SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 12 – Tim Freitas on AP Lang Writing Strategy, Rubric Secrets, and Critical Thinking in the AI Era
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe Sebestyen sits down with veteran AP Reader and Garden of English founder Tim Freighus to unpack what truly drives high scores on the AP English Language exam. Tim shares how strong thesis statements and cohesive topic sentences establish lines of reasoning that consistently earn points, and why many classrooms assign writing without explicitly teaching students how to structure arguments.
Dr. Joe Sebestyen and Tim Freighus discuss how AP Readers are trained, what teachers often misunderstand about rubric evaluation, and why the sophistication point is frequently overemphasized by students. Tim explains that AP writing success is less about natural talent and more about understanding predictable patterns of logical progression that appear in high-scoring essays year after year.
The conversation also explores the broader educational landscape, including the impact of AI tools on student thinking, the importance of handwriting for cognitive development, and how consumer culture may be contributing to declining critical reading habits. Tim outlines practical strategies for earning easy rubric points, building cohesive arguments, and developing disciplined thinking skills that extend far beyond the AP exam.
This episode is especially valuable for AP students aiming for a 4 or 5, English teachers refining their instructional approach, and parents seeking clarity on how AP essays are evaluated. Whether preparing for AP Lang, AP Lit, or any writing-intensive assessment, the principles discussed here provide a blueprint for stronger analytical writing and deeper critical thinking.
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. Hey everyone, welcome back to the Supported Learning Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Joe Sebastian, back with another great guest, uh Tim Freitas. Am I saying that correctly? Yeah, you got that right. Yep. Welcome to the podcast. Welcome to Supported Learning Podcast. How are you doing?
SPEAKER_02Thank you. I'm I'm thrilled to be here. There's no doubt about that. And things are fine, especially because I just moved across the country. Uh, and I'm now that I'm in Las Vegas, I don't have to freeze all winter.
SPEAKER_00Oh, you're so lucky.
SPEAKER_02I know. It's a nice thing. Where did you move from? Massachusetts.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Gotcha. Oh, well, you're well, you're I think they're gonna get pretty hit pretty hard with a snowstorm coming.
SPEAKER_02So yep, and I'm not gonna miss it at all. What uh what made you move to Las Vegas? So I work at Faith Lutheran High School as an English teacher there. And um with what I do with the Garden of English, I'm in a lot of high schools, you know, around the country. And I did some professional development at Faith Lutheran a few years ago, and it was the nicest, it was the nicest school that I've ever been in. But it also my two passions for education are Christian education and vocational technical career training. And this particular school offers both of those elements, and I was like, I didn't even know that existed. Um, and so we kind of got on each other's radars, and last year they offered me a job, and I said, Yeah, I think it's I think that's a good idea.
SPEAKER_00So you're native-born Massachusetts, right?
SPEAKER_02Oh, born and raised. I kid you not, I actually sold the house that I grew up in, that my dad grew up in, that his mom grew up in to move out here.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's I'm I'm from Pittsburgh, so like it's the same thing. Like, I I got out and then I boomeranged all the way back. So like I mean, I live about an hour and a half away from my parents, but at one point we were living in the house with them before we started having kids, and yeah, yeah, I'm like, I need to get out too because I I can't do the winters anymore. So I'm I hear you. So that's that's okay. Well, let me introduce you just to our audience. You have a bachelor's in writing, communication, and rhetoric from the University of Massachusetts, Dartmouth. You have a master's in teaching secondary English education from University of Massachusetts, 15 years of classroom teaching experience since 2008, a veteran AP reader, uh interesting to us as well, sample selection table leader and AP question leader, member of the College Board instructional design team for AP English language and composition, College Board endorsed consultant who trains AP educators nationwide, co-author of the nationally distributed AMSCO AP English Language Composition textbook, and he runs the Garden of English, which we'll get into here in a minute. But uh a lot of credentials from College Board.
SPEAKER_02Um, yeah, and it's one of those things where like I I consult for the College Board, you know. Um, so I don't I don't work for the College Board, but you know, we consult for them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I we have uh a couple graders on our team too for history, and uh, you know, I I've been trained obviously at the APS of two, which I'm assuming that's where you go to train teachers as well.
SPEAKER_02Um yeah, so I'll do APSIs in the summer. Um, but you know, now that I'm a reader, you know, one year I might be a sample selection kind of table leader, one year I might be a question leader. Um, but I haven't been just a uh a reader, which is someone who just reads the essays, of course, probably for about, I don't know, about eight years. I've been in reading leadership for the majority of my time since about 2017 or 2018.
SPEAKER_00I gotcha. When did you um when did you first learn you want to be an English teacher?
SPEAKER_02I was a ninth grader. Um, and interestingly enough, one of my passions for education, like I said before, is career tech ed. And in Matt in Massachusetts, career tech ed is like prestigious, right? So a lot of times when I go to schools around the country, they're like, oh, we kind of send kids who don't do school well to the vocational school or to the career tech ed school.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02But it but in Massachusetts, it's really hard to get into a career tech ed school. Um, and so I went to a career tech ed school in Massachusetts, and this is when it was kind of half and half. It was beginning to become what it is now. And I was like, I'm gonna be an electrician. I don't want to go to college, I don't want to do anything like that. And I had this freshman English teacher, and man, let me tell you, this guy was was bizarre. Uh, but he was he was really quirky and really cool. And I realized very soon into starting my electrical trade work, which I did all throughout high school, that I didn't really love getting dirty, to be completely honest with you. And I would come home really dirty. And so I was like, man, that guy is so quirky and he's so inspiring. And uh he really made me like love reading. Like he was like, Let's read Harry Potter. It's it's big right now, and let's let's do it. Let's actually have a fantasy course. Um and I was like, wow, this guy is this guy is life-changing. And there was another time when um he told me, I think I got like a B in the first quarter of his class or something, and he pulled me aside and he was just like, dude, you're actually really good at the school thing, but you put no effort into it. If you put some effort in, you could probably like do something great. And at that day, I was like, you know what, maybe I should just try to do school better. And I ended up graduating like second of my class and things like that. And it was all because this guy was really quirky and sometimes a little bit brutally honest and also super engaging. And I was like, I think I want to do that.
SPEAKER_00I like that, and you subscribe to a very similar philosophy, which is rare, I think, because I'm still administrator. I I can kind of I'll I'll you'll see where I'm going with this. But you said you don't teach English, you teach students. Where did that philosophy come from?
SPEAKER_02Well, it's it's funny because a lot of times people are always asking me, like, what do you teach? And I'm like, students, and they're like, Yeah, but you know what I mean. And I'm like, Yep, humans, they breathe, they have emotions, all these things. I think that I don't know how to, I don't know how to teach any other way. Like, there's I have a really good friend who's an excellent teacher who's like, Tim, I just gotta cover my content and it is what it is. And for me, I'm like, I get to I get to hang out with some of the coolest people I've ever met for 190 days straight. And then when they finally graduate, we can hang out some more when they do awesome things. Um, you know, and I have students now that are former lawyers, sorry, former students that are now lawyers. Right. I have students who are super successful doing really cool things or traveling different places. Um, I have a student who was a nuclear scientist who decided that she wanted to just go live in Australia and China and kind of like work on a farm. Those are cool stories to have. And then when they come back around and they contact me and they're like, hey, we're here, can we hang out? I'm like, yes, we can. Because the point of our job is to invest in humans. Now it's great to give them awesome thinking and writing skills, but I've never considered that that's what I do. I invest in the character of kids. And in doing so, I then hopefully teach them how to think and write pretty clearly.
SPEAKER_00I love that. Because that's honestly, I mean, I struggled with uh the well, the first year was I was teaching middle school social studies, and I thought my personality will get me through. I could tell really cool stories. Then I ended up teaching in inner city, DC the second year. Did not know classroom management. I got a really good lesson in that that year. But my third year was teaching IB history of the Americas, and you know, it's really where I transformed into my philosophy that I think is similar to yours, where we had to teach writing through history and really actually have those really important connections. And you know, kids don't care until they realize how much you care, right? You have to kind of meet them there almost more than halfway. So it sounds like you teach from a system of passion. Um, but you know, specifically for the AP exams, I guess when did you realize that the success of AP Lang um wasn't really about talent but understanding the system?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so that was interesting because I I actually was given my first AP Lang class when I was 23 years old. Um 20 24 at the oldest. But the reason why was because I had a rhetoric degree and AP Lang was a rhetoric course. And so they were like, Tim, why not, you know, why not, why not do this? And my first two years, I was teaching, I taught AP Lang, and then I also picked up AP Lit, and I realized that I had read, I had already read way too many AP papers, right? Um, hundreds and hundreds, and then going to the APSIs that I was attending and scoring papers and reading my own papers and reading the samples that were released online. One of the things that happened in those first two years of my teaching AP, I noticed that all of the higher scoring essays, no matter what the topic in AP Lang or AP Lit, had the exact same pattern of writing every time. And I was like, oh, gee, they all follow this particular pattern. And then I went and I looked at my graduate work because I started my graduate work when I was like 24, and I was like, oh my goodness, my graduate papers that are earning A's have this same pattern. And so I realized, not in relation to gaming the system, because I think that some people think that the templates that I create are meant to kind of just game the system and move on. I realized they actually help you communicate effectively. Um, and that's provable because the same patterns that show up in the higher scoring AP papers are the same ones that I have in my 12 to 15 to 20 page master's paper that I just turned in. And so because of that, it was like, oh, this is actually teaching patterns of thought and logical progression, not just here's a template that you can fill in. Um and it's funny because it's so misunderstood, because there's even a book out there, I can't remember who wrote it, but the author actually uses my YouTube videos as an example of kind of being like not teaching kids to think essentially. And I'm like, what are you talking about? Fill in that template with anything that's actually sensible. And you would be like, I just wrote a great sentence. It's good thinking, you know what I mean? Um, and so just noticing those patterns allowed me in that those early three two or three years of teaching AP allowed me to kind of start moving towards that. Oh, I can help you really hone in on what needs to be covered in the exam to be successful.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's writing can be formulaic, right if you know the good structures of writing, because we used to our our acronym was APEC, assertion, proof, explanation, connection. Every body paragraph should have all four of those elements to match to get the points on the rubric for the IB rubric. Um I carry that over into how I taught AP history, and it it works with the DBQ, the L AQ. And so, you know, I don't it is more than just like like you said, more than just filling in the in the blank. It's actually teaching kids how to think, and it's really cool because when you apply those strategies, at least to our content, you don't have to know the content, you can just know I need to I need to write this way to get the points. Now, obviously, it's more than just points, but like I was if just like you, take using the same strategies in my master's program that I was teaching my kids, and it's like really good writing.
SPEAKER_02I I actually have master's papers, like sorry, papers that I wrote my master's program that I purposefully used my AP Lit you know techniques with so I could show my students, hey, I just did this in my master's you know, during my master's degree, and I got an A on that paper. And the other thing too, right, is for me, especially because of how I work with teachers all around the world. Well, I do work internationally, like online, but um around the country where I like travel, a lot of teachers assign writing and think that they're teaching writing, but that's very different. I understand. And for for a student who needs, first a lot of students need a lot of guidance in creating their thought patterns, but I don't just stop there. I then teach kids who finally have those thought patterns that can create those lines of reasoning. I teach them how to vary their settings structures. I teach them how to use advanced punctuation and things like that. And I think that that's the thing that's kind of left out. It's like, oh, this guy has a formula that can do this for test day, so it's just test prep. And it's like, well, first of all, if the test, if the test is testing the right skills, it's not that bad. Um, and then on top of that, or formulas aren't necessarily that bad if you can do it, but also a strong base formula allows for awesome things. If I'm a jazz player, I should probably know my jazz scales first. That doesn't mean you have to. Some people can come out just, you know, throw in down awesome solos, but not everybody can do that. And I want to make sure that I meet the kids who can't just come out as authentic writers born going to Harvard, put themselves in a position to think well, write well for the exam and beyond that, and then eventually learn how do we break free from the templates and vary things up while still keeping these good parts that were taught were talked about or taught to us.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I um definitely can relate to that because the AP history, 60% of the test is writing or the grade comes from the writing. And what history teacher do you know spends 60% of their classroom instructional time thinking, evaluating, writing? They'll assign a DBQ for homework or a project, and it's like that's not how it works on the exam. Not only that, but they're not spending that time to teach that. But you decided to form the garden of English. Tell me about that. Like, what were you trying to solve with that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so what happened was in about 2012, I'd I started, you know, getting involved in online Facebook communities for AP English language and AP English literature and things like that. And I would consistently submit, you know, just materials out to people and whatnot. And um, I would also give my phone number away freely, which I still actually still do. Wait, still actually still do. That was superfluous, forgive me. But I still do. I give myself phone number out all the time. And I have no problem having a phone call with anybody about anything English. It doesn't bother me, uh, particularly teachers, of course. I don't just give my phone number out to students or anything like that. But uh nonetheless, what ended up happening was one time, one week, my my wife was like actually said to me, she said, Tim, you've answered the same question this week five different times in five different phone calls. And she said to me, Don't you think it would be more appropriate to just start a YouTube channel and take these questions that you're getting consistently and just making videos about it? So you can just say, Here's a link, you can get your answer here. Here's a link, you can get your answer here. So my wife was really the kind of um impetus for me doing this because she just didn't want me to be on the phone as much as I was. Uh, it didn't help because it turned into a business that I now have to be on the phone a little bit more, you know. Um, and but nonetheless, um that was kind of the start of the Garden of English as an entity when I started doing YouTube. But then it came into um people really wanted to have um well-produced videos. People wanted to have you know more test prep if they could, um, or more test prep materials. And I just have so many of these things that I was like, you know what, maybe it is time to kind of put this together and also offer professional development if I can. Um so I so I started offering professional development. Um, and then you know, the I mean the the rest kind of comes from there. And then when you when you can run good PD, I mean you're an administrator, you know how much PD actually out there is that's out there is not good, right? And and and right, and they charge an arm and a leg. Well, fortunately for me with the Garden of English, I have like three to five consultants that regularly work for me, two that are like the first two people that I call. But we promise that we will be the best English PD for your English department ever. And if you don't believe that, then we'll give you all your money back. So we'll say, here's our bill. But if if your teachers do not say that it's the best PD they've ever had, or they feel like they were not given something of value, then I'll I'll pay my people or up, you know, and then I'll I'll just I'll just give you your money back because we really stand by what we do.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome. Have you had to give any money back?
SPEAKER_02Never once. Nope. That's me, that's me. No, I've been doing this for uh we the Garden of English has been what it is for five years. Um, and I actually got a call from a uh administrator two years ago in Washington, and he was like, just wanted to let you know, I just went to an administrator conference and I told every single curriculum coordinator if you're not working with the Garden of English, you're just not doing it right. And I wasn't even the one that went up there. Um, so I don't want anybody to think that I'm like some pretentious jerk or whatever. Um I sent another I sent another one of my colleagues up there and just absolutely glowing reviews. And then the next year I sent my other colleague up there, same exact thing. How valuable could could this be? And that's why we stand by what we do, uh, because we also offer the lowest prices for PD as well. And as you know, as an administrator, you want to get good PD. And so now that's what we do. We're just really small, you know? Right, right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I like that. So kind of shifting into like the AI landscape because when ChatGPT came out, I think maybe two years ago, where the students were all over writing their essays with it, but how do you see it changing how students approach writing?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I'll tell you how I see it in my classroom. In my classroom, I don't allow almost any technology. Um, and that's not because I don't think that they're gonna not go into a world with technology, and it's not that I don't think they're gonna go into a world with AI, but the truth is that writing is thinking on paper. And I need to teach kids how to think. And the only way that I can really hold them accountable for wrestling with their thoughts is by getting them to write by hand. So one of the things that I've seen in my classroom over the past few years is kids who have been able to potentially get away with AIing part of their work or all of their work or doing the AI thing and then trying to change it up enough so it doesn't sound like AI, it doesn't fly in my classroom. And the reason why I do it that way is because analog skills translate directly to the digital world. But digital skills do not translate directly to the analog world. And so, for example, right, I make my students write everything by hand. I can have kids that can type fluidly and think fluidly here, and then when they go to write, they can't do either of those things. And I'm like, at some point, your computer and your phone will turn off. You don't know why. Maybe you're out of battery, maybe you need to communicate with somebody, maybe you need to whatever. Um, and so those are the kind of things that I force kids to do. I'm like, look, it you might not like it, but I'm gonna make sure that you are accountable for your actual own thoughts and you're not actually using um the digital world to create those there. I'm not scared of AI in relation to how it can help adults be more productive at times, but I will tell you that I am scared with how kids are so willing to outsource their thinking to AI platforms or any type of electronic help. And I really kind of wish that our culture took our AI book from the Jetsons because AI and the Jetsons did their laundry, cooked their food, cleaned their dishes, and the humans could still be humans. They could write, they could think, they could create, they could do art. And instead, we're kind of like, here, we'll let the AI write for you, we'll let the AI create all the art, and then we'll just turn you into little minions who go work at a factory or something like that, you know? And I'm like, ah, I think the Jetsons had it right.
SPEAKER_00I was just having that thought in school as well of how we're just outsourcing critical thinking now. Yeah. Because you know, we're writing argumentative-based essays, and I get a lot of kids that come into our program or the parents like they're already they're a good writer. And I'm like, probably a narrative-based writer, maybe persuasive-based. I doubt argumentative based, because there is a formula, like we mentioned, having that evidence and analysis there. But I realized like if when kids would debate orally, they can get their points across. But when it comes to that pen and paper, you're so true about that. The analog style, they are not arguing the same way they would if they did orally, and just allowing for those kids to do it. I love your thought process on pen and paper, because I agree with you 100%.
SPEAKER_02It's it's one of those things where the last few schools that I've interviewed at, I've been asked, what do you want kids to learn about technology in your classroom? And I've said, what to do when it turns off. Because that's when we're actually human. And if you think about the first question you asked me when, or the first thing you brought up when you were like, What you know, tell me about this idea of you teach students, you teach humans, right? I want the humans to be human in my classroom. And if that means they have to make mistakes, they are welcome to make mistakes. If that means that I have to read their hieroglyphics, I have inner Sanskrit up here somewhere, you know? Um, and and that's and that's okay because that's part of what makes us human. And the idea of everything needing to be more efficient and whatnot. Life is messy, thinking is messy, and being human and growing together is not this efficient process. It takes a lot of trial and a lot of error. And just doing things fluidly on a computer that squiggles things for you when you mess up is not the trial and error that I need. In fact, it's distracting. They can't even get through their whole thought because they realize that there's a red squiggly line there and they want to spell the word correctly or at least right click to get it. That red squiggly line gone. And then their thoughts are entirely gone. And I'm like, no, I needed your whole thought out there. Then we can fix it. Things like that.
SPEAKER_00Ironically, my iPad died with my questions on it, so now I'm like beautiful.
SPEAKER_02What to do when it turns off, right?
SPEAKER_00What to do? It's just gonna get another device. So just charge it back up. So okay, so you're actively a grader for College Board, um, table lead table reader. Um, and I guess you know, the the but we just talked about writing the the college board, they're going digital, AP exams are going digital. Um, and what do you see where where it's heading in terms of how they're redesigning the assessment today? How do you think AI is gonna factor in potentially to grading?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, I'm not I'm not entirely concerned about AI in relation to becoming like like robo readers. Like I know that the state of Texas kind of like does their AI reading for their state tests and whatnot, or I'm sorry, I should say I have heard such things uh from my Texas colleagues. I'm not in Texas, so I don't know that to be entirely true, but I'm pretty sure that's true because I trust my colleagues. But um, in terms of the college board and whatnot, I don't I never have presuppositions about this the college board being this maniacal, money-hungry machine. Um I don't, and I know that a lot of people do because it's $90 per exam and there's an exam cancellation fee. And you know, there are those types of things, right? And I know that I know that their executives get paid, you know, a lot of money when they release their public statements and whatnot. But the truth is, is I don't I don't hold those pre supposed those you know, presuppositions or even suppositions or assumptions because I've been on the backside and I've seen how much work we have put in as readers to select the best samples we can based on a rubric and we talk those out like humans. So at the at the level that I've seen here, when I'm with my table, if I'm a table leader and I'm talking to the people that read with me and whatnot, we are it's a very, very human process that I think everybody understands as some of the best professional development you could ever be involved with.
SPEAKER_01Everyone says.
SPEAKER_02And I and I and I honestly think that if the if the college board wants to have any grace with the teachers that support with what they do, they will not take the best PD options available away from them. Otherwise, there might be some sort of like uh, you know, uh figurative lynching or something like that.
SPEAKER_00You know, what do you um well as a as a table leader, as a question leader, um, what do most teachers who've never been in those rooms don't they don't understand or they fail to understand about how essays are actually evaluated?
SPEAKER_02I can't answer this question as clearly as you want just because of what I'm allowed to say and what I'm not allowed to say. But what I could what I could tell you is this. I think that there's a lot of questioning the process. Shouldn't necessarily be well, hold on. It's it's great to ask questions about like what's going on, but it's one of those things where the these tests have been normed and and uh analyzed statistically for years and years and years and years. They consistently fall within a margin of error, a statistical margin of error. So, of course, does that mean that there are errors that might be made with any type of scoring? Sure. But that's expected when you have that much of a volume of something. I have learned to trust the process because the truth is, is that in the way that readers are trained and the way that readers talk about things, it's very seldom, it's it's it's quite seldom that there's a huge discrepancy between any given score. Just because of how, I don't know, like you have you ever seen Severance before? Yeah. Okay. So in in the show Severance, right? When when they're in the severed layer and they're trying to talk about putting numbers in the bin, like, oh, the numbers kind of like stick out and put in the bin. It comes to the point when we're so well trained and we know what we're looking for because we have experience, right? That that that you just like you know that this fits these qualities of the rubric and you don't have to question it. And that happens every single year. People are normed, and there's ways to actually check to make sure that readers are normed. And then reading leadership follows through with that. So if there are abnormal numbers, things are checked, right? And so uh I think that a lot of people think that it's kind of like, oh, someone read your paper and then just threw it out the back, right? And it's like, no, we know what the statistical margin should be, we know what these things should be, and they're checked and they're focused on. And I think that that's one of those things that I think everybody's had that one student, or maybe more than one student, who they thought was gonna get a five and got a two. And it's like, how? How is that possible? And it might be part of the margin of error, but it also might be that any given test day, a student can have something go wrong. Maybe they got in a fight with the boyfriend or girlfriend that morning, maybe their car broke down on the way to school. Like maybe there are so many things that can happen on test day. And to just kind of know that in those rooms, we really care about putting our best effort into knowing the rubric, applying the rubric fairly, and checking for anomalies, I think is one of those things that I think that I think teachers would want to know.
SPEAKER_00On that same line, what is the rubric reward that most classrooms don't explicitly teach? Is there something that we're not teaching that should be taught?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, actually, I think so on the English side of things, right? So the rubric for AP English has a thesis point, an evidence and commentary point, and a sophistication point. And a lot of times people call the sophistication point a unicorn, and I don't necessarily agree with that. I do think it's teachable. But the the the the points that are there in a history, it would be your complexity point, right? Yeah. Um, I do think that there are things in there that are teachable, even though the criteria are the criteria is a little nebulous in terms of the wording. There are specific things you can do. But one of the things that I think is not taught that should really be taught to help really build better writing on exam day and in general, is the importance of strong topic sentences that are derived from a thesis and then interrelate each paragraph of the essay. Because row B is just called the evidence and commentary row. However, a really strong topic sentence, whether you're writing about history or English, if it has transitional language, if it refers to the example that's about to come in more detail, and if it contains uh a relation to the argument that's in the thesis, every time you're establishing a line of reasoning, and that strong topic sentence will then direct the kid, oh, here was what you said your evidence was going to be. So that's the next part of your paragraph. And then that argument that's also in your topic sentence as well, that's what you got to connect the evidence to in your commentary. And if people are taught a stronger topic sentence, then kids wouldn't be able to establish better lines of reasoning, guaranteed, every time.
SPEAKER_00We call that an assertion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00It's basically it's topic sentence with a how or why, and it has to tie into the thesis and the overall structure and provide smooth transitions because that's like your line of reasoning. Like that everything should tie back to your assertion.
SPEAKER_02Right. And the the problem is though, is that when you look at just the rubric language, there that row B says it's called the evidence and commentary row. But you'll in AP English language and AP English literature, you'll see the phrase line of reasoning there. But that line of reasoning is really dictated by the topic sentence, but that's not in the rubric. And so it's one of those things to answer your question where you're like, well, what's what's what's not there that should be there? When people focus on the language of evidence and commentary, but they don't think about the idea of how the topic sentence directs that when it's tied to the thesis, that's where a lot of that line of reasoning breaks down, and people don't get their points.
SPEAKER_00Because you're not making an argument at that point. You're not actually structuring like a reasoned argument, and you're not so. I mean, that's literally how I teach the DBQ and the LEQ for history, because it's you have to build your argument with evidence, but you have to at least there has to be a common theme that runs through it. Otherwise, what are we talking about?
SPEAKER_02So and there has to be cohesion in why you're making point A and point B. Like I once had a student who was writing a paper and he wrote about Magellan, which was a great example, and then he wrote about Tom Brady. Um, and this is when he was deflating footballs or whatever. And the example worked great for the essay, but he didn't interconnect the two. He didn't say, hey, this is true not only in science, but also in menial sports entertainment. All he had to do in his next topic sentence was say, not only is this true for you know more serious things like scientific exploration, but it's also true when it comes to menial sports entertainment. That's all he had to do, but he didn't. He just went from Magellan to Tom Brady, and I was like, Well, there's your problem, bud. Um, and it's one of those things where it, you know, we then really focused on that topic and that transitional element to create the cohesion. And that's just that's just thought processes that kids don't necessarily know to have that we need to teach, not just assign.
SPEAKER_00I I like that. Yeah, we're uh we're on the same wavelength of writing. It's really, really cool. So do you think also I can say the most non-PC thing. I was just like, I my in my like when I was teaching 10 years ago, like through the process, I did see the writing D grade. The kids came to me 11th grade, first IB class, like every year. Not now to structure like worse and worse writing, even not a right topic sentences. But do you think AP writing instruction is getting better or more diluted over time? Just in general, from what you see on the PD side of things.
SPEAKER_02I think see, that's a hard question because we also have to think about the kids who we're having coming in, right? So kids have shorter thought, shorter actual thought processes. I'm not even talking about um, you know, distractability. I'm talking about actual thought processes, right? So I think that writing instruction, especially on the AP side, is becoming it's consistently becoming more deliberate. It used to be in the early 2000s, right? That the kids that were taking your AP class already knew how to write. And chances are they've been good writers since third grade. And it's kind of like this intuitive something, right? Now that there's this AP AP for all initiative, which really started picking up speed, probably in my mind, I started really noticing it in like 2010, let's say, where it was like, hey, let's actually try to tear down a lot of these gatekeepers. Um, you know, we're we now had to scaffold writing a little bit more. So I think that writing became less assigned and more intentional. But we also had an entire group of teachers who were used to assigning writing as opposed to teaching writing. So now I think we're finally moving towards the end where we have a lot of teachers who are ready to start teaching teaching writing to these kids that are in AP classes, but when we now have a demographic who has more choppy thought processes than they did in 2000. So it's one of those things where now that the teaching is getting better, I'm not saying the students are worse. I'm saying the students are different in their ability to process their own thoughts. And so now, what if we had the same kids in that that were taking this test in 2000 with the actual scaffolded writing instruction that we really focus on, that I do think is getting better. I mean, I really think that the kids that were already born going to Harvard would be like, oh, we're gonna go to Harvard and we're gonna make a new one on the moon, you know, like like and in and what they're able to do. Um, so the the question that you asked is a little bit um complex because I do think writing is getting better. Sorry, the instruction of writing is getting better, but we have to use that scaffold instruction to do more remediation than in the past. Um, for kids who are actually still intelligent, um, but just not as fluent or fluid with their ability to communicate their intelligence as they apply their arguments um or their analyses or things like that.
SPEAKER_00I love that. Yeah, that's uh good observation. It's like our thoughts are fleeting with how everything's been hijacked now with uh reels, TikToks, all that kind of stuff. I'm like I say, and that's the the thing with AI and the thing with our attention spans, like every every piece of information is out there. That literally kids can learn more now than any like you have the you have the ChatGPT, for example, could teach you, but if you don't want to evaluate the information you're getting, you know how to think critically. And kids don't even do that, right? It's not even worth getting there in terms of that.
SPEAKER_02And it it's almost like they don't even want to. And that's the part that I think is the is the scariest for me when I have a student who's like, I just don't want to do that. And I'm like, well, what do you want to do? And I once had a student say, just scroll on my phone. And I'm like, yeah, but do you realize that you're not gonna be able to just scroll on your phone for your job? Like, that's not like to be a productive member of society, and at some point, like I think about um I think it was Booker T. Washington who wrote about labor as being part of like humans' divine purpose, right? Um, he he had that he had that piece where he was like, put down your buckets where you are and and and kind of dig in. And unfortunately, I don't think that the majority, that the majority of students realize, oh, wait a second, if I put the labor in now, it'll actually allow me to do the kind of more leisurely things that I want to do later on in life when I'm an adult. And that's the problem because I have so many students who think that, oh, I'll take care of that when I'm an adult, I'll take care of that when I'm in college. And I tell them, if you don't have the discipline to do this now when you're living with your parents who care about your grades and are calling me and whatever, when you're at college and you have that video game system right here, and there's no one telling you to go to bed, and there's no one putting a time frame on it, you're not gonna just miraculously change. That's not how it works, you know? Um, same thing with critical thinking. And so these are the concerns that I see with my students, and I try to articulate to them. And one of the ways that I deal with that is I say, we're gonna read almost everything in class, and we're gonna write everything in class, and I'm gonna make sure that you're not on a computer while you're doing it. And then and then they they don't love it at first. Um, but it's funny because last year I had a student um in my who was a senior for me, and she asked me if she could handwrite her major fifth, like eight to fifteen page paper. And I was like, You want to handwrite that whole thing? She said, Absolutely. I I really don't want to do it any other way. And I was like, I'm in. I am in. So if she asked me to do it like tablets like Moses style, I would have let her do that too. The chisel and the stone, you know?
SPEAKER_00There you go. Take a little longer.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, before we get into rapid fire here to wrap this up, I will uh leave you with this something that my um accountability coach when I was building my business gave me. Uh and that's always stuck with me too. And kind of like when you're caught into this, I think something you could pass on to your students or anyone is that really you're either creating or you're consuming, right? We're either creating something, we're building towards something, which is it's what we're all humans are put on the planet for to create something, or we're engaged in consumption. And I think our youth right now are way that and not that consumption is always bad, right? We can still consume and enjoy, but everything in moderation, and I think that lever is way over on the consumption rather than actual creation. And so building critical thinkers is something I'm very passionate about too. So I it sounds like you are as well.
SPEAKER_02Well, I actually told my students this year, I said, look, it you are you are purposely by by culture, right? I said, you are purposely, and we were reading actually, sorry, but let me preface this. We were reading The Pedestrian by Ray Bradbury, which is what inspired um Fahrenheit 451, which is very much about consumer culture and whatnot. Right. And I said, You are being, I don't want to say the word groomed because I understand the connotations that come with that, but I'm like, you as a as a generation, you are being groomed to be functionally illiterate. And the reason why is because the more functionally illiterate you are, that doesn't mean that you can't read, you can read the sign, you can, you know, do these things, but the more functionally illiterate you are, particularly in terms of your deeper reading comprehension and your critical reading skills, the easier it is to make you more of a consumer. And the more of a consumer you consistently are, the more you are purposefully giving your money away to somebody else who decided to be a creator, who is not functionally illiterate, but knows that it's better if you are. And I'm not I'm not saying this to be like I hate capitalism or anything like that. No, if there are problems, people solve problems and they should be paid for that. I I enjoy that, right? But when we have when we see this problem of a actual promotion of functional illiteracy as the under the guise of entertainment, just so we can have more consumers to line someone's you know pockets, that's a scary thing. And I'm like, you have to realize that most people don't recognize this, and I want you to. Um, and that's why we have Fahrenheit 451 and and 1984 and Brave New World. Unfortunately, those books were supposed to be warnings, but it seems as though culture is using them as guidebooks, and that's the part that's scariest to me.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's why we can have the Congress could have the lowest approval rating of any branch of government, but yet almost all of them retain their seats. Yeah, we have there's other structural systematic issues there, but it's why we um, you know, is la power kind of begets power, like we want to stay in power and and you know, blaming someone else, causing something else to happen, giving someone else a reason, distraction, and just consume, consume, consume, and not if a nation of critical thinkers is really dangerous, yeah. Right. And and for people in power, that is like that. There are that might challenge the status quo. So um, yeah, it's uh it's great talking to you. I want to end with uh rapid fire and then allow you to uh promo some stuff as well if you're if you're gameplay. Oh, I'd love to. All right, Tim, just first thing that comes to mind no explanation necessary unless you want to. So rapid fire round. So most overrated writing advice.
SPEAKER_02Um, make kids write more. And I'm gonna give an explanation. I hope you don't hope you don't mind. And the reason why is because if kids are writing really crappy stuff and they just consistently write really crappy, yeah, nothing's getting fixed.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I gotcha.
SPEAKER_02One thing students overthink in their AP essays the sophistication point, because that's only worth one point, and the they can get five points by having a good thesis and strong evidence and commentary. And so that one other point actually is statistically not even it doesn't even factor into getting a four or five for almost every person that scores one.
SPEAKER_00I said that. I said, like, uh I love L EQ and BBQ. I'm like, get five points before you go for the six. Like make sure you have all the five elements.
SPEAKER_02So one thing they underthink the importance of using the word because in their commentary. Because so, so, so most so most of the time kids is kids project their commentary as fact, right? And they and they basically say, so it's obvious that this is the case. It's not obvious. You put the word because at the end of that sentence, and that will for that will force them to try to understand the assumptions that they bring to the table to articulate their inference. Or any cause and effect language, because, since, consequently, right uh, due to the fact that, so that, therefore, anything like that.
SPEAKER_00Best place to earn easy points on the AP Lang exam.
SPEAKER_02Uh, the thesis point is low-hanging fruit. I once heard it described that it hangs so low that sometimes it grows on the ground and it's actually moldy. The easiest points to earn are there. Um, and then if you can even just produce a summary of evidence, you know, you'll get at least one point in Roby. Oh, one other one. Synthesis essay in particular. Um, make sure that you cite at least three sources to get above a one on Roby, because they're up to four points. And you can't get a two, three, or four unless there are three sources that are cited, and kids sometimes overlook that.
SPEAKER_00Nice, nice. And then uh one sentence every AP student should hear in August or September when they're starting their journey.
SPEAKER_02Writing. No, good writing is rewriting, and good writing, good writing is precision writing.
SPEAKER_00So that's two. Love it. That's okay. Okay, cool. Well, Tim, I appreciate it. I know you just moved across the country, you're starting like new school, you got all kinds of things going on, and it's almost the start of AP season. So I appreciate you carving out a little bit of time to make time for this podcast. Um if uh people are interested in learning more about what you do and want to find you, like can you share anything with our audience uh of where to find you?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So can I actually tell you what I what I have that could probably service them too, or no?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no problem. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_02So uh you can go to thegarden ofenglish.com. Uh that's much more like teacher-based, though. Um there is stuff that students can access there as well. Um, but that's much more like, hey, how do you contact us for professional development? Or I have a files and resources page where almost all of the resources are free. Not all of them, but almost all of them. Um if you want to look for a lot of free resources that I have, is I have um YouTube videos for AP Lit and AP Lang. Um I have playlists on both of those for how to write each type of essay and each part of every type of essay. And honestly, if you watch a playlist, it goes, it goes all the way from how to break down a prompt, how to write a thesis, how to write topic sentences, how to write evidence, how to write commentary, how to write conclusions for every type of essay there. So um YouTube is a great place to find Garden of English stuff. And I ask that people just tell their friends because AP Lang is the largest um AP exam, right? But we have we have 32,000 subscribers, and yeah, I go over to my dear friend Heimler, who's got like a million subscribers in the AP histories, and I'm like, the AP histories aren't as big as AP Lang. How come I can't get a couple of those of those subscribers here?
SPEAKER_00You know, come on, if one likes social studies more than English.
SPEAKER_02Honestly, right? Um no, it's it's true. And actually, for us, our content are our skills, and I I understand that. It's not one of those things where I can say, I know that this is what's going on.
SPEAKER_00Um I think it's the free, it's the four. So we're well, the five biggest, right? So it's Lang, US, uh, world. Is Lit still up there?
SPEAKER_02Um, I think Lit has actually moved to five or six. Um because I think bio, I think bio jumped in.
SPEAKER_00Bio is going up. Yeah. Psych is getting up there too. More and more kids are taking psych. So okay. Yeah, we're we're in the top, so it's the most, but it's um yeah. Uh what anything else?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, sorry. There's there's one other thing that I want to actually just share is that um one of one of the few things that Garden of English sells, right? Because normally we do workshops for teachers and we do professional development, but one of the few things that we actually sell to teachers and to students is called length support. And that's actually an interface that we built where I made videos that deal with all of the content for the course and exam description for each unit. And then there are 20 multiple choice questions to practice with. There are two practice exams that you can actually take and self-score and self-evaluate with. Um, I had students write samples and I put scoring commentary in there so you know exactly why these essays scores score what they are. Um and there's just a lot in there for kids. And a lot of times kids are like, I want to do, I want to get like a five steps to a five, or I want to do Albert I.O. or I want to do a lot of these other things. Well, first of all, we're a really small business, right? And so we appreciate what, you know, uh any support that we can get. But on top of that, like, I don't know that this could be more comprehensive. And then for the teachers, we paired up with my dear friend Beth Hall from Coach Hall Rights, who's like another uh lead YouTuber for AP English language. And we even provided courses for how to teach rhetorical analysis, how to teach synthesis, how to teach argument. And so the price for what those do is very, very low for everything that's in there. Um for the student, for the student stuff, there's over three hours of videos for them to help learn their AP content and there are worksheets for them and everything like that. And it's like 20 bucks. And and then for teachers with eight hours, sorry, she had five. I think there are, I think there are over eight hours of video in total for about teaching AP Lang, and they can give out my videos for their kids to for the test studying and the multiple choice and everything. It's like 125 bucks a year, or they could buy it outright for 300 bucks. Or sorry, for sorry, they could buy it outright for 350 bucks, and then they never have to pay again, you know. So we really tried to make this affordable because we put she and I put over 2,000 hours a piece into what we do. And it's one of those things where it's like we can't give it away for free, but we can try to give it away for something that I think is of a significant value. And you know, as an administrator, when you're buying educational resources, a lot of times that price gets jacked up, and that's just not how we roll. We serve, we serve teachers, we serve students. That's what we do, and that's what we want to do. Uh, but we also have to make sure that you know I've got I've got five kids, I gotta pay for five kids. And so that's one of the ways and a private school teaching job, it's fine, but it's not gonna pay for all the five. Um entirely. Uh especially if I wanted my wife to stay home. So those are just things that I wanted to just point out. And um, you know, um, if it's okay to put that out out there, that's great.
SPEAKER_00No, if you absolutely we'll uh we'll discuss after recording this too about how we can also help promote you. So but Tim, I appreciate you very much for being on. Um thank you so much. Good luck this year, the rest of the school year. Enjoy Las Vegas, enjoy the sun. Uh it's one of my I got married, I eloped in Vegas with my wife. We have three kids, but uh but yeah, yeah, absolutely. So um enjoy it because I'm very envious of the uh vitamin D you're getting where I'm still thank you so much. Thank you all for joining us on another episode. We'll see you next time. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.