SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 75 - InGenius Prep CEO: Only Two Things Matter - Joel Butterly
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Joel Butterly, co-founder and CEO of InGenius Prep, a Yale Law and Dartmouth graduate who built his firm around a large team of former admissions officers from schools including Harvard, Stanford, and MIT.
Dr. Joe and Joel discuss his argument that roughly 70 to 80% of an admissions decision comes down to just two variables and why most of what families worry about is noise, how institutional priorities quietly determine outcomes and why an applicant’s intended major can dramatically change their odds at a given school, what holistic admissions actually means when one reader handles well over a thousand applications a cycle, why colleges want well-rounded classes rather than well-rounded students and what that means for how a teenager should spend their time, when in a student’s career planning actually pays off, and why he believes much of his own industry delivers no measurable value.
This episode is especially useful for parents of eighth through tenth graders planning ahead, families evaluating college consultants, and anyone trying to understand why strong students get rejected.
📲 Connect with them: https://ingeniusprep.com/
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@Ingeniusprep
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/drjoeAP
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/dr_joe_ap_exams/
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, balloons taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. Most families think the college mission game starts junior year. Joel Butterley says by then the game is already over. He's the Yale law grad who built what's reportedly the world's largest team of former emissions officers, actual people, who sat in the rooms at Harvard, Stanford, MIT, and turned them into a system for decoding what elite schools actually want. Today we're breaking down what most families get fundamentally wrong about the process. Welcome back to the Supported Learning Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars and years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people who have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. That's why I'm thrilled to have Joel here today. He is the co-founder and CEO of Ingenious Prep, one of the largest global college consulting firms in the world. He's a Yale law grad and a Dartmouth undergrad. And he built Ingenious around a team of former admissions officers from places like Harvard, Stanford, and MIT. And he's been featured in New York Times, Forms, Bloomberg, and runs operations across the U.S. and Asia. So we're going to dive into what elite emissions committees look actually want and look for, why most consulting is theater, and how families can think about this as a multi-year strategic process rather than last-minute scramble. Joe, welcome to the show. Thanks so much for having me and for the flattering introduction. Absolutely. Thank you for the time. I know it's ramping up for busy admission season in the summer here. So but I've given them the highlight, real. I want to hear from you. Give us like the 60-second snapshot of who you are and what specific problem in education and learning you solve for families.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think that fundamentally there are more misconceptions about admissions than there are kind of accurate understandings. I think at the end of the day, understanding the admissions process to uh highly selected schools is actually relatively straightforward. It's executing on a strategy kind of pursuant to that uh understanding. That's hard. Um, so people tend to assume and are kind of bombarded with the messages that um admissions is sort of hopelessly multivariate. There are thousands of things that you have to worry about from your extracurriculars to what you do over the summer, to your grades, test scores, what instrument you play, what sport, so on and so forth. Um and the reality is that 70 to 80 percent of how admissions decisions are made rely on just two variables. Um, one of them being, are you academically qualified, which is a function of grades and test scores and is a binary variable. And the other being, are you an expert at something in particular? Have you identified a passion or interest as early as possible and developed it to the farthest extent possible? Um, and so the problem that we are solving is sort of twofold. One is first educating families so that they understand how admissions decisions are made and what institutional priorities drive them. Um, and then secondly, helping them access the resources necessary to execute a strategy around that understanding.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I want to come back to institutional priorities as we get into this because I think that's a key thing that we often overlook, especially when when families are just like, my kid's a good student, why aren't they getting in? But you just going back through your background, you went, you were at Yale Law, right? So most people, most cheat JDs go to firms or politics. What made you go into the consulting business instead?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I mean, I was at Yale in the era of like JD, Vance, and Divek Ramaswamy. So a lot of us didn't end up in um in law, um, though, though not all of us ended up in politics.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, I mean, I think I think that like there's two answers to that question. One is why not law? And the answer is because I understand that risk and reward are correlated and and law is a relatively low-risk career, which is to say that in law you'll you'll only ever kind of get as much as is required to keep you around. Um, which is why I was you know interviewing with partners um on Friday nights um in New York law firms and them telling me they're not particularly happy with their life during an interview. Um the so that was uh that was an easier decision. Um and I wanted something that that had more risk and more reward um to it. The other is just that there was such an obvious whole um and need for these kinds of services at scale. And when I was looking into this industry, it was pretty clear that nobody had figured out how to offer these services, not only at scale, but with a sustainable level of quality at scale. Um and part of that is that there is a fundamental truth about this industry, which is that the barriers to entry are incredibly low. Every part person with an Ivy League degree can say, I'm an admissions consultant for Ivy League schools. The barriers to scale are enormous because what you need to do at scale is you need to produce a reliably high quality or comparable quality service in which every single student does something totally different from every other student, right? The uniqueness is the objective, and that creates real tension with the need to scale. Um, and so that actually was an interesting pedagogical challenge uh kind of early on in the company that we were just super excited about tackling.
SPEAKER_00What did you see? Was it in Yale or Dartmouth that, you know, in terms of college emissions while you were there that you saw that needed fixing? You kind of spoke a little bit about it. Was there specific specifics in your journey that you thought about needed fixing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, my own personal journey, um, at the risk of sounding like I'm trying to, you know, create a sob story, which is very much not sob-worthy. Um, you know, when I when I was applying to college, um I was one of the top-ranked policy debaters in the world. Um, I was very certain that I was going to get into a great school. And the the Harvard debate coach had uh said to me, you know, you're a shoe in, you don't even need to apply to other schools. Um, fortunately, I had an extremely overbearing mother who insisted that I apply to other schools, which is a good thing because I was deferred waitlisted and rejected from Harvard. Um I think fundamentally it kind of betrayed the truth about admissions, which is that this is a game of differentiation. And it is very hard to differentiate yourself with something like debate. Number four in the world for policy debate, okay. How do you compare that to number one in extemporaneous speaking, number three in Lincoln Douglas, number two in public forum? How do you compare number one globally to, you know, the the number one in New York City or the number two in the United States? Um, and how do you compare across these different formats of debate? And the answer is that you can't. Admissions officers cannot tell the difference between those things. It's the reason why, you know, the like things like the math Olympiad and the biology Olympiad are overwhelmingly useless for students from an admissions standpoint, because for every subject matter, there's five different competitions, and every competition has local, regional, national champions, and international champions. Um, you can't compare. So part of it was uh having felt like I worked myself to the bone and did not get exactly what I wanted. Now, boo hoo, I got into Cornell and Dartmouth and Princeton off the wait list, and like, you know, I went to Dartmouth because it had the best debate team. Um, you know, you know, woe is me, not a big sob story. But the but the reality is that I had real misconceptions, despite coming from a family where everybody had, you know, multiple IB league degrees and should be the kind of family that knows fundamentally everything about this process. So the misconception must run deep if my incredibly overbearing mother was unable to discern the needs and wants of these institutions.
SPEAKER_00Now, you'd failed to mention debate like Will Farrell and old school in there. So that's maybe why that was the differentiator, probably. But if you if you nailed that one, I think you probably could have got that.
SPEAKER_01So I didn't get I didn't I didn't get the dean kicked out. I wasn't fighting the dean. I didn't I didn't do like the ribbon dance and exactly. I didn't have that moment.
SPEAKER_00Um so you actually built this around former admissions officers from Harvard, Stanford, MIT. Why that model? Why not just hire small smart consultants like everyone else?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, fundamentally, uh people assume that if you've gotten into a college that you know why you got in, you don't. I don't know why I got into Dartmouth and Princeton and Cornell, and I don't know why I got rejected from Yale and Harvard. Um, I don't. Well, I sort of do because we knew somebody in the Harvard Admissions office, so I sort of know why, not Harvard, but the but like just getting in does not mean that you know why. Um it means you know why exactly one profile succeeded, but you don't know why it succeeded in that year. You don't know if it would succeed in the next year. Um the that is to say, you don't know anything about the institutional priorities that that govern whether or not a profile is desirable or not. Um so the use of admissions officers is an absolute essential element um in in the counseling process. Like, you know, when I tell when I talk to families that ask me like advice on what kind of company should I be looking for, the first thing I say is they need to have admissions officers. The reason why we have so many is because it gives us a really robust insight into not just one, but all of the most kind of selective schools, right? So for example, we know that you can almost increase your probability 20 times over applying to UCLA if you're interested in anthropology versus mechanical engineering. We know that young women applying to Yale have a much, much higher probability uh of success if they're interested in engineering than humanities or social sciences. We know that creative writing is something that Johns Hopkins is trying is trying to push historically and currently. And as a result, your probability of getting in if you're applying for creative writing is much, much higher than for biomedical engineering or anything in the life sciences. Right? Having that IP, right, have it having that knowledge base, not just about one, but about all of these schools, is essential to providing really high-level strategic advice to students. Um, so it's like basically here, here, here's how you decide whether a company knows enough about admissions. Do they have more, do they have an admissions officer from every top uh or every highly selective school? The answer is yes, they probably do. Um if the answer is no, they probably don't. Um the and if they don't have admissions officers at all, then they definitely are just guessing at things. They're probably using Chat GPT, which is overwhelmingly wrong in its in its sort of guesstimates of what these schools are looking for.
SPEAKER_00You you call your methodology the inside out of missions. Like walk me through what that actually means.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think we start from the on we start from the premise that um you first need to understand what admissions offices are actually selecting for and what institutional priorities exist. Right. Like here, here's a very simple example. Everybody, when when they're applying, they'll they'll give it an they'll give it each institution an indication of what they might want to major in, right? Or what their future plans are. Now, what they're not thinking about is the fact that 80% of students or applicants are applying to only 20% of the majors. Right. If you're applying for anything in the biology or life sciences, that might represent 10 to 12% of the applicant pool, but only four to five percent of the admitted students' pool. You've cut your probability in half, right? Each of these, each of these uh uh departments, each of these majors, they have tenured professors, those professors need to have students. Um, and so, you know, starting from the premise of understanding what are the things that institutions need to fill that aren't basically oversubscribed is a very good place to be strategically, right? If you say I'm interested in a thing that a third of applicants are interested in, but only one in 10 admitted students are interested in, you are really making life much harder. So starting from an understanding of what admissions offices select for and the overriding institutional priorities, which can include anything from how much of their class they fill in early decision to how many full-pay students there they're trying to get, to which majors are most undersubscribed. That's the best way of coming up with a really effective strategy. And what you find is that basically for every institution, there is some version of an arbitrage opportunity. There is some really undersubscribed discipline. And I'm not ad advocating that people lie and say, Oh, I'm interested in Russian literature when you know it's like nobody's interested in Russian literature. Um the the the what I'm saying is that the more specific you get and the more inter interdisciplinary you get with your interests, the more, you know, the kind of just generally the more specific, um, the more likely you are to succeed because you differentiate yourself from other applicants.
SPEAKER_00So holistic admissions is a phrase every college uses, like every consultant's talks about. But what does it actually mean, like from the people who've used it? What does holistic admissions look like, especially for ones that want top schools?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So um let's just say that you're an applicant, and this is something that like anytime I'm talking about admissions, I I run kind of the audience through this particular topic. Let's say that you are submitting your application. Basically, nobody understands what happens to that application after you've submitted it. Um so an application is 12 to 15 pages long, it goes on top of a stack of applications that might be 40 stories high if you were to print it out, though obviously they don't print it out anymore. And then those applications are then separated by region. Um the so, you know, this the admissions officer who's assigned to read applicants from China reads those. The admissions officer who's assigned to read applicants from Connecticut reads those. An individual admissions officer will read between 1,200 and 2,000 applications per cycle. That's on the high end, roughly 30,000 pages of applications that they need to read. Um, the holistic admissions is the fact that that one admissions officer is not given a rubric that is, you know, hard and fast. It's not like, oh, if you have this and you have this, you get in. It's like, here are the things that we care about generally. And that one individual forming a subjective opinion about an entire applicant based on essays, grades, test scores, activities, honors and awards, et cetera. Um, the and that is the holistic element. It's another way of putting it is that it's subjective. It's one person that you have to convince. And then if that person is convinced, they'll usually take it into like a committee and they'll vote on it in the committee. Um, but that's what holistic admissions means. The reason I bring up sort of the sheer volume of pages is because you have to understand that the job of an admissions officer is incredibly unpleasant. Um, they're reading application after application. 90% of them sound identical to some other application. Um, most students err on the side of writing the most depressing essays you could possibly imagine. Nobody's ever like, can you write about something that'll make the admissions officer laugh? You know, these schools want kids who are happy too. Um, the so it's like they all are like really depressing one after the other. At the end of the day, the applications that get pulled from the pile are the ones that stand out, the ones that are different. They're different because of the student is maybe funny. They're different because the student has different interests or different activities or different awards. Um, it's not the students who do the exact same thing as everybody else but do it a little better. Those students aren't getting it.
SPEAKER_00We can always tell at school when it's admission season because uh in the fall we have like um we have a monitor on all the students' devices for like, you know, for threats or for the so the uh warnings go off of like suicidal ideation because everyone is telling the most depressing story on I shouldn't lie, just make a joke of it, but of like can we I tell the counselors can we focus on something? Can there I don't know if I'll want to be reading a hundred applications about the time you thought about harming yourself? Like it's it's wild.
SPEAKER_01I remember I got lunch with a it was a it was a current admissions officer at Yale, this is a few years back. And one of the things he said is like we have basically a happy student quota where we just admit students who are qualified but are otherwise indistinct, and they just because like nobody wants uh an entire campus of miserable students. Um, but it's like if you give a hundred students, you're like write about whatever you think the admissions office wants wants to hear. 95 of them are writing about dad is an alcoholic or I grew up fat and being teased and humiliated. Um, and it's just like, my God, that's depressing to read. But also it's like a lot of students contextualize their suffering. It's like the it's like, yeah, that that's hard, but everybody else has something like that. That's different than something where everybody reads it and they're like, my God, this student overcame so much. Right. Um, and students don't have that perspective. So they they write about depressing things that are also fairly commonplace.
SPEAKER_00So going back to the institutional means and institutional priorities, you um you talk a lot about that about driving decisions. Um, and most parents have never heard of that, which is interesting because it's like I hear a lot of parents, well, so-and-so's kid got in there, so therefore we're doing this. I don't know if they realize that schools have five-year plans. They change their priorities all the time in the students they look for. But why does that matter when building a competitive application?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I guess one way I guess I can I can I can make the point best by example. Um, most families are still concerned about the concept of being well-rounded. Um, well-rounded applicants, that that was always a myth. If it if it wasn't always a myth, it was it was it was maybe true for a couple of years, 25 years ago, but it's been a myth for a very, very long time. Colleges don't want well-rounded students, they want well-rounded classes. Well-rounded classes consists of a lot of students who are specialists in particular area. Um and part of the reason that they want specialists is, I mean, not to go kind of too off the beaten path, is because every student is an investment for these schools. Like you know how much tuition is, right? Let's let's just $70,000 to $90,000 at these private institutions, exorbitantly expensive. How many people know that each of these schools spends, you know, 50% more than that on each of these students every year, and only 16% of the students are paying full tuition, right? They are sinking a lot more money into these students than the students actually spend in tuition. Um, and the reason why they do that is because the student is an investment. And that investment can pay off one of two ways. The investment can pay off because the student goes out, goes forth in the world and does amazing things and it reflects positively on the school. It's a Supreme Court justice. Um the it can also pay off because you become very rich in donate. Um the these are these are two of the primary ways that this pays off. What is the best predictor of whether somebody is going to do something great in the future? It'll be predominantly that they have focused on one particular area for a long a sustained period of time and are already an expert in it. That's the best bet as to whether they do something great in that field rather than somebody who's like a dilettante. Um and so that's why they care about students having, you know, kind of like specific areas of interest or specific areas of focus. Anyway, the fact the fact that that is the case, knowing that institutional priority, understanding that these students are an investment to them, that they're not, they're not like, you know, they're not making a profit on these, on these students in any in any means, by any means, um, is critical to understanding what they're selecting for. Um so if you try to do like a whole bunch of different things and be really good at a whole bunch of different things, you're not very admissible to these top schools. But if you're really great at one thing, now you're admissible. Um so you you cannot form a cogent strategy without understanding what the institutions are selecting for and why.
SPEAKER_00This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supported tutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. I I um I mean, like here's an example of we got a kid um at my school, he got in the CMU, not overly impressive with any of it, but he's from Pittsburgh. CMU's institutional priorities are looking for kids. They don't they get a lot of kids from all over that are coming there and they get great degrees and then they bounce. They don't contribute to the job market. There's like a there's a strategic plan in place at CMU to keep them here and contributing to Pittsburgh, and it seemed to work. So you um you're a strong advocate of cancy building as a multi-year project for a parent of a freshman. What does that actually look like? Where do you even start?
SPEAKER_01Um so ultimately, kind of going back to what I said to start, um, admissions is about two things. Are you academically qualified? Are you an expert at something in particular? Um, so when you're you're dealing with younger students, and and and the reality here is that like if you look at this from just a statistical perspective, starting in eighth grade has the highest overall impact on your probability of success. Um, the though usually starting in 10th grade has the highest return on investment, meaning how many, how many, how much it costs to start in 10th grade against the improvement in your probability. Things drop off pretty steeply after 10th grade, right? So one way of thinking about this is how much are you uh what is the improvement in your probability of getting admitted into elite schools, right? So if a student that works with us in 10th grade is eight times as likely to get in, a student who starts with us in eighth grade uh might be 12 times as likely. And a student, but a student who starts with us in 11th grade is four times as likely. Um, so the biggest drop off is between 10th and 11th. Um, when you're starting with a student younger, grade eight, grade nine, um, part of it is just give equipping them with the skills to succeed academically. And I don't mean tutoring. I mean really advanced writing programs. Um, the that that tends to be really impactful. Speaking, executive functioning is woefully needed in in most students uh today. Um, just time management and organization, incredibly important. Those are things that aren't class or subject specific, but that that really do dictate whether you're likely to succeed academically in high school. Um, on the sort of extracurricular side of things, a lot of it has to do with just passion exploration, figuring out what you really like doing. Um, the like I've never met a student who was so ambitious that they were willing to invest enough time in something that they hated that they could become a real expert for their age group and be attractive to these schools. So you really do have to start with what you really love with as much specificity as possible. So figuring out what that is early on. And I know that sounds fluffy, but the reality is that so much of value flows from it. Um so it's it's that. And then it's just about building a really compelling extracurricular profile, giving students the uh opportunities to pursue those interests at a level of sophistication that other students don't have, whether that's advanced research, whether that's starting their own organization, whether that's internships, summer programs, so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_00So by like end of junior year, how much of the student's profile is locked in? I called it like, I call it the cake is baked at this point. Like we're not, if we haven't done anything, we're probably not gonna move the needle much here.
SPEAKER_01You can get one really good capstone achievement or extracurricular activity over the summer following 11th grade. Right. So for a lot of students that work with us, they'll come to us around that time. And it's usually like, you know, we're setting you up with a professor to do original research and um, you know, you're writing a research paper and maybe submitting it for publication or something like that. Um, the, but you know, you really can't modify the foundation. Meaning if it, if at the end of 11th grade you don't have a very clear kind of theme to your application, what we call an application persona, which is essentially just your in your passion and the activities surrounding it, it's very, very hard to manufacture it at that time. Um and what you've done at that stage is you've taken yourself from a student who could magnify their probability by 8x, and you've reduced it to a student who can magnify their probability by 2 to 3x, which is still a lot. You know, it's like the application does matter. But the reality is that what you, you know, an hour of our time in ninth grade is worth a lot more to you than an hour of our of your time. Oh, sorry, an hour of our time.
SPEAKER_00Compound interest factor, basically, just stacking it on top of each other, starting early.
SPEAKER_01Time time in the market. It's literally just investments. The dollar invested in ninth grade versus a dollar invested in 11th grade.
SPEAKER_00Um, your company Ingenious operates a lot in Asia, China, Korea, Singapore. Why what do those families understand about emissions that American families miss?
SPEAKER_01I'm not sure that they understand more about admissions. They honestly might understand less. Um, they care more about it, right? So so those are cultures where accessing elite institutions is um kind of culturally endemic. Um the these are families who care a great deal about that, and sometimes in the wrong way. It's not it's not always the the way to be. I mean, you you talked about a student who got into CMU. It's like there are plenty of students who would rather go to Yale than CMU, but if you want to be an engineer, CMU is the correct answer, um, not Yale. So rankings are not everything. They're not even close to being everything, but uh, they care a great deal about that. And those are the biggest study abroad markets. And so in study abroad markets, you know, 95% of the students who are applying are using some kind of consultant, whereas in the United States, it's a slight, it's it's a much lower percentage of students who are using um consultant channel, though it's been growing pretty rapidly. Yeah. I'm just saying today, I'll yeah. Today, today about 60% of our families are in the US and about 70% are in North America. Um, but like Asia is definitely still a very large market, um, and that's why. Um the you know, it's like the value add to those families is extremely high. And I don't think it's because they know more about the admissions process at all. I think it's just this is what they want to spend money on, is basically helping their students get into, you know, extremely selective institutions.
SPEAKER_00So for an American family of a high achieving student, what is the single biggest strategic mistake they're making right now?
SPEAKER_01Um I think the I think it it depends a little bit on geography, but uh I would say overall it's looking around and having that kind of FOMO problem, which is I don't want to not do these other things that other people are doing because I'm afraid it'll mean I don't get it. So I end up doing what everybody else is doing and I just try to do it a little bit better. Um, the correct orientation is to look and see what everybody's doing and say, I am going to do totally different things. I'm gonna have different interests, I'm gonna do different things over the summer. I'm not gonna do it the same way. Um, what you see with these families is that they do the they all do the same thing, same instruments. They play sometimes the same sports. Most often they're going to the same summer programs, like, oh, I have to go to Stanford summer session. Stanford summer session has exactly zero impact on whether you get into Stanford or any other school. Um, that is true of like 99% of these summer programs. They have no causal relationship with whether you get into get into school. Um, and they all do the competitions. I'm gonna do the math Olympiad. And it's like, okay, well, it's like I'm a bronze medalist for the math Olympiad in New York. All right, great. Well, there's literally 10,000 other people who have or a thousand people who have equivalent credentials. It's like Harvard isn't looking for one, you know, a thousand people one of a thousand. They're looking for one of one. Um, and so you know, it's like it's that. It's it's just looking around and seeing what other people are doing and just out of fear, doing the same thing and trying to do it better. That that is the number one mistake by far.
SPEAKER_00You've said college coach, college consulting is theater. What separates real strategic advising from theater? Go into why you think it's theater first, and then what separates the two?
SPEAKER_01Um, well, so what I what I mean by college consulting is theater is that I mean, this is a this isn't like the most salubrious industry uh overall. Um the, you know, it's like it has a somewhat bad reputation. I think that bad reputation is frankly well deserved. Um, and I think that the reason that it is the case is that these services, for the most part, are non-falsifiable. Your kid works with me and I get them and they get into Harvard, is it because of me? If they get rejected, is it my fault? The fact that you can't answer that readily means that you have a ton of service providers out here who are offering dubious, you know, dubious value or no value in in their services. They're really just kind of hand-picking students who are already great and then claiming credit for their achievements.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_01So it's like if you were to look at like the 10 largest admissions consulting, you were to look at their outcomes, and you were to track those outcomes against the number of students that they helped apply, what you'd find is that about half of them are basically indistinguishable from the overall acceptance rates at those institutions, meaning they've added zero value. Um the the and some of them are adding an enormous amount of value. Um the but so it's theater in the sense that people, you know, pretend that there's like these hacks and these, these, these, these tricks, and there there really isn't. Like it's it boils down to are you academically qualified? Are you an expert at something in particular? Um, there's lots of little things that you can do and nuances that to improve your probability. But if those are the two things that you per that you that you pursue, great. Um I would say that when families are engaging in this industry, what they want and need, or whether they want it or not, this is what they need. They firstly they want, or they need, sorry, they need good strategy. Good strategy is born of people who understand the admissions office, right? And understanding the admissions office comes from people who have worked in the admissions office, the former admissions officers. So having a large base of IP from those individuals is incredibly important so that you can create a good strategy. Strategy without execution is useless, right? I give this example often. Like recently I redid my will and I went to a trust and estates attorney, and that trust and estates attorney said, okay, here's the things you need to do, and these are the these are the trusts you need to create, and all of that. If I had said, great, let's go, let's do it, and they had said, Oh, no, no, we don't do the legal work. We we don't we don't do those things. We just tell you what to do. I would say I'm not paying you. Um, but families in this industry, they pay for the strategy without the execution. The execution is if I tell you you need to do A, B, C, D, and E, I need to have the resources necessary for you to execute on that. If I say you need to do research and publish, I need to have professors and I need partnerships with peer-reviewed journals. If I say you need to create your own organization, I need some kind of startup incubator or or or you know, nonprofit incubator. If I say you need to do internships, I need to have those available to students. So the the the kind of advice and the execution are what makes this industry valuable. Without either one of those, you are paying for, you know, theater.
SPEAKER_00Well, what's crazy is when you dig into it, because I think just coaching in general, like in the BizOps space, has gotten oversaturated, right? There's a lot of players in there that are just marketing and sales, not really core education. It sounds like obviously you're you're not one of them. You're one of the good ones. The um the thing that I'm surprised is people are paying 20, 30k for college coaching for promises, and then they're actually getting sold into pay-to-play research opportunities or other things, which like they're just affiliates with. And you just said they're no value add as well. It's crazy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, so I mean, real research is extremely valuable, right? So, like a good example of this is UPenn a couple of years ago in their acceptance, acceptance letters. They did something that I've actually never seen in an acceptance letter, was they called out specific achievements of applicants. They said something like, um, it's like 20 to 30 percent of our students completed advanced research, or of our accepted students completed advanced research. Um that probably compares to about 1% or less than 1% of the student of the applicant pool, right? So less than 1% of the applicant pool became 20 to 30 percent of the students pool. Um, I think though, the reality is that most pay-to-play research, and there's tons of that, we offer pay-to-play research. Um, most of it is not actually research. It's an online class. Right. Right. And it's like there's very there's great value in it. But like those are programs that compete with Coursera, not with like an academic internship, right? Like if you're gonna do research, it needs to be your own research, it needs to be original, it needs to be supervised by by a by a professional. Um, and it should create new knowledge. Um, it should not be just a recitation of what already exists. Um there, there is so there's a great value in that. In fact, I think it's one of the things that students should invest in more. The problem is that, you know, of all the companies out there, I know of maybe two that actually offer real research as opposed to just online classes with a professor, you know, one to many, which is not not useful for admissions and can be useful educationally, but oftentimes is replaceable by a much less expensive Coursera course.
SPEAKER_00So for like students that have AP capstone, because that is becoming from the AP side of things, that is becoming a lot more popular than your traditional AP Lang, AP Lit. Um, some schools are actually replacing their AP Lang with AP seminar. And if you do the two-year, you finish it with or IRB, supposedly through the IRB, you have a research project. How many kids could leverage that instead of you know having to find something else? What uh what is your experience with that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, um the unfortunate reality is that anything that is common is devalued in the admissions process. Although that that's true in any, in any economy, right? It's uh scarcity drives value. Um, so what we often see with our students is that they'll do the AP capstone in conjunction with a research project with us on the same topic, and the two kind of are mutually reinforcing. Um, there is something to be said about being supervised by uh you know a professor, about getting published in like a legitimate journal, legitimate meaning it's not just pay-to-play. There's like some peer review process, and there's only about six or seven of those for high school students that I know of. Um the and and and uh but yeah, I mean it it is valuable. It's just you kind of need to take it outside of the school context in order to really in order for it to really be differentiated from what other students are doing. Um, and um, you know, I say that's unfortunate because there are plenty of students who do the AP capstone and they're doing better research than the average student working with a professor. But because it's AP, um, you know, it's like it's because those so many other students do it, it's thought of as being less less important or less significant. And that's not always true, but like at statistically, like when we analyze these things, that that's largely the case.
SPEAKER_00Um from a potential client prospect of like how what are you seeing as the split of, and you'll you'll know when I ask those questions. How many are how many potential clients the parent really wants the Ivy League over the kid? The kid's just like uh, you know, the kid, the parents driving that conversation versus the kid. And I I think getting more, you know, mindset or deeper down, a lot of elite emission starts with that desire. Like most kids, some of the kids that I talk to, they don't even they don't know the first thing to differentiate us between Harvard or Columbia or Yale or Princeton. They just they've been they they they're chasing the brand, is what I say. Like, what is that split in your in your perspective and what you've seen?
SPEAKER_01Um honestly, you'd you'd be surprised, though. I I think that like usually what the parent wants has sort of spilled into what the student wants for themselves. Um it's it's not we don't see a ton of cases, though we see it common commonly, but you know, maybe 20% of cases where what the student wants is objectively a completely different thing than what the parent wants. More often is that they fundamentally want the same thing, they disagree on how to get there. Um, you know, it's like the student really wants to be um, you know, an engine, a great engineer, um, and wants to go to like UIUC or CMU or Georgia Tech, and the parent's like, no, it's got to be, you know, an Ivy League school. And like, in that particular case, the student is probably right, because if you're going to, you know, Dartmouth, Brown, or Yale, the the engineering programs, and that's probably probably the I'm I'm not including enough schools, but the the engineering programs are objectively worse than those other programs that I just mentioned. Um and so we see that more often. Um, the the issue that we see most charmingly is a family is wedded to a specific ranking um rather than a specific outcome. That is to say, families think about college. Like I always say to people, like, you think that you're hiring us to get you into a great school. And in a very literal sense, that is what you are doing. The reality, though, is that what you're paying for is the highest probability that your student has a happy, healthy, successful life. Um, you know, that doing, doing what they love, being being, you know, productive, et cetera. And if I could guarantee you that outcome, you wouldn't care what school they went to. Um, you just think that this school is the path to get there. Um, and so the misconception is the idea that a an overall ranking is somehow representative of like what schools get you where you want to go. Like you want to go into finance, you'd be shocked what the top five schools are that feed into like the high, you know, the bulge bracket, you know, finance jobs. You'd be shocked. You want to go to law school, you'd be shocked which schools are feeding into the top law schools. I mean, there's some that you expect, like Harvard and Yale and Stanford, but then there's a bunch that you don't expect, like several of the liberal arts colleges that are feeding into. So the the fact that like there is a fundamental misconception of what they of what kind of end results in terms of colleges results in the in what they're actually looking for.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess I should ask it a different way, because I've used that analogy too of the goalposts. Like the goalposts are limited to getting into the school when, like you said earlier, the schools want what you're going to become. Like ultimately, that's who they're seeking. And the reason you might get rejected from that school is because you're selling yourself short of just emissions, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I like the I just think that the correct way of thinking about this industry and thinking about these services is start with what the end goal, the true end goal is. What do you want to be doing when you're 30 or 40? And then work your way backward. What are the schools that actually offer that pathway to you? Because there's some schools that are very good at it and some schools that are bad at it. And as it has some correlation to rank, but not nearly as much correlation to rank as you would think it does. Um, and so like one of the things that we do is we compile a ton of data we call the feeder schools data, which is essentially what are the schools that are best at feeding into specific career paths or specific opportunities. Um, and that could be law school, medical school, finance, Silicon Valley and tech, entrepreneurship, et cetera. Um, and that's a whole different ranking, right? Like, yes, a lot of the top schools are at the top of those lists, but a lot of the times there are schools that you'd be very, very surprised about, you know, ranking very, very highly that these families should be considering. So I think it's just a matter of uh nuance. Like I think, I think we're all in agreement as to what we want for our kids, I think, more or less. Um, I j I think that there's a disagreement over how best to achieve it.
SPEAKER_00You've been quoted in the Times, Forbes Bloomberg, on the business of higher education. What is a trend most parents aren't tracking that they should be?
SPEAKER_01Well, one trend I think is uh, you know, as the Trump administration continues to disrupt and add uncertainty to budgets and research uh grants and things like that to these institutions, they're going to increasingly be looking for students, you know, international students who pay full tuition or domestic students who pay full tuition, right? So what that will look like is a higher proportion of students are admitted an early decision because that's where you can kind of lock down your budget. Um and I would say that that's sort of one trend that that seems to be having um a meaningful impact. Now, that doesn't mean if if you're a family that that needs financial aid and cannot afford the tuition, rest assured you're with 84% of the other of the other families. Um it doesn't mean that there's not there's not spots for you. But this is a a moment in time where schools are going to prioritize that more than they have in the past. I mean, over the last decade, the proportion of students paying full tuition at private universities basically got cut in half. Um and so I I would expect sort of a a reverse trend for at least a couple of years. Um and uh so just so in any event, I I think that like at the end, at the end of the day, money is important for these institutions just as it is for any institution. I would I would expect that to have a meaningful impact on the admissions process.
SPEAKER_00All right, let's uh let's shift gears here as we round this out. We're gonna go to lightning round, just uh rapid fire questions, first thing that comes to mind. Does that sound good? Sounds good. All right.
SPEAKER_02Most overrated piece of college admissions advice. Most overrated piece of college admissions advice.
SPEAKER_01Um Wall you gotta be well rounded. It's a piece of trash. It's never been true. Um the time, it's like absolute garbage, totally wrong.
SPEAKER_02Uh how about most overrated extracurricular? Oh god, anything that you do at your school.
SPEAKER_01Um, the basically everything, any competition, programs, any any like any sport at your school, basically everything that you normally do.
SPEAKER_02How about one thing parents overthink? One thing parents overthink.
SPEAKER_01Um I think that one thing that they overthink is school selection. Um, I think that uh not to say that school selection is important, but the reality is that they think they all oftentimes families and students think that there are maybe there's one, maybe two schools that that's perfect for them, and everything else is a step down. It's ridiculous. I've never met a student where there were fewer than 10 schools that could offer them everything that they needed. Um the idea that there is one school that's a perfect fit for you is nonsense. Um these schools are so diverse and so well resourced that there's always at least 10, probably 15, that can offer you everything that you need and more. How about something they underthink? Um something they underthink. Um they often underthink uh sort of an act. Extracurricular, uh like they're basically extracurriculars generally. Right. So they normally just sort of like fall into I'm gonna do what everybody else around me does. I'm gonna try to do it a little bit better. Um, they never really give thought to a multi-year plan for like developing expertise.
SPEAKER_00Best book or resource for a parent of a freshman?
SPEAKER_01Best book or resource for a parent of a freshman in high school or freshman in college?
SPEAKER_00Freshman of high school.
SPEAKER_01Oh God, that's that's hard. Uh honestly, most of the stuff that's out there that's publicly available is garbage and incredibly generic. Um I mean, it really is. It is shocking, it is shockingly generic. Um, I would say probably the best resource is like reading uh internal memos, uh, like from like the lawsuit against Harvard, um, this the student for fair admission. I'd read every single document there because it will tell you everything you need to know about how these institutions prioritize certain things.
SPEAKER_00Hmm. That's good. All right. And if you could whisper one piece of advice to the parent of a high achieving freshman in high school, what would it be?
SPEAKER_01There are a million high achieving freshmen. The it's not enough to be great in your school. You have what I call the vertical view, which is you look at your high school, you see your student at the top, and then everybody down below it. That's not how universities see things. What they see is the top five or 10% of every school in your area, and they compare those students to one another. It's in that perspective that you need to be different, um, not in your high school. So the the kid who's every parent's like, oh, you need to be more like Timmy, that kid often does really badly in admissions because there's a Timmy at every school. Yeah. Um the so if you were to slice off the top five, the top 10, the top 20% of students at every school in your area, and you are truly differentiated from that population, you'll do well.
SPEAKER_00Well, Joel, this has been incredibly valuable. I uh I really appreciate your time. And I know parents are going to want to go deeper with this. So where's the best place for them to find you and Ingenious Prep?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, uh they can they can contact us, ingeniousprep.com. Um, the um I think we have uh we have tons of like recordings of different webinars that we've done in the past um and and kind of free resources. Um they can always uh set up an appointment uh to have a have a call with one of our experts um to kind of walk through their own students' um backgrounds and needs. Um and and you know, what I would say is like in in this in this industry, you know, earlier is better. It is also more expensive. As I said before, eighth grade, highest overall impact, tenth grade, best return on investment, ninth grade is the average where the people start, at least for us. Not not in this industry generally. Um, but the best thing that you can do is is help your student figure out what they really love doing and doing a lot more of it at a very advanced level as early as possible.
SPEAKER_00And um before we wrap, what's one thing you want people to remember from this conversation?
SPEAKER_01Uh I mean, I g I guess the most the most important thing is the vast majority of things that you've heard about admissions are wrong. And it is born of ignorance, willful or otherwise, or companies in my industry that are trying to scare you. Admissions is simple. There are only a couple of variables that matter. Um, if you focus on those things, you will be successful. If you fail to focus on those things, you will not be successful. Um, are you academically qualified? Are you an expert at something in particular? Those are the things that matter.
SPEAKER_00Well, Joel, I thank you again. I appreciate you just sharing everything, uh, the playbook. Um, and uh I really do appreciate your time for coming on. My pleasure. Thanks so much for having me. Thank you. Uh, for everyone listening, like remember, you don't have to play the game the way the system is set up. You can find the foundation, build the skills, and get the results without the burnout. We are going to put the links to everything we discussed in the show notes and in the YouTube description. And thank you again for tuning in to the Supported Learning Podcast. We'll see you next time. Thanks, Joel. Thank you. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.