SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 77 - Apprenticeship Advocate: The Four-Year Degree Is a Financial Trap for Most Students - Ryan Craig
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Ryan Craig, managing director at Achieve Partners and author of A New U and Apprentice Nation, to unpack why the four-year college degree is no longer the safe bet most families assume it is.
Dr. Joe and Ryan discuss the “great misalignment” between what colleges produce and what employers actually need, the four specific scenarios where college still delivers strong ROI, why entry-level jobs now require experience that new graduates don’t have, how apprenticeships are expanding beyond the building trades into tech, healthcare, and finance, and what AI is about to do to internships and junior-level positions.
This episode is especially useful for parents of high schoolers weighing the college decision, families concerned about student debt and return on investment, educators rethinking career and technical education pathways, and anyone curious about the earn-and-learn alternatives gaining ground across the economy.
📲 Connect with them: https://www.achievepartners.com
Newsletter: https://www.alchemy.works
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Book a call: supportedtutoring.com/book-call-youtube
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, blue taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. Ryan Craig has spent 15 years building a thesis. The four-year college degree is the most expensive default decision Americans make. And for a lot of students, it's a financial trap. He's an investor, a McKinsey alum, and the author of two of the most influential books on the future of education and work. Today we're going to talk about what he calls the great misalignment, why apprenticeships are the future, and what every parent of a high schooler should be thinking about that they probably aren't. Welcome back to the Supported Learning Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars in years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people who have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. And that's why I'm thrilled to have Ryan Craig here today. Ryan is the managing director at Achieve Partners, an investor in the education to employment space, and the author of two books, uh, New You, Faster and Cheaper Alternatives to College, and Apprentice Nation. He is a former lawyer, a McKinsey alum, and one of the most cited voices in the conversation about the real value of a college degree, the structural problems with the higher education, and the rise of apprenticeships and alternative credentials. We're going to dive into what he calls the great misalignment between college and employment, where smart money is invested in education right now and what parents of high schoolers should be thinking about for their kids' careers, not just their college emissions. Ryan's welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_00Joe, great to great to see you. Thanks for having me. Appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I've given them a 60-second rundown of who you like who you are, but I want to hear from you. Who are you and what specific problem do you solve in education and learning for families?
SPEAKER_00What right do you have to be talking about this stuff? Sure. I am the son of a community college, community college professor, and have been working in uh in and around higher education for 30 years, started my career at Columbia University, have helped launch universities, have helped save universities, uh, have been investing in higher education-related businesses for uh over 20 years now. And uh the the the journey has been really interesting and I think has uh positioned us right to where where really important work is happening right now as we think about uh the value of college and the future of college. In a nutshell, we've gone from focusing on classroom-based organizations to work-based learning. I think as a as a nation, we've overinvested dramatically in a post-high school in classroom-based learning and uh really underinvested in work-based learning. Um, and over the last couple of decades, I think increasingly the skills that companies are looking for are actually uh harder to learn in a classroom uh than they are they are by doing. So we're we are, you use the phrase the great misalignment, we are misaligned right now in terms of the funding and the priorities relative to what companies in the labor market are seeking. And the answer has to be a shift to more work-based learning, more internships, more apprenticeships. Uh, it doesn't mean that instead of, right? But it definitely has to include work-based learning in an era of AI, if we want our children to be able to launch successful careers.
SPEAKER_01Ryan, as a lifelong educator, still an active educator, someone who holds three degrees, a master's and a doctorate. I could not agree with you more. I honestly, sitting here today, don't know if my daughters will go to college or not. Um, not because they're not smart enough, because I just don't know what the future of college looks like. And I saw an interesting stat. Actually, so Pennsylvania has done a lot of work with career development. It hasn't really flushed out, I think, the way the state wanted it to. But one of the videos they were showing us, I remember this was probably about eight years ago, was the proper ratio is seven to one. Seven like almost like technical positions, two like bachelor's degrees, and one professional degree of what the output should be. And I think we're comp like you said, we are completely misaligned in what we're producing and what the expectation is. And there's a reason why people graduating school can't find the appropriate jobs, and there's there's other pathways to it. So you've actually coined that phrase, the misalignment. Where like walk me through what that actually means and and what's behind it in this misalignment.
SPEAKER_00Well, uh, you know, if you look at for a hundred students, for for four plus decades, pop uh public policy, federal and state, has been uh effectively college for all. Uh, we think that uh every every student from and you see that reflected in, for example, charter schools, uh, where from kindergarten on, you see posters of uh colleges, brand name colleges on the walls, and that's what they should be aiming for and shooting for. And as a nation, uh, we were up there in terms of matriculation, right? We have among the highest college going rates uh in the in the world. The problem is that if you actually look at 100 students who were heading off to college, matriculating in in college, uh, the percentage who are actually graduating into an appropriate uh sort of career launching job, uh that is depending on how you measure it, anywhere from 30 to 40 percent. So no matter how you look at it, the majority of those who matriculate are either not completing uh or they're completing and graduating into underemployment. So uh the system is not working for most uh today. And it's certainly not working well uh for those who most need the leg up uh provided by provided by college. Uh you know, it worked a lot better uh a generation ago when most companies, uh when they were looking for kind of professional track uh employees, you know, didn't have as many criteria. They wanted someone who had cognitive skills, who had durable skills, who had some interest uh in the profession and who would be a good fit. Uh, you know, I I talk about in my book, I talk about uh the uh Don Draper's ad agency and mad men. Like, what did it take to get a job at one at that firm? Well, one, you had to be a man, I guess. But beyond that, uh, they were looking for a set of skills, but they were looking for a prior experience in advertising. They weren't looking for particular uh uh mastery on a software platform. But those are the things you're seeing now. You see a dramatic skills gap, you see a dramatic experience gap where jobs that used to be entry-level jobs are now effectively asking for six, 12, 18 months worth of uh relevant work experience in the space, which essentially turns entry-level work into an oxymoron and there is no such thing anymore. So it's it's it's problematic. And we we we've continued, I think, up until very recently, telling our kids that this is the this is the path, this is the one path, this is the only path, and uh it's not it's not working. So we we've been really focused on two things I'd achieve. One is establishing alternative apprenticeship pathways, which could eventually, if we can uh increase dramatically increase the supply, truly become alternatives. To college for now, they they the the programs that we we've created tend to be serving underemployed, unemployed, and unhappily employed college grads who uh are not being well served by the system as it exists. So creating alternatives, but then also within the system, trying to expand work-based learning, we've come to the conclusion that it's highly unlikely that we're gonna be able to create enough apprenticeships to deal with what AI is about to do to entry-level jobs. And we'll we can talk about that more in a second. So we think every student, if they want to have a shot at a good job when they graduate, is going to need relevant in-field paid work experience. And that's not something that 99% of universities are set up to help arrange. Internships are haphazard, unsystematic, relationship-based, and highly inequitable. And they should be systematic. They should be uh incorporated as a core component of every program of study. And if universities can't figure out how to do that, whether by themselves or more likely with a partner, uh, they probably shouldn't be offering that program.
SPEAKER_01So you're you were you were a lawyer, you went to law school, you went obviously you you went to undergrad. So you went through the whole process. But how do you go from being a lawyer and and you're an investor now to be one of the loudest voices, kind of like not anti-college, but this thought that we should be investing and growing this in completely other field, I guess. What was the moment you knew you wanted to do this work? And was there a specific case that crystallized it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't think it was one moment. It was just a series of things where we began. My firm was investing in more traditional higher education businesses, businesses that supported the college status quo, if you will, and finding that we weren't achieving either the financial outcomes or impact outcomes that we were hoping for. You know, after post-great recession, we were looking at unemployment and underemployment numbers for college grads, and they just simply weren't coming down. And so we suspected that that was really a secular trend resulting primarily from digital transformation, but which, you know, has transformed hiring. You know, it used to be that you would send out letters, resumes to a handful of jobs as opposed to, you know, hundreds of applications that you can submit with two clicks. So that that that has completely changed uh the hiring process, uh, and it's changed the skills uh that companies are are seeking uh for entry-level, entry-level employees. So that's that that that's very different. And we began you know investing in, you can see Mike, the the you mentioned my last last book, second to last book, uh, behind me, faster and cheaper alternatives to college. So we began investing in in boot camps and income share programs and programs that attempted to address that skills gap through what we the term we coined was last mile training. And then the sort of the next innovation was building, building that uh boot camp type structure into a staffing company or a services company. And that's what we do now at Achieve, where with our workforce fund, we've we focus on sectors of the economy where there's a talent shortage, find an appropriate services business in that space, and then build apprenticeship into that company so it could become a talent engine for its talent-starved sector. That's good for the company and obviously good for the apprentices who are now being hired into these roles. So we've helped launch thousands of uh careers uh that would not have launched uh if not for our apprenticeship program.
SPEAKER_01We all aligned on one thing in cross spaces. We do believe skills over content. Like we we talk a lot about that in our AP program that it's the development of skills and the assessment of skills, and we learn by doing. I literally used an I'm not I use the analogy all the time of listen, I built with my friend a set of steps off the back of my deck. And it was one of the hardest things I did. We did not know how to do it, but then we did it and we figured it out. And now if I had to do it again, I learned a lot more. And so I think one of the spaces where we've gotten misaligned in education is we're so focused on content and the regurgitation of information and not what we do with that information and the application of it and real-world technical skills, you know, you could learn through a book like how to how to wire a house, how to how to become an electrician, but really you don't become a master, you don't become a master electrician unless you put the time as an apprentice in that field to become certified because you actually have to show that you could do it. And ultimately that's what you're advocating for.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, we have a whole industry, right? It's a multi-trillion dollar industry called education, and it's run by educators. And the modality is classrooms, and it's kind of easy to understand. You literally put kids in a building and you have professionals uh teaching them and in some cases babysitting them. And uh that's that that's that's the model, completely segregated, almost completely segregated from the rest of the economy. That's not serving the economy well anymore. It's not serving kids well anymore, at least from, you know, sort of certainly beyond high school, and in some cases, you might argue from you know the the high school or at least you know grades 11, 12. Sure. On serving kids, it's not serving kids well. We have, you know, one one result of the college for all approach has been the emaciating of career technical education in high schools. Uh, and that's demonstrated in so many different uh ways. For example, grade point averages where you have uh uh uh extra weighting added for honors and AP classes, and there is no such thing as honors and AP classes for CTE courses. So anyone who takes a CTE course is uh, you know, inherently at a disadvantage uh if they're even thinking about applying to college. And the fact that simply we have, you know, I wrote an article a few years ago trying to uh capture what I think is the dilemma we pose to high school graduates in this country, and it's called college or tripole. Uh so uh there is no middle ground, right? You can go to college or you can do a frontline service uh service role with very little prospect for career launch or advancement, but there's nothing in between. And that's just not true in most other developed countries where, for example, you can go to work as a pharmacy, as a pharmacy at a pharmacy, as a pharmacy assistant in Europe and work your way up to becoming a pharmacist without necessarily having to go back to school. Uh or you can earn and learn and earn that while you're while while you're working. We just we just don't have that in this in this country. And so there's a real need to create these these third pathways. But I I want to be clear that uh I'm not anti-college. I do think that um, you know, there are I think there are four distinct uh cases uh where college is absolutely the right decision for a given student. The first and most important one, and I imagine highly relevant to most of your clients, is if you can afford it. If you can afford to pay for college, you're not going into debt to send your child uh through four years of what uh is sometimes called a maturation vacation. Your child at the end of it will uh be uh more employable than they are at the age of 18, uh, have matured, gained a number of uh a number of skills, and have engaged in some level of discovery uh where they'll know themselves better and have a better supply to do. Uh so um, you know, that that's a good portion of the certainly not the majority of the population, but uh, you know, a good portion of the population falls into that that category. Second category would be uh if you get into a highly selective university, those tend to be the ones that uh have the most generous financial aid. But if you're if your child has that opportunity, I don't care what apprenticeship presents itself, uh you should probably do that. It's likely going to be affordable for you uh given the financial aid. And the employment outcomes for those, you know, whether it's top 20, top 50 schools continue to be very strong because employers uh rely on the brand value of those institutions. And that signals that students who were, you know, high had high cognitive skills, high durable skills at the age of 18, and were when they were admitted, they're being outputted and they're likely going to be strong employees. So that's that's a great, a great signal and certainly worth worth pursuing. The third category is you're gonna be a STEM major. And that changing, right? Computer science is not as reliable a major as it was, say, five years ago. For the most part, if you're gonna major in STEM, uh you're going to, you're gonna have a strong return on investment, regardless of what, uh assuming you complete, regardless of what college you attend. Again, there are exceptions. Computer science, perhaps now, biology, if you're not going into medical school, for the most part, STEM majors, engineers, uh, engineering majors in particular, is a is a very, very good bet to make. Uh, fourth would be if you don't fall into any of those, you're not rich, you're not getting into an Ivy League or Ivy Plus school, you're not a STEM major, you better attend a university uh or college that has something like a co-op program or has some way systematically of connecting you with uh work experience beyond just simply saying, oh, we have lots of internships listed on handshake or available in the career center. That's not enough. And there has to be a systematic way of matching you, connecting you, and integrating it into the program. Uh if they don't have that, uh then you're not checking any of the other three boxes. Then the ROI from enrolling in college is likely going to be questionable. And certainly if you're taking on debt, you may be better off looking for alternatives. Uh, could be apprenticeship. If one, if you can find one. Again, we have a huge, a huge shortage of these programs right now relative to other developed countries. Could be Chipotle. Uh, you know, you may there are lots of lots of young people who would be better off working for a few years in a retail job and seeing where that where that leads, as opposed to taking on debt, enrolling, perhaps not completing, or best case, uh graduating and then you know being underemployed.
SPEAKER_01This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supported tutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. So the apprenticeship, a lot of people just associate that with being blue collar. You're saying that's changing now, that the modern apprenticeship is different.
SPEAKER_00And now we in fact last year was the first year. Last year was the first year where more new apprenticeships were created outside the building trades than inside the building trades. So it is changing. And that's what uh we're working on it achieve. It's the the organization I co-founded Apprenticeships for America, which is the trade association of apprenticeship sponsors and intermediaries focused outside the building trade. So in tech, in healthcare, in financial services, in logistics. In other countries, it's actually quite common to, for example, launch a career as an accountant by being an apprentice as opposed to going to college to do it. And so we're very focused on changing public policy at the federal and state level and funding to try to catch up to where other countries are on apprenticeship so that it's common to be able to launch. But we think there should be as many apprentice jobs as there are seats in college, so that somebody graduating from college might be able to, you know, apply to six different colleges and apply to six different apprenticeships and decide. Do I want to invest in myself and pay tuition and take on debt and surface forward of you know five years later and sort of see where I am? Or do I want to take a more conservative approach and earn and learn my way forward? We just we just don't have that option now because as I said, we've dramatically underinvested in earn and learn and overinvested in college for all.
SPEAKER_01So what what opportunities are there in in the blended world of so like I'm on the fence, right? I'm a parent of a kid who Yeah, I mean, like, I don't my really the career development didn't exist in our school. We don't know what we're doing. I guess we'll go to college. Or maybe they're good, they they maybe they like some STEM stuff, but maybe they don't have grades for STEM, or they really don't know if it's a good investment. What are the possibilities of something that they could get in and be extremely successful in and honestly earn a high income? Because that's I think that's college is always seen as the safe bet to a middle class life of just secure job. Whereas now, I mean, you could you could leave a technical program as a as an electrician, as an HVAC specialist, or some little options are out there where you're employable, you have no debt, and you're making really, really good money.
SPEAKER_00Well, there's I mean that's the problem. We have a shortage of these alternative programs. Uh there are not enough apprenticeship uh programs in the trades. Uh, there certainly are plenty of uh schools that will enroll you in a trades uh program, but you still have to, you know, complete it and graduate into an apprenticeship. Apprenticeships are jobs, all right? Just to be clear, these are not training programs, they're jobs where there's an employer willing to hire and pay you before you become productive and certified. So there's a shortage of them for obvious reasons, which is that most companies aren't interested. In hiring and paying a worker who's not yet productive. So that that's uh other countries have solved that uh by either requiring uh organizations by law, like in Germany, to do the work of setting up and running these programs and hiring these apprentices, or in England, Australia, France, Canada, incentivizing organizations to set them up and run them and paying them for every apprentice hired and trained. Uh we don't we're we we we've now actually in the last year, thanks in part to our work, we've made the turn at the federal level. So we're gonna be starting to fund apprenticeships in that way at the federal level. Uh, but the the dollars are still tiny. I talked about in my book how, you know, depending on how you look at it, we are funding a classroom-based learning college for for every sorry, for every dollar uh that we spend on earn and learn apprenticeships, federal and state government, we're spending $1,000 on college classroom-based learning. And for every dollar that an apprentice receives in support, a college student receives $50. So that ratio is off. I'm not sure whether it should be one to one, but it shouldn't shouldn't be at that uh thousand 50 to 1 level. So we need to fix how we fund these alternative programs and then increase the the funding so that uh we kind of have a level playing field uh between tuition-based, classroom-based, debt-based, uh, post-secondary education, and earn and learn pathways.
SPEAKER_01Where is the smart money going? Where is the investment going right now? Where has the investment been on this space?
SPEAKER_00Well, we're doing three things. I'd like to think we're smart. We've certainly been successful. Uh the first is, as I described, we're building these apprenticeship programs in sectors where there are talent shortages and accelerating the growth of companies we buy. Second is uh we're now, we just actually today announced our the expansion of our workforce strategy into internships. Uh so we invested in a company called Alchemy, which is the first internship service provider. So they partner will partner with hundreds of universities, essentially providing a co-op program in a box. So, for example, they you can go on on the site right now as an employer and by inputting a couple of business goals or KPIs, develop a very detailed four, eight, or twelve-week internship work plan. So what the intern should be doing every hour of every day for up to 12, up to 12 weeks. And then Alchemy hires the intern, matches them to the employer, onboards them, and helps manage their work for the employer, serving as the employer of record. And that's the the same reason we don't have enough internships, is the reason we don't have enough internships, is the same reason we don't have enough apprenticeships, which is most employers aren't in the business of hiring and paying unproductive workers, and the supervision cost and all the other costs of setting up and running these programs is predictive. So they need help, and all of our apprenticeship do that. They serve as what we call apprenticeship intermediaries. This is the first, Alchemy is the first internship intermediary. And so, yeah, we're excited about that. Uh, we think that this is going to be a whole new category of uh opportunity within higher education companies that specialize in setting up and running internship programs for uh employers, uh, which is what Alchemy uh is uh is doing with its AI platform. So that's one direction. A second direction is what we call talent marketplaces. So uh workforce development, if you if you think about everything we've been talking about, really outside of the sort of college sphere, these alternative sphere, tends to fall under the bucket of workforce development, right? Apprenticeship programs, sort of, you know, uh boot camp training programs. That's all under workforce development. And workforce development is actually a sort of state and local, you know, in your in your in your town, you will have a workforce development board, and that board receives federal funding to help those who are uh unemployed or underemployed find jobs and also upskill. So the problem is that uh workforce development in this country is a mess. Uh, it's disorganized, and we're not using technology yet to solve these problems. So we've invested in the first uh what we call talent marketplace that sits on top of workforce agencies as sort of a career navigation layer. So someone, even a even a high school graduate, can go onto this talent marketplace, create a resume or upload their resume, identify their skills, identify uh jobs in their region that they immediately match to, or look at what might be in their zone of proximal development, identify up skilling opportunities and the jobs they may qualify for in six, twelve, twenty-four months uh that they should be aiming for. So that's the kind of you know, GPS, if you will, a human GPS that uh we don't have that we need, and the technology and AI can actually do a great job there.
SPEAKER_01You've called the four-year degree the most expensive default decision Americans make. That's obviously a pretty heavy claim, but it's becoming more and more realistic now as just some state schools are now a hundred thousand dollar investment. Walk me through why that is now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, it's all it's all about the return on investment, right? If everyone graduated from with a uh first one, you know, not everyone graduates, right? Sometimes many schools, the selective schools, do a much better job at graduating students than others. Uh, but the average graduation rate in this country, I think, is 60%. So 40% aren't aren't completing from their uh from their programs. And then those that do complete, like I said, something like 40% of those uh are graduating into underemployment. And that's not the fault of colleges or universities. I think they're doing as good a job as they've ever done at equipping young people with cognitive skills and durable skills. What's changed is is digital transformation, technology, and the labor market. The way we hire is different. The jobs that young people uh need to are being hired into are very different. The skills are different, and as a result, it's not simply enough to just have those cognitive skills and durable skills. You also need technical skills, platform skills, and relevant work experience. And colleges just simply haven't kept up with that. So as a result, you know, that's why I said at the outset, uh, the majority of those who make the decision to matriculate into college are not experiencing positive economic results. There are those out there who continue to cite old data to support the fact that the college degree continues to have a premium. They're they're not taking into account that those who enroll in and complete a college degree were probably more likely to be successful anyway, because they come from families of means and and uh the fact that most of that data is is is older. So if you take in in aggregate, the college educated workforce, uh someone who graduated 20, 30 years ago, they graduated into a very different labor market than those who graduated just last month did. And those who graduated just last month are facing all of the challenges and pressures that I've talked about. And I hope that they have had in-field paid work experience uh before they graduate, because otherwise they will they they will be at a real handicap. And unless there's some sort of family connection that they're making or they get really lucky, they might have a hard time launching.
SPEAKER_01What about student debt? You say it's the symptom, not the problem. What do you mean by that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh, I mean, I I I uh I do think that debt obviously plays a big role in that ROI calculation. Like I said, if you if you don't have if you if you have means, you have savings, and sending your student uh through uh you know four years of of college is not going to require you to go into debt, then your ROI is probably gonna be okay, right? It it or or maybe you don't care the ROI because uh you had the money saved and and uh uh allocated to that purpose anyway. Um but I think those who those who are taking on debt uh because they feel like college is the only path, uh, that's really unfortunate and a result of, I think, uh bad or misguided policy over the last uh you know 30, 40 years. No other country has gone as far in the college for all direction as we have. And we're at a disadvantage now because of it, in large part because, as I said at the outset, the skills that companies are looking for are harder to learn in a classroom than they are by doing. And so we should have been more thoughtful and imaginative around post-secondary education and career launch, really tried to foster a multitude of different pathways for economic mobility as opposed to focusing on uh the pathway that worked for the elite, you know, two, three, four generations ago.
SPEAKER_01So the student I mean, obviously that's what contributes to the student debt crisis, is that yeah, I mean it's like it's unbelievable where we're at right now. And your your solution to the apprenticeship seems to be some government intervention. Do you also see that as a necessity to well, obviously government probably should reform how we how we give out student student loans and cap, but do you see that as a possible uh additional solution to pushing more families to look towards apprenticeships?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, that's not the issue. You open up an apprenticeship in a desirable field, you'll have hundreds of applicants for every seat. It'll be more selective than Harvard. Uh so that's not the issue. You don't need to you don't need to shift demand. What we need to do is we need to increase the supply of these earn and learn opportunities, of these apprenticeships and internship programs. And so I do think government definitely has a role to play there. We need to have a more equal approach to funding work-based learning as opposed and classroom-based uh learning. Uh, and we need to make sure we fund it correctly. But I absolutely think in five years' time, a company that's hiring and uh paying an apprentice in a desirable field, you know, in Europe, the you know, companies that do that in Europe, they're getting $15,000, $20,000 from the government to do that. We should we should do that as well. Uh that it absolutely makes economic sense for the country, strong return on investment for the uh the individual and the company that's going to employ them and for the taxpayer. That's actually a better investment than we've been making in higher education today. And I think that logic also extends to internships. We should be supporting internships, and we're going to need to, because AI is about to decimate entry-level jobs and internships, for that matter. The work that first, second-year workers, junior workers, and interns used to do is going to increasingly be done by AI. I just read an article that said that investment banks are have already announced that they're dramatically slimming their hiring after this year to the point where today you might have 10 analysts supporting a managing director at a bank. In a few years it'll be one-to-one because that analyst is going to be expected to be using a host of AI tools and agents to do the work of 10.
SPEAKER_01So AI is going to be extremely disruptive. What questions should families be asking colleges that they're currently not asking?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the biggest one is work-based learning. You know, they're they they they they take a tour, they're mesmerized by the architecture, the dorm, the dining hall, and so forth, all that is is great. But at the end of the day, uh the economic uh outcome or return is unlikely to be there, again, outside of the most selective schools, outside of STEM, uh, unless there is a uh concrete systematic work-based learning program that the university runs. And that could be a co-op-like program that either they run themselves, like Northeastern, or the partners with, for example, our company, Alchemy, to do the co-op in a box that I mentioned. Or it could be sort of an extension of what is known today as clinical education, right? Law schools run clinics uh and provide students, uh, law students with relevant work experience in those clinics. University of Iowa journalism school bought a uh a series of community newspapers for their students to work on and have that work experience. And so reimagining ways in which through for-profit or nonprofit businesses, your students can actually do real relevant in-field and hopefully paid work before they graduate is essential. Unfortunately, it's foreign faculty that attended decades and graduated decades ago. And the classroom-based model worked perfectly well. Back then, it doesn't work very well anymore, and or doesn't work well for most anymore. And what's required is really thinking outside the box approach to how to integrate employment with education.
SPEAKER_01I want to end on this, Ron. What it if a parent could only do one thing after listening to this, what should it be?
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, I've I'm just writing about this now, the summer job market. I would say have your teen work. I mean, again, unless you fall into one of those four categories or three categories I mentioned, if you know, return on investment isn't important to you because you have the money saved or you know, you can afford to send your child, you know, ha have them do real work during high school to get a job. Novel idea. Work at work at Chipotle, you know, I work as a busboy, you know, Jeff Salingos, groof scooped ice cream. These are all uh, you know, really useful skills and work begets work. And uh somebody who's graduating from college who has a series of you know enriching volunteer activities and extracurricular activities, again, unless they fall into one of those categories I mentioned, uh is going to be at a real disadvantage.
SPEAKER_01Well, Ryan, I appreciate your time and coming on the podcast. It's been kind of eye-opening, definitely a change of pace than the people we usually talk to who are like pushing college by all means and pathways to college. Obviously, it still plays a role, but I love what your work is doing and the alternative options out there. And I absolutely think you're you're definitely on to something. I think you're ahead of the curve in where we're going, especially with AI. For people who want to learn more about you, go deeper with you, where can they find you and check check out first?
SPEAKER_00They can they can subscribe to my newsletter, gapletter.com.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. And uh, I guess before we wrap, what's one thing you want people to remember from this conversation?
SPEAKER_00You know, just just just because college worked for you, it doesn't mean it's gonna, you know, the the economy is just think about how different the economy is now from when you and you know we all graduated into you know and started started work so different now. So the lessons that we learned about you know what worked then uh really don't apply anymore. So just you know have a have an open mind.
SPEAKER_01All right, and thank you again. I appreciate you coming on. And uh for all those watching, thanks for uh tuning into the Supported Learning Podcast. We'll see you next time. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.