SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 74 - ex-UPenn Admissions Officer: Why Your Kid's Perfect Application Gets Rejected - Jayson Weingarten
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Jayson Weingarten, senior consultant at Ivy Coach and a former assistant director of admissions at the University of Pennsylvania, where he evaluated thousands of applications and took part in the confidential committee deliberations behind Ivy League decisions.
Dr. Joe and Jayson discuss how applications actually move through reading and selection and why most receive only single-digit minutes of attention, why one individual reader often becomes a student's sole advocate in committee, why Ivy Coach argues for a well-lopsided applicant rather than a well-rounded one and what a genuine singular hook looks like in practice, how early decision helps strategic applicants and does nothing for unqualified ones, why being described as hard working in a recommendation letter can work against a student, and why the phrase passion project is among the clearest signals of an over-engineered application.
This episode is especially useful for families targeting highly selective schools, parents of students building activity profiles, and anyone trying to understand what actually happens after the application is submitted.
📲 Connect with them: https://www.ivycoach.com/
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@Ivycoach
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. What if you could to sit in a room where Ivy League emissions decisions actually get made? Jason Weigarden doesn't have to have to imagine it. He was the assistant director of emissions at UPenn, where he sat in the confidential committee debates that decide who gets in. Today he's pulling back the curtain on what actually happens in that room and what every high-achieving family needs to know. Welcome back to the Supported Learning Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars and years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people who have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. And that's why I'm thrilled to have Jason here today. Jason is a senior consultant and Ivy coach, one of the most well-known elite emission firms in the world. But what makes Jason genuinely different is his background. He is a UPenn undergrad, a warden MBA, and holds a master's in education, and served as the assistant director of emissions at UPenn, where he personally evaluated thousands of applications and sat in the confidential committee debates that decide Ivy League acceptances. We're going to dive into what actually happens in those committee rooms, why well-roundedness might actually be hurting your kid, and what high-achieving families should be doing differently. Jason, welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_00It's great to be here and to share a little bit of knowledge with everyone.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. So kind of giving them the highlight reel, but if you mind just starting off as we ask all of our guests, kind of break down who you are and what specific problem in education you solve for families.
SPEAKER_00So my background, as I said, is professionally having spent countless years in admissions, reading applications, helping to make the decisions, also having a degree in higher education as well as an MBA. I think that for me, the big problem that I'm solving for families is one of helping them tell their story about their child. I think that too many families are trying to do a little bit of everything. They're trying to spread their child way too thin on so many different pursuits, rather than figuring out and really distilling what makes their student stand out. How in a sea of tens of thousands of applications, their student is going to be memorable, is going to be compelling, is going to clearly articulate a reason of why they should be admitted to that incoming class.
SPEAKER_01So let's start with the UPenn experience because most people in the industry haven't actually been in that room. You served as an assistant director of emissions at UPenn. Walk us through what that actually meant day to day. What were you doing?
SPEAKER_00So the job of an admissions officer is very cyclical. There is a time of the year, usually kind of late summer through the fall, that it is recruiting season and you are on the road, you are putting on events, you are evangelizing the school, meeting with families and counselors and everyone in between. Then there is usually a portion of the year, depending on whether the school is doing an early application process or just a regular application process, but it really turns into an evaluation, uh, reading through the applications that might be from your region, that might be aligned to an undergraduate program that you oversee. Then there is a selection phase, kind of the month leading into decision release, um, where the applicants are not just read, but they are discussed, they are evaluated, and students really have their ultimate fates made. And then the final season of the year is the uh matriculation season. So helping all the students that have been admitted to learn more about the school, whatever last thing that they need need to know in order to realize whether this is or is not the school where they will be successful during their four-year undergraduate campaign. Um, and to help them get to that May 1st common decision release uh decision deadline of selling the schools where they want to matriculate. Um, you know, then it's obviously summer, a little bit of break and then back at it again. And because there are the current, you know, rising seniors and then the students that are kind of you know further after them, some of these timelines do overlap uh and stretch out. Uh, but really there is, you know, kind of a very seasonal, very cyclical job in the admissions office, depending on what part of the calendar we're at.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01So what was it like? So, first off, you know, you graduated from UPenn double, right? So undergrad and as an MBA. And then you get to sit in the committee room deciding who comes into this prestigious university. What was the first time like when you sat in that meeting room? And what was different about the experience than what people probably imagine?
SPEAKER_00I think the biggest difference that really shocks a lot of families when they find out is that there's really not a lot of time spent on every application. Um, you know, the number of applications that are coming into these schools have pretty much doubled in the past 15, 20 years or so. The number of people reading these applications has not doubled, let alone tripled in some cases. Uh, maybe there's a few extra people around, but they're really the staffs have not grown. And so when you have an increasing numerator of how many students need to have their application read, and you have a pretty stable denominator of how many application readers there are, you end up with a lot of applications read increasingly quickly. And so most schools are spending single-digit minutes on an application. They're not spending 10, 15, 20, 30 an hour reading and reviewing and really getting to know every little nook and cranny detail of a student. It is a fast-paced process. And every school is trying to eke out any sort of operational efficiency that they can in the process and really just get through the applications and not necessarily seeing applications as representative of individual students, but rather just seeing them as pieces of paper and folders, digital folders that need to be gone through. And so keeping that in mind that applications are read so quickly, it's important that students have a compelling answer when they're read when they're writing all of the essays, that they keep things very clear and very consistent, that you don't try and kind of upset the reading flow of an application reader. They don't have time to be kind of pulled off of their regular rhythm. It's all about telling your story quickly, efficiently, and compellingly.
SPEAKER_01And after all of that, the UP admission or uh UPenn admissions, excuse me, Wharton MBA, the master's in education, what made you move into the consulting side at Ivy Coach?
SPEAKER_00So when I was working at the admissions office and getting a master's degree also in higher ed, I was realizing kind of increasingly that if I were to stick on campus and really continue on the path in academia, that by the time that I was going to end up as some sort of president or provost or some sort of dean of sorts, that the campus that it was just going to be very different and that some of the trends that colleges were seeing were not necessarily going to be the ones that I wanted to eventually kind of be on top of and oversee and deal with. You know, I realized that a big part of what I really like about education, that what I really like about college admissions, I was be able to still scratch that itch by helping families on the other side of the proverbial desk. Um, and so it really was at that point that I decided to uh move from the admissions officer side of the table and move over to the more college counseling side of the table. Um, you know, at that point, I didn't want to work for a school. I really wanted to work a lot more closely with a smaller number of families and a smaller number of students to really understand them, get to know them, so I could really be providing them uh, you know, kind of that exclusive specific advice that so many families do need.
SPEAKER_01So you've like you've been on obviously on the committee room. If we can get deep dive into that, like be honest, when an Ivy League committee opens up an application, what are they actually looking for in the first 30 seconds?
SPEAKER_00So I think the the first thing is that it's very rare that an entire committee will open an application or that they will review together every aspect of the application. Um, you know, there's two main workflows, if you will, that applications go through. The first is a lot more of kind of the old traditional way, which there's one individual reader who reads the entire application cover to cover. They make a temporary initial decision on that application. There may be second readers, there may be some professor experts or others that kind of read an application or have the opportunity to look through an application at full and leave their notes. But that one individual is sometimes the only person that reads the application. If they then get to a subcommittee or a full committee process, they then are that single reader, the person who is evangelizing the student and really talking up that student and really advocating for that student in the committee process. And so individual members of the committee, yes, they could read the application, but oftentimes, more often than not, they really are reliant on that one first reader to talk about the student and really advocate for the student. And then if there is like a few one-off questions or you know, people have curiosity from the committee, they're able to, you know, look through, do some searches and try and get the answer to a lingering question that they have. Um, you know, I think what is you know always looked for in an application really is, you know, one, that a student is academically prepared and academically qualified to attend the school, um, you know, making sure that, especially at the highest, uh most highly selective schools, that a student is not going to come in and need some sort of remedial help, that a student has taken the most demanding courses at the high school, has achieved good grades in those most demanding courses, does have the test scores, despite what a lot of schools um kind of use as innuendo to talk about tests optional and test flexible and all that marketing and PR spin. But they're really first and foremost looking for that academic preparedness. They're looking for students that are uniquely qualified to make an impact, to ideally proactively utilize the resources that a school has and use those in a way that is going to put them on a path to making that impact in changing the world in one very specific way, or making an impact in a smaller portion of the world, a small subfield or industry that eventually, when the student is looking back on their career, is going to bring a lot of great value and prestige and kind of that warmness back to the school by way of just being associated with the university or through more kind of direct alumni giving and financial support.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I often tell families that come into our program for like AP support, you know, and they're looking at an Ivy League school, their their goalposts are sometimes too short. I think a lot of families, and and you know, especially with the culture of today, a lot of families, the finish line is getting into an Ivy League school. When I often say the people that are accepting you are not looking. They're looking at what are you going to do after you get out of school? Is that the right assessment to give to families?
SPEAKER_00That's I think that's right. I mean, at the end of the day, the job of an admissions officer is not to coronate kings and queens. It's not to give out trophies and ribbons and accolades, but it's to provide the university with an input. Who are those 1600, 1200, 2500, whatever the incoming class is? Who what is that incoming class of students that is going to be better than last year and is going to contribute to the university, both during the four years of undergraduate, but then also through lifetime association?
SPEAKER_01What's the biggest disconnect between what colleges tell families publicly and what actually drives the decision in the room?
SPEAKER_00I think that a lot of times schools, especially maybe we'll call it from 2018 through 2021, 2022, kind of that five years around 2020. You know, they really continue to see how do we get more and more students to apply. It's why so many of them join the Common App. It's why so many of them cut down on the essay lengths of their supplements or cut down on the number of questions on the essays. It's why so many of them encourage students to still apply, even if they have a blemish or two or three or four in various different ways. Um, you know, schools, you know, they are at some level almost, you know, creating commercials like the state lottery is creating commercials that, hey, you're not gonna win if you don't play. Someone's gonna win. Why can't it be you? And the fact of the matter is, is that by creating some level of artificial hope, by kind of not being super honest about the importance of the academics, of the test scores, of what call of what really motivates uh colleges and the role that that individual uh specificity and that pointiness and that uniqueness uh really requires, given how many students colleges, you know, quote unquote have to take that are not well lopsided. I think that they really do a disservice by you know providing a false sense of security and a false sense of hope for too many students that really don't have um you know any shot of earning admission, um, but really just kind of are somehow told by colleges to throw their name into the hat and see if the roulette ball lands on red.
SPEAKER_01And Ivy Coach is famous for well-lopsidedness over well-roundedness. For a parent who's listening, who spent years building a balanced profile for their kid, what is actually wrong with that approach?
SPEAKER_00So, what's wrong with that approach is really strictly with how college admissions works. So, of course, there's, you know, a reason that any parent would want their teenager to have a multitude and a breadth of experiences. Um, you know, it helps young people grow up to be contributing members of society. It helps teenagers grow into healthy, well-adjusted adults. The virtues of being creative with music and the arts, the virtues of being physically active, strategy with a team, all of that through sports. That is 100% true for making good, well-adjusted members, contributing members of society. But colleges, they're looking for students who are going to be strong applicants and are going to be strong future alumni. And they want students that are going to really move the needle and make an impact in a specific field. Of course, you know, there's many students that come in and they switch majors and they do this and that. But I'd argue that students that come in and switch majors, um, you know, they do have and they have shown the opportunity and the ability to make an impact. It's just that they've chosen a different field now of where they're going to make an impact because maybe they didn't have full breadth of opportunity based on the resources and availabilities at their high school or in their town or community. And so what really ends up happening is that colleges are looking to fill a lot of spots in the way of like filling a lot of roles, that they need someone who's going to be this role and someone who's going to be that role. Um, you know, the student who is shooting 90% plus from the free throw line is very different than the student who's pipe heading into test tubes in the labs in the life science lab is very different than the student who's doing archaeological work, is very different than the student getting involved with town and gown relationships and social justice issues. And so by trying to do a little bit of everything as a student, you don't necessarily as cleanly fit into one of the roles in what the college admissions really is trying to cast students into being.
SPEAKER_01So what does a singular hook actually look like for a real kid? Can you give us an example?
SPEAKER_00Sure. So a singular hook for a student really comes down to a point of view in the world, an issue that matters to that student, and how they're hoping to make a mark. Now, it is a point of view that maybe could be shared by many people, or maybe is not shared by many people, but ultimately it is a clear point of view in how something should be or how something is. You know, for example, there is a student we worked with who is very interested in material science, specifically about cardboard. You know, we can all imagine the problem of how many boxes, cardboard boxes, fly through the mail to deliver all of the packages that we all order online. And the student was concerned that, you know, had the point of view that, hey, you know, the increasing reliance on online shopping is leading to more and more cardboard. And that's creating more and more trash and more and more issues with the landfill and pollution. And, you know, we need a better form of cardboard. I want to be the student that is able to engineer better cardboard that is going to be less pollutive and less problematic for the world. Now, does this student invent better cardboard? Maybe, maybe not. Did this student uh, you know, win any sort of science fair or anything like that? You know, maybe, maybe not. It doesn't matter. What matters is that they have a very clear point of view that they want to invent better cardboard to improve online shipping for all the boxes that we all receive. That is, you know, kind of that angular hook. Now, did the student also do, you know, some of the robotics and some of the Lego stuff and on the Science Olympiad and all that? You know, yes, because that is what engineering, STEM, that side of the brain students have available to them. But more important than whatever awards and accolades, whatever activities they did that many students will do, is their point of view that they were interested in solving this problem, making a mark, and that they were collecting different experiences that were all pointing in that same direction for how they would change the world, how they would change maybe this small slice of the world, the slice of the world that is online shipping.
SPEAKER_01So that is pretty interesting. The fascination with cardboard. The uh early decision, like families hear about it, few understand it. What is the truth? When does it actually help? And when is it a trap?
SPEAKER_00It really can only help students if they are strategic with how they approach it. So every school that releases their data clearly shows a preference for students that are applying early decision just by the sheer admissions metrics. Schools are taking now more than half of their incoming classes through binding or non-binding early application programs. Schools are adding early decisions when it's something like Michigan as a public school adding it on, or the University of Chicago adding this ED zero program for students that have done one of their summer programs. So more and more schools are relying on early more and more. They're coming up with new ways to provide that earlier access. Um, you know, it is a win-win. For the schools, it's a win because if it's a binding program, they know that they're if they have an incoming cohort of students that loves their school, that wants to be at their school, that is going to thrive and be successful at their school. A group of students that doesn't have the chip on their shoulder that they didn't get into school X and so now they're ending up at school Y. It also just from the admissions standpoint helps to spread out when applications are read. You can imagine if you have to sort through that, you know, two, three X number of applications this year than you had 10, 15 years ago, it's a lot more helpful if you receive more of those applications to read in November and December than if you really only have January, February, and March to review those applications. And so there's reasons for school that they want to do it. For students, you know, again, it's clear the better admissions odds that you have is something to. Really consider and take advantage of. Now, what that does not mean is being an underqualified student and thinking that you can somehow just squeak by and throw an application, and now you have twice the odds of getting in than you did if you applied regular. I mean, for many students that have no chance of earning admission in regular, they also have a chance that is slim to none in the early round. And so for students that can be honest with themselves and think strategically about how to apply early decision, it really is only to their benefit. And certainly at IV Coach, we encourage all of our families to apply somewhere early to get those applications in because you want to strike when the odds are ever in your favor.
SPEAKER_01And talk a little bit about red flags. Like, you know, they're talking about a strategic narrative correction, but what is a red flag? Most parents don't even realize they're putting on their kids' application.
SPEAKER_00A red flag, I think that it's, I mean, there's I think the biggest red flag and maybe the biggest backhand accomplishment. It's not something that students put themselves on their application, but it's when students are overly described in recommendations from the teachers and the counselors as hardworking. I mean, colleges, they want students that learning comes naturally and that they're able to do well on a test, an assignment, whatever it is, with grace and with ease. Um, they don't want students who have to grind it out for every single assignment, for every single project. Are there going to be times in every student's career in college when you're gonna have to stay up all night in the library and just get through it? Of course. But those need to be the exceptions and not the rule. And when students are giving off a sense that they are hardworking and that they are just grinding through it, um, that really is a big turnoff. It sounds like such a nice compliment. Oh, you know, little twent Timmy is so hardworking, but for most admissions officers, it's actually a horrible backhand compliment.
SPEAKER_01That's interesting. This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focused on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supportedtutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. So you talked a little bit about test optional, but like you know, we've we've seen Stanford not only move away from test optional, but now require AP exam scores if they have APs on their transcript. I believe you of Chicago is following suit this year, but what's the real story from the Ivy Leagues and from your seat as an Ivy coach? Like, what is is test optional even really a thing anymore? I know it's still out there, but just where are we at with it?
SPEAKER_00Test optional, I think we'll look back at the, especially the during the pandemic era as a huge lie that was promulgated by these schools. It is impossible to teach these old dogs new tricks. These schools, they don't you don't get the ivory tower moniker without being some of the slowest to move and adapt places of all time. And so this idea that schools were suddenly going to be able to not need test scores, that they wouldn't even look at the test scores, don't worry, just apply without the test scores. It started out of a good place that these schools didn't want students for whom actually sitting for any sorts of exams would be impossible just due to the realities of the pandemic. They didn't want those students not to apply, but they caught too many dolphins in their net of students who thought that they could get by without having any test scores or had such bad test scores that they wanted to, you know, skirt by without sending those scores in. High achieving students with high test scores had every advantage over students that may have been just as high achieving on various other metrics, but did not send their test scores. The few schools, I'm thinking Georgetown, Cornell, that regularly released their data on the statistics for students who did and did not submit test scores, clearly showed a preference for students who did submit test scores. And of course, having higher test scores was ultimately what was in a student's best, was best for students. Colleges have been increasingly relying on the AP exams, especially as the SAT twos, the SAT subject tests have gone away. The college board amid the pandemic made the decision to retire the subject tests. And so a lot of colleges, they want to be able to evaluate what an A in chemistry means for a given student at that score, at that school. And by having the AP exam, they're able to compare and contrast students across that national, that national and international playing field. And so schools, they do need test scores. They want test scores. Of course, every school is going to have slightly different nuances of their testing policy. But when in doubt, students should be submitting their test scores. They should be taking test prep, the SAT, the ACT, the AP exams incredibly seriously because it still is an important metric that these old dogs are using to evaluate students.
SPEAKER_01So you said the hardworking thing about putting that on the application, but what about targeting these top schools? What's the number one mistake families make when they're looking to go into an Ivy League or other schools in the top 10?
SPEAKER_00I think the biggest mistake students make or families make is trying to do things that they think will be impressive to most highly selective schools or writing about things in a way that it it gives an air of bragging. I mean, colleges want students that do things effortlessly, that are not bragging. Bragging just makes students unlikable. If you think that it's very impressive that you scored first place out of 593 people in the county on whatever exam, you know, that's just unnecessary bragging. It's better just to say, you know, first place, you know, first in the county. That extra little bit is just trying too hard. And there's nothing that admissions officers hate more than when they get a sense that a student is just trying too hard. Because if you're trying too hard about this, what else are you trying too hard about? And then we get to back to the hardworking and over engineering and application part that colleges just don't want. Um, you know, it's it's the students that are most like themselves, that carry with them that quiet confidence. Um, those are the students that really resonate for admissions officers and really are compelling to admissions officers. Ultimately, most admissions officers, um, you know, they are people that you want to get to for them to like you. And doing things that are make you unlikable is not something that you should be doing in your college application. Again, you only have a few minutes to make that first impression. And if your first impression is this is an overzealous, braggadocious kid, then you're just not going to be earning admission.
SPEAKER_01What about the well-intentioned parents who are just too involved? What's that look like in the application and what damage does it do?
SPEAKER_00So ultimately, admissions officers read enough essays that they can tell when it is the voice of a teenager versus when it's the voice of someone who's middle-aged, or even when it's the voice of, you know, a computer and AI and just how that's you know slowly taken over. And so I think it's the role that parents can best play is to be that net underneath their student, you know, really being there to, you know, catch a student and support a student, uh, jump in when need be, uh, making sure that their students are staying on track and on time, not waiting till 11.59 to hit submit the day before the application is due, but really there to support their student and make sure a student stays on track. And I think that the second most important thing that a parent can do is just really be honest with their student. Um, you know, when I was getting a my master's in education, I was at odds with nearly everyone else in my program because I did not believe at the time, and I still don't believe, that everyone needs to go to college. I mean, the the any time you say that everyone needs to do something, that's probably not correct. And the idea that everyone needs to go to a top school, the most highly selective school, or any sort of college in order to contribute to society seems foolish. And so I think if parents can realize the, you know, what is best for their child and the likelihood of admission for their child, if you know that your student has a bunch of B's, is not creeping over 1500 or a 34 on the ACT, you know, doesn't really have any phenomenal extracurriculars, you know, encouraging our student to apply to the Ivy League schools where they really don't have a shot of admission is just ultimately not going to be in a student's best interest. And that's really only setting up a student for failure. And so parents really should be honest with their students, still gentle in cases, but really honest with a student about the likelihood of earning admission and really narrowing in a student into what is an appropriate set of schools to even put in that time and energy and effort into applying to.
SPEAKER_01So kind of going into that, be honest, like, you know, you obviously you've done this for a while. You've been a part of every part of the Ivy League journey, but when is paid consultancy, like paid college coaching, actually worth it? And when are families just buying anxiety relief?
SPEAKER_00So unfortunately, I think that for most students, applying to top, you know, targeting top 50, top 100 schools, um, you know, it's worth it. Unfortunately, you know, in the year 2026, too many schools, public schools especially, have cut the counseling that they're giving to students. We hear about the caseloads of a lot at a lot of schools that have ballooned from like one to a two dozen students to now 50, 100 plus students. Uh, and a lot of times students are just not getting that kind of support that they really need in order to navigate this kind of increasingly complex process. I'd even argue that a lot of, you know, a selective private high schools, you know, a lot of times the college counselor, they're really looking out for the best interests of the private school. They're really looking out for the health of the overall graduating class and not the individual student. I've seen too many times where a college counselor, you know, just started to undersell a student or not really help a top high flyer achieve that kind of top high flyer admission and really kind of have everything go to a lowest common denominator in a well-intentioned attempt to raise up some of the stragglers and strugglers up to some good level. No college counselor wants uh to end up with some students getting completely shut out of anywhere. And so I think for a lot of students that are aiming for that top 50, top 100 area, it becomes important for them to really have someone as their advocate and someone providing that advice that is really tailored to them individually and that they can really rely on as they go through the process.
SPEAKER_01Is there a secret to get it into an IVLEA school?
SPEAKER_00There is certainly not a secret, or if there was a secret, it is out there already. I mean, I do not believe in the moon landing hoax. I don't think that amount of people could be in some sort of Hollywood studio and faking it for that long. Word would have gotten out by now. If you think about just how many dozens of colleges are out there with their process, how many, what the turnover is, had some of these schools with admissions officers leaving and, you know, kind of starting to do what I do, the secret would be out there by now if there were a secret. And so there really isn't a secret, you know, other than students that are, you know, to be as academically prepared and qualified as possible, for students to be as singularly talented as possible, and for students to come off as likable, compelling, and have that clear, concise point of view that makes admissions officers want to root for them in the process.
SPEAKER_01What's a common piece of good advice you'd wish families would stop following?
SPEAKER_00I think there's a lot of keeping up with the Joneses. I think a lot of times families will see that, you know, the neighbor's kid did X and got into college, and their friend from work's kid did Y and got into the good college, and that older kid in high school did Z and got into the good college. And so if my kid does X plus Y plus Z, like they have to get in. And doing X plus Y plus Z only makes that student more well-rounded. It's not the college student families don't realize that the student who focused on X got in because they were the student that was going to change the world of X in that one specific way, or the other student was going to change Y in that specific way. And so I think unfortunately there's a lot of keeping up with the Joneses. There's a lot of thinking that I need to do a little bit of everything. Um, and then there's also a lot of conflation, I think, with what really is different and unique and stands out, and what just is um, you know, kind of branded as, you know, um amazing. But you know, if everyone's doing something that's amazing, it doesn't become amazing anymore. I mean, the the millions of students that are in the National Honor Society, I mean, it says national, it says honor society, that's another good word. But there's millions of students that are in National Honor Society, and that in and of itself is not something that is going to get someone into a highly selective school.
SPEAKER_01I'm going to give you three buzzwords that I know you heard. Tell me which one, if any, moves the needle on college admissions while we're talking about diluting the pool.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Passion projects, research, internships.
SPEAKER_00That is anytime someone says the word passion project, that to me is like a huge red flag that the parents, especially, are trying to over-engineer an application and do something that just seems impressive. That is, I mean, maybe that should have been my answer for the biggest red flag. When I'm meeting with families and they introduce something that a student is doing because it's their passion project, oh my gosh, that is red flag city.
SPEAKER_01I I just recorded some content in my car. I haven't posted it yet, but I was just talking about. So, like, literally have a family. They were and we're they were talking about college admissions and they want to go BSMD or Ivy League. And she is a rising scene, she's a rising senior. So she's like literally coming into college admissions, looking for college admissions programs. It's June. And they're talking about starting a passion project. And I was like, here, here's here's $30,000 worth of advice right now. Don't. Because the first question that they're gonna ask, why did you wait till your senior year to start your passion, to start anything you're passionate about? And I basically drew like, I say, you know what?
SPEAKER_00I'm passionate about so passionate, suddenly they woke up one day.
SPEAKER_01Suddenly, six months before you submitted your application. Not even. That's amazing. I go, you know, I'm passionate about model railroading. I am 38 years old. My father put up a train around my crib when I was six months, and I have loved trains from that moment. I've collected trains my entire life. If I could be paid a high performing salary to just do model training, that's what I would be doing. That's what I'm at, but that is it's it's compounded over time and it's not artificially created. And there are so many programs out there just selling manufactured passion projects at a very high premium, which I'm sure you're aware of. It doesn't sound like Ivy Coach advises that.
SPEAKER_00No, I mean, we uh like the one individual passion project, I kind of curl just you know, saying the words. I mean, that's not going to earn a student admission. I mean, yes, it's helpful if you have a few different things, a few different pursuits that all point into that one point of view, that one hook, that one, you know, singular talented narrative. But, you know, I find that too often students are well-rounded and they do that one passion project that they think is gonna like push them over the line. And the fact is that you know, not every student, not every child in Africa needs tennis rackets. I'm I'm sorry. That's that there's too many passion projects that are that.
SPEAKER_01And it's not even like connected to any. That's why I like it's so it's like they don't even hear it, but I think it's I think it is one keeping up with the Joneses. I'm sure we've served very similar audiences or series, very similar clientele, like with a lot of families from India, a lot of families that immigrated from Southeast Asia, and they're well-meaning, but it's brand chasing and it's name-dropping, and it's like one-upping each other in a lot of cases. And they don't understand, and I I've explained a position like this. I'm like, listen, I had a kid in my school, you know, he unfortunately had cancer, lost his leg, had a B amputee, a bone marrow cancer at ninth grade. Literally didn't let that affect his attitude. Probably the most positive kid. I mean, he's done everything, like multiple makes a wish, like been to the Super Bowl, local sports teams have treated him great. But when he when that happened to him, he turned that into an opportunity to help other kids and started raising money for kids in similar circumstances. That turned into a naturally a nonprofit, a charity that he still runs to this day, even though he's in college. I'm like, even though that the intention behind it is authentic. That is truly, and even though it's only in high school, that's truly passionate. I like that that is something that isn't we're doing this because it's I'm doing this and it's something that helps me stand out. It's a spike strategy rather than just manufactured. What do you say about that's right? What do you say about internships or research projects?
SPEAKER_00I think they're fine, but not for everyone. I mean, the idea that everyone needs to be doing this, that, the other, that only makes students more well-rounded. There are plenty of um, you know, the hooks where having an internship makes sense or doing a research project makes sense, uh, but there's many more where it does not. Part of my job in helping to advise students is to figure out what's from the kind of broad cornucopia that's available to students is going to make sense for where they live, what they're interested in. And it's not the case that the same one thing has to be there for every single student. Is it great when students are able to have an internship? Sure. But it's also great when students are able to found a nonprofit or get very involved in their own high school's leadership and student government, or when a student's able to start their own um, you know, local issue or able to do something. It, you know, not everyone, again, needs to be doing the same thing, and there's not one magic activity. If there was that magic activity, if there was that secret thing that you could do, that's that handshake that's going to get you in, you know, we would know it by now. And everyone would be doing it. There's no way that this many people could keep the secret. And so is an internship, is a research project, is that like the secret thing? No. Is it good for this for some students? Yes. Is it good for every student? Of course not.
SPEAKER_01For a parent out there that's a child, eighth, ninth, tenth grade, or even maybe in 11th grade, what's something that they should be doing differently than they were doing five years ago?
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of time this is maybe more for middle school. You know, I think of middle school as that kind of back to school shopping time where we've all been, you know, dragged, if you're like me, to the mall by your mom and you're, you know, taken to the store, and it's time to pick some back to school outfits. And you kind of have to, you know, try on a bunch of different clothes and see what fits and what color and the style and all of that. Um, and you try on a bunch of clothes before you ultimately decide on a few new outfits for the school year. Now, do you have to try on every single outfit, every single article of clothing in the store? No. You kind of already know if there's certain colors that you know are just not for you, or there's certain styles that are just not for you. But you you should still try on a bunch of things. And so I think that for students that are in eighth, ninth grade, um, you know, trying out a few different things to start to narrow what uh what you know a student's passion can be, what a student's interest hook can be, I think is important. But that being said, you don't need to try on every single thing and you don't need to try everything. If you already know that you do not like blood and you get squeamish, you know, maybe anything in Dr. World is not for you. And so I think that's Trying on these outfits, um, you know, so to speak, is something that most students that are in seventh, eighth grade can do. And it's something that's different than you know, five, 10 years ago, just because the opportunities that exist for students that are that young that you know just hit double digits, you know, 12, 13 years of age, there's just more opportunities that have trickled down into that age demographic.
SPEAKER_01All right. Let's move into lightning round. We'll just have some rapid fire questions. First thing that comes to mind, all right, to round this out. Uh, most overrated college admissions advice right now.
SPEAKER_00I think being being well-rounded, or you might as well apply. Most overrated extracurricular. I think model UN.
SPEAKER_01One thing parents overthink in the process.
SPEAKER_00Uh the over overthink, I think, is overindexing on the comments in the common cards or thinking that that's going to like make or break college admissions. Uh, you know, colleges receive grades on the transcripts, they rarely receive the full commentary. And if they were to get the full common cards, they're not spending the time to read those.
SPEAKER_01How about something they underthink?
SPEAKER_00Parents often underthink how many students are out there that are just like their own unique special bundles of joy. You know, not every student is the most different, amazing student that's out there. I mean, it's it's a good thing for our society that there are so many high-achieving, capable, gifted, brilliant, motivated, proactive, you know, every good adjective under the sun students out there. But I think student parents especially, they lose sight of how many of those students are out there. Because if your kid is like the best, like one or two of a few hundred in the high school, well, there's thousands of high schools across the country and many more worldwide.
SPEAKER_01How about the best question every family should ask on a college tour?
SPEAKER_00I think that at first, I think parents and students, everyone should split up on these college tours. That way you're not the parent that's embarrassing the kid. And that way, if you're the kid, you can ask the question that's really on your mind and that you're able to compare and contrast the answers that your different tour guys gave and the different things that they uh brought out. Um, you know, I think that more importantly, you know, if you look around and you are a family and you know a bunch of students from the school or from the church or from your cousins or the work associates or the little league or the Boy Scouts or all these different communities that your own child might be in, and you know a bunch of students that go to school X, if they all love school X, they're gonna want to talk about it. And it's probably birds of a feather flock together. Your child is gonna have a successful time at X if they're able to get in. That being said, if you know like a few people that go to school Y and no one wants to talk about it, and you can't even like set up 30 minutes to ask, you know, hey, how does school Y? No one wants to talk about it. I mean, happy students, they want to tell everyone how happy they are. Unhappy students, they don't want to talk about it. And so if you can't find one person that goes to school Y and wants to share about it, then maybe school Y, as highly slept as you might hold, is just not for your kid.
SPEAKER_01And if you could whisper one piece of advice to a freshman or a parent of a freshman right now, what would it be?
SPEAKER_00I would say to you know, work hard and continue to do well on the academics, to do what you need to do to get those top grades in that most demanding curriculum, to try to take advantage of any way that you're able to take incremental APs or able to be a year ahead of a peer in like a math or a history, to double up and use your elective space strongly. I think it really does come first and foremost down to the academics, not necessarily being like the perfect 4-0 kid. The incremental benefit of being like the perfect 4-0 kid versus a student has like a 398 GPA is fairly inconsequential. But you, if you want to have that differentiation through your activities and your extracurriculars and your essays and all that, you need to have the table stakes with academic ability and being able to prove first and foremost to colleges that you are someone who's academically qualified to go to their college because ultimately these colleges are schools that teach. They can't be admitting students as wonderful as a student might be, who's gonna flunk out.
SPEAKER_01Jason, this has been incredibly valuable. I know parents are gonna want to go deeper and learn more about Ivycoach. Like, where is the best place to find you and more information about that?
SPEAKER_00Best way to find is Ivycoach.com. We have a great blog that has lots of interesting info on all different sorts of parts of the application process, trends in the industry of highly selective schools and admissions and the world at large. Uh, but you know, find us ivycoach.com. Uh, we're more than happy to have a free consultation with families and talk about how we might be able to help their child earn admission to as highly selective a school as possible.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. We'll put all that information in the show notes and in the YouTube description. Before we wrap, what's one thing you want parents to remember from this conversation?
SPEAKER_00I think that the most important thing to keep in mind is needing to be that well lopsided student that has a clear point of view, that is likable and compelling, that is not over-engineering or trying too hard, but someone who is, you know, able to plainly articulate how you're going to change the world in one specific way.
SPEAKER_01Well, Jason, thank you for again, thank you for coming on. I do want to ask one last question because I have a college coach that used this anecdotal thing anecdotally that stood out in uh the admissions room at UPen. What is the name of the pizza place where kids used to go to study for finals, but they changed their hours and they no longer do it?
SPEAKER_00I think Allegro, maybe.
SPEAKER_01Allegro. Okay. Yeah, he he did all the research and found out they were changing hours and mentioning how disappointed he was that that was no longer a thing. And they were super impressed that he knew that much about the college, which we didn't we didn't get into, but we did, but like actually a genuinely interest in going to that particular school. He did a lot of research, following everything. So but yeah.
SPEAKER_00If you're if you're only talking about the thing that's on the front page of the website or the brochure for the schools, you've not gone deep enough. I mean, these colleges, they're very insecure. They want to think that you love them. I mean, you got to think like you are like a The Bachelor or the Bachelorette, and you've got like a dozen contestants left that you're trying to find true love. You have to find a way to have that special relationship with every school you're applying to and make them feel like they're the first of among equals of schools that you're applying to and that you love them the most and that you have the strongest connection with them. That's that is uh certainly the name of the game when it comes to uh college admissions and and especially the white college essays.
SPEAKER_01That'd be some good content. Ivy League Bachelor or Bachelorette. So Jason, Jason, thank you so much. And for everyone else listening out there, remember you don't have to play the game the way the system is set up. You can find the foundation, build the skills, and you get the result without the burnout. Uh we'll again we'll put all the links below. Uh, thank you for turning in to the support supported learning podcast, and we'll see you next time. Thank you, Jason. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.