system of school No, no, I don't.
SPEAKER_01Like I'd say this, I wouldn't blame individual teachers, I would I blame the system for sure.
SPEAKER_00The system because like you're told there's it's divergent versus like convergent thinking. Like you're taught there's one way of thinking through it, there's only one way to do it, and then they're like I know Neil deGrasse Tyson used to talk about like toddlers of like experimenting, and like everything they hear from parents is no, don't do this, don't do this, don't do that. And so like toddlers naturally question the world by testing limits, and that's how we develop the curiosity. But like, do you think the system of education, um and I mean system of like pre-K, this is all the way through, right? Of just how we are teaching society to conform. Do you think that well you've kind of answered already, but like, are we we're really not allowing kids to generally be curious, like curio, like let curiosity drive question making.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely not. So you know, I was lucky my daughter went to, she didn't go to Montessori, but she went to an Amelia Romagna program, which you know, it's one of those models that is based on student directed learning, right? Um, and she's been lucky to do that. But like, I mean, I know one, her program is an exception, and then you know, when you enter into the usual sort of K through 12 system, like that level of experimentation is, you know, it's rare, right? Because, you know, it's just it's about the way in which curricula are structured, it's the incentive structure of like the teachers have to teach a test, right? And if they can't get their students across the test, then they lose their job, right? And then the simple fact that like, you know, you don't have the time and the resources to teach creative thinking. And I don't I don't know how you solve that. Um, but it is critical because I think you know, as you say, like exploration, experimentation, imagination, these are all really important and are other, you know, they're they're tons of intelligence that we don't consider to be intelligence, but they are intelligence. Uh and they tend to lead more towards uh people who think critically and creatively about the world, and we need more of those kind of people.
SPEAKER_00Do you think schools kill creative thinking or critical thinking?
SPEAKER_01They can, for sure. Um, I mean I think that I think you know, any of us who have gone into education, right, I won will inevitably tell a story about some teacher who didn't do that, right? But I it seems like it's those teachers don't stand near the norm. Um, and again, um, I don't know why that's the case. Um, you know, I blame the overall system, but um, you know, it's it's just tough, right? Like teachers are paid garbage, like they're you know, our schools are in terrible condition, like, you know, uh it's just you know, it's difficult, right?
SPEAKER_00Well, we have both been tutoring our shared number of AP history students. Does it still surprise you to like how many kids come in without the the lens of even like how they're gonna think critically through these the writing and like they they apply almost all the wrong attributes, right? Because they're not they're trying to like memorize themselves into the ground when like none of the test is memorization and just like teaching a kid that's what I said. Like we're getting products of kids that are coming through a broken system and they're not thinking for themselves at all, and they're just like they're like, I know this one way of studying, it's just to memorize, memorize the right answers, and you'll be good. And it's like, well, you get to the test and you're kind of screwed if you do that.
SPEAKER_01So you're like, Yeah, and the history test, you're absolutely screwed if you do that, right? Because um, yeah, I mean, again, I think it's it's there's such variety, right? You know, I've got definitely gotten students who are very focused on the memorization, like it's a content, content, content, right? And not about skills, approach, you know, methodology, uh, and so on. And then I get students who clearly have been really well prepared by their AP teachers, right? Who under they understand that that's what the test is about, or they're just one of those teachers who that's how they teach, right? And so I actually think maybe I would even say I've been pleasantly surprised, at least particularly this year, about how many of them are have some of those skills already in place, right? And so it's good, made it easier for me to build on because they've already got that there. And they they understand that. And so I guess I would say kudos to their teachers because they've they've done a good job with them.
SPEAKER_00So well then we expect a lot of fives then, Dr. Haley.
SPEAKER_01No pressure. I hope so. I hope so. Well, I'm I'm optimistic.
SPEAKER_00So um Miss Patty, who was one of our APUS tutors last year, um, she was a retired A push teacher, and she was also a reader like yourself. And she was, she gave me the presentation that college board, like that the readers got, and it just seemed like I mean, it just seemed like there was a subtle message of ease up on the grading of the writing. At least that's what how I came across conveyed because it provided like we're not doing this because we're competing with dual enrollment or college and high school classes, we're doing this because their belief is that I mean, but it's like how do you can you not say that you're not? Because a kid can take a CHS US history class and get the guaranteed credit without taking the exam. Meanwhile, A push is still one was one of the hardest exams to pass, and kids are not walking away with credit when it's like they can get out of their intro US classes. So do you have you got a sense for the world at least that the graders are easing up on what they're accepting as scored responses? And do you think that's a good thing?
SPEAKER_01I mean, well, I mean, I think you can see it in that, you know, they have changed the rubrics, right? For the DBQ, right? They've, you know, they've reduced the number of documents you need to use. They've, you know, um, they've eased up on that. I mean, although if you think about it, like the the idea of doing one of those DBQs in an hour is absurd to me. Um, because it's like, you know, how can you read these documents and even begin to digest them and then write an essay about them? So they've eased up on that a little bit, but um yeah, there has been a bit of easing up. There's a bit more flexibility, I think, in terms of what qualifies. But, you know, if if you don't have the stuff there that they want you to have, like you're out of luck, right? Like if you can't demonstrate that particular, you know, a certain skill set in your answers, you're out of luck. But there's certainly been a bit more flexibility in maybe what qualifies for those answers. Um, and it's I'd say it's eased up a little, but it hasn't in the seven years I've been doing it, which is you know, I started about when they changed the, you know, they changed the formats seven, eight years ago, right? When they switched to the like, you know, the current basic format of like, you know, SAQ, D BQ, L E Q. Um it hasn't changed as dramatically as I thought it would. Um, but there is definitely um on the longer essays, there's a bit more flex, I think, than maybe there had been at the beginning.
SPEAKER_00So are you um are you guys are you going to Kansas City this year? Yeah, I am Kansas City. We're gonna do a live stream from there inside college abhorred. Yeah, there we go. Perfect. So like secret AP World Secrets. Um exactly. So, okay, cool. Well, um, I guess like where do you see it all going in the next couple years in terms of just thinking about higher ed AP as a system? Like, where do you see the biggest opportunities to potentially apply a system? Because we don't, we're very disjointed, right? We don't necessarily prepare kids holistically to for the rigors of college and the career, but then I don't know if colleges do a holistic job because everyone's, I'm sure they're very siloed in their own departments there as well. But like, where do you see education going as a system?
SPEAKER_01I mean, that is the billion-dollar question, right? Um I don't know. I've been really, you know, if you had asked me that question a year or two ago, I think I would have given you a very cynical answer. Um, and just that I it feels to me like outside of the realm of like elite universities, like a lot of our universities are being sort of turned into glorified trade colleges, which is no knock on trade colleges, right? Like that's not what the university was originally set up to be, right? Like and it's it's you look at the declining number of majors in fields that are not, you know, pre-professional. And uh and it's you know, and and on on one hand, I understand that track, right? Like it's it's you know, the competition for jobs has become such that like students can't luxuriate in stuff that doesn't help them, right? But the problem is that this is then incentivizing administrations to then double down on that, right? Which does this becomes like a vicious cycle of like the non, you know, the non-STEM fields get defunded, right? And then they you know, I'll just give you the examples like my building at the university is like should be knocked down and condemned, right? Because you know, it doesn't it doesn't really broadcast uh a great advertisement for history as a discipline that you're in this decrepit building that is itself should be consigned to the document of history, right?
SPEAKER_00Like um the science building's probably good though, right? But the science building's probably good, right?
SPEAKER_01The biology building should also be condemned, but really the engineering just got a new building, so um but I guess I I also feel like there might be we might be reaching like a peak if or we might be reaching a pivot point, right, where people are starting to realize like so. I heard this interview back in October with the he is the career counselor at Carnegie Mellon in your city. Um, and he was talking about how his students, right, who are coming out of Carnegie Mellon, right, which is like a STEM college, right? Yeah. Having a hard time compete. You know, some of his students were having a hard time competing for jobs because they lacked soft skills, right? And then he told, recited what soft skills were, right? And I was listening to it, and I'm like, everything he just recited is what the humanities teaches, right?
SPEAKER_00Well, that's so funny because uh Farid Zakari said that too, like in defense of a liberal education.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's something Martha Now Nessbaum gets to in her book about that also. But I think maybe the future is, and this is where I think those of us in in disciplines like history, and I look at one of my colleagues who kind of does this work, is thinking about how do we combine hard and soft skills together, right? Like how do we teach them, you know, and we say soft skills, I shouldn't say that that's not a it sounds judgmental, but it's not. It just means things like they're not like it's things like writing, interpretation, argument, public speaking. Um, you know, they're not soft in the sense that they're like Yeah, no, we're we're starting to be able to do that. Actually, arguably more difficult than hard.
SPEAKER_00Communication skills, human skills. How to be how to be a human.
SPEAKER_01How to be a human being, right? Like uh but maybe how do we think about combining those? Like where they can learn like you know, a set of skills that they can take with them into that first job, right? But then having the more complex complex and higher level critical skills that are gonna see them into the future, right? Like what's gonna get them that second and third and fourth job outside of college, right? That's where we I think we have to start rethinking the university because I don't think it's STEM versus humanities, it's about thinking about how the two can work together, right? Which is at the end of the day, the ideal of the university, right? Universe was the last 30 years, right? Right.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, um thank you so much for coming on. Absolutely. Appreciate you having you. I hope this was uh good. This we're still very early on in this, so be good to feature it. Um, do you have a cop? Do you have a coup do you have a cover of your book out there yet or no?
SPEAKER_01I do, yeah. I'll send it to you. How about that? I will we'll we'll put it in by the book, right?
SPEAKER_00We'll we'll promo that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'll I'll send you the cover.
SPEAKER_00So all right, and we still uh need to meet up in Nashville for some hot chicken and some some beer or something for some next time for sure. How far away are you from uh just two hours? It's not that yeah, we'll definitely do that. So all right, Dr. Daly, it's been a pleasure. Uh keep keep crushing with our students. Take care. Absolutely. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.