SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 81 - Admissions Insider: Your Kid’s Perfect Checklist Is Why They’re Getting Rejected - David Reynaldo
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with David Reynaldo, founder and CEO of College Zoom and a 17-year veteran of college admissions consulting, to expose what actually happens behind the admissions desk and why the standard checklist approach is failing families.
Dr. Joe and David discuss the two-part admissions test most families don’t know exists, why clearing the GPA and test-score hurdle is only the beginning, what Harvard’s federal lawsuit data revealed about how rubric scores drive admissions outcomes, why passion projects and published research have become the new meaningless checkbox, how Bloom’s Taxonomy maps onto what the most selective schools are actually scoring for, and why the admit rate multiplier claims that consulting firms promote are structurally misleading.
This episode is especially useful for parents of competitive high schoolers applying to top-20 or Ivy League schools, families who have invested in passion projects or summer programs expecting an admissions edge, anyone evaluating whether to hire a college admissions consultant, and students trying to understand what “fit” actually means on an admissions rubric.
📲 Connect with them: https://collegezoom.com/
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@CollegeZoom
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Book a call: supportedtutoring.com/book-call-youtube
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. He has spent 17 years reverse engineering the actual scoring rubrics of the most selective universities in the country, Ivy League, USC, the UC system, and many more. And he's been openly critical of the emissions industry he works inside, calling out its misleading success metrics and the checklist mentality that's turning high-achieving students into indistinguishable, indistinguishable applicants. David Ronaldo has built College Zoom into one of the most data-driven emissions consulting firms in the country. Today we're getting into what colleges actually are looking for, how to stop playing the wrong game. And uh really, really interested in kind of diving deep into this, the whole, the whole landscape of where we currently are. So welcome back to Support Learning Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Joseph Beshan. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars in years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people who have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. That's why I'm thrilled to have David Ronaldo here today. David is the founder and CEO of College Zoom, a research-driven one-on-one emissions consulting firm he built in 2009 while at USC, Go Trojans. I guess, but you're in like Pasadena. So we're over 17 years. He's been known for specific edge in the crowded industry, reverse engineering, the actual scoring rubrics of top universities, and building data-driven high school specific strategies for individual students. He is a member of NACAC and WACAC. He's been outspoken about industry transparency, misleading success metrics, and the checklist mentality that's hurting families. So we're going to dive into what emissions offices actually score, why the standard checklist approach is producing indistinguishable applicants and how AI is reshaping the game and what every parent of a competitive student needs to know. David, welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Dr. Joe, for having me. It's a pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Uh, respect to USC. I'm a Steeler fan, Pittsburgh, Troy Palomalo. I've always loved even though like I grew up undoted aim fan, and you know, I still I still kind of low-key like USC, especially during the height of Pete Carroll. So you were there for it. So like the Reggie Bush, the Bush push, all that stuff. That's awesome. Yeah. So I got it, I got a USC uh Troy Palomalo jersey. My bucket list is to see a U C L A USC game. So I will have to hopefully when I'm visiting California, have to hit you up on that.
SPEAKER_00So I have a house divided flag in the closet. Every November that thing comes out, and we fly that flag and license plates as well.
SPEAKER_02So it's uh But you guys are so chill in California. You don't you don't take like football novels for yeah, is it like I mean it's not Michigan, Ohio State, like people like people assault each other, right? So yeah, but um David, you've been in this space as long as I've been in education, actually a year longer. Um, and you know, you founded College Zoom in 2009. That's 17 years. Um, you I I know we're gonna have a lot to talk about, and uh, but I guess just in a 60-second snapshot, what specific problem do you solve for families in education and learning?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so the biggest problem that I solved is that by the time that families get to me, they've been so inundated with social media. Every expert has a different opinion. And I explained that contradiction is not just common, but it's expected within the exact same admissions office. And so what I've done is I've been able to take the rubric that sits behind the admissions desk, reverse engineer it, decode all the data, and be able to show people where do you stand on this rubric? Where are you strong? Where are you weak, and what does that mean for your candidacy moving forward? And what's nice about that is that in every admissions office, the student will get at least two reviewers, right? If they can grade the kid within a very small margin of error and they're spot on, then it's a done deal. Wash the hands, right? The kid's um rating is locked in. If it's a split vote, a third person breaks the tie or it goes to a committee. And when you can understand how the rubric is aligning the conversations that are happening behind the desk, you have a much better understanding of what version of you as a student will authentically fit what the college is looking for instead of having to guess, you know, what side of me do they want to see? Who should I present myself as when um, you know, uh it doesn't have to be a guessing game.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. So you actually founded this while you were an undergrad at USC?
SPEAKER_00I did. You know, the the long story short is it started as a class project where um the professors pulled my class into a room and they said, you know, we caught wind at some East Coast colleges are starting a class in their entrepreneurship programs where you actually start a business and run it for like six, nine weeks, um, whatever the semester was long. Uh, do you guys want to do that? And of course we're all like, yeah, because it was going to replace uh a class that was simply just, you know, sit down, listen to a guest lecture, and through osmosis, learn how to be successful. And every hand in the room raised that they were opting into this class, except for like a fifth, uh, fifth year senior. And so they said, okay, it's not legally approved because it's not in the curriculum. Uh, but take this class, we'll replace it with this class. The dean is okay with it, but just you know, no one complained that it's a bait and switch class. And I'm like, okay, that was the class where college was born. And um, my two partners dropped out very quickly. Because as we talked a little bit earlier, college admissions can be a bit like alligator wrestling, right? But I I actually really liked it. Uh, I'm I guess I'm used to wrestling alligators. Uh, and so uh I have a real passion for the work.
SPEAKER_02So I guess in those 17 years, what's the biggest thing that has changed in the space from your perspective?
SPEAKER_00You know, what's really interesting is that the actual game has not changed, but a lot of the trends that people propagate as to what colleges want cycle in and out like fashion statements. Um what I would say is like, yeah, like um uh one of the anecdotes I could tell families is from a MIT admissions presentation that I found online a couple of years ago. And the admissions director was talking about, you know, these are the trends of who MIT is admitting. And what's really unique about MIT is that they have an office of institutional research. And so every year they survey certain things, and one of them are the most popular extracurricular trends that the admits of MIT have taken, right? And around the year 2000, the trend was community service. And the around the year 2010, it changed to academic competitions. Uh by 2020, uh it was tied. Internships and published research were the top two. Uh and what's crazy is that in those 30 plus years, the actual rubric that MIT uses did not change. And in all those 30 plus years, they were still looking for the exact same kind of kid, um, despite the fact that all these kind of urban legends of who MIT is looking for this year, you need research or you don't have a chance, all those things would take off. But the actual foundations of what MIT wanted were, you know, generation to generation the same. And so what I find is that while there's a lot of noise around what's changing, the things that matter don't change because, in a way, being successful, being passionate, being good at what you do is very timeless. And a lot of times I use another analogy that college admissions is a little bit like a poker game. Uh, and everyone knows that the best hand in poker wins. But a lot of times kids are so obsessed about being different, you know, they'll play like a really bad hand just to be like, this is a unique hand, right? And it's like, no, but it wasn't good, it didn't rank high. So um that's uh the more things change, the more they kind of stay the same, you know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, that's like we you know, as an ambitious teacher, like you know, you kind of like, yeah, new, new professional, like there's a lot of trends or things like that. And now I'm I've been in long enough to see this, like literally trends in education cycle through through what what's riveting PD and just kind of like pendulum swing. So it's interesting. Like, is there new ideas? So it's interesting that's happening in parallel in the college admissions space. Um, so you've you're you're a member of two distinguished organizations um in the landscape, and you're actually been openly critical of the college admissions industry. We were talking about it before we started recording. Um what made you take that consumer advocate stance? Like what are you seeing that is making you this critical or the critical advocate of this of the space that you're in?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I I would say this the reason why a lot of parents get very zany around the admissions process, um, which is why, you know, we uh in Germany use the term alligator handler, is because it's one of the most pivotal times in a young person's life where they're going to be trusting an outside professional to come in and guide this young child to be successful and enter adulthood. And, you know, what irks me, and this is maybe just my personality, like I I studied business and entrepreneurship at USC. So it was all about disruption. How do you, you know, uh jump the value chain and deliver the ultimate value to customers. And when I got into the admissions industry, I just realized that there was a lot of parroting of advice that people would hear, but they would almost like turn off common sense because it was the popular safe thing to say, right? And I'll I'll give you a quick example. I was at a WACAT conference once when I was really like new in the industry, and I met a guy from MIT. Uh and I was excited. I was like, you know, I didn't have that much exposure to the East Coast. I was like, oh, I'm really excited to hear about your practice and what you do and how you advise students because everyone says, you know, the East Coast is different. And this was around 2012, 2011. So right around when community service was the trend, right? Uh for applicants. And he says, Well, you know, I just tell them uh do community service, join these clubs. And I'm sitting here thinking like, wait, wait, like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. And my literal words to him was like, well, you know, that that's all bullshit, right? And and then he literally tells me, he goes, Yeah, yeah, I know, but like everyone else is telling them that. So I don't want to be the only guy not saying it. So, and I was just like, I was amazed. And well, in 2014, NACAC, the National Association, came out with an industry report. And it was really interesting because it was all based on upward career progression within the admissions industry. And it really lays bare the fact that you'll see how this all springs into why I'm very critical of admissions consulting as independent. But it was talking about how your typical admissions officer will spend about maybe two, three years in a single admissions office, right? Uh, the pay is not the best. You're constantly on the road, you're constantly, you know, maybe sleeping in the rental car, waking up in a school parking lot, then you're talking to school families at like a junior night. Um, good luck having a boyfriend, a girlfriend, a family, you know, all that stuff. And people at the top don't really move out. You know, they got a good job. So if you want to move up, you got to move, move out to move up, or you go work at a school or you become independent. And so it's a lot of very high attrition. And so you get these people who have like in like a big consulting brand, right? They have the brand name on the resume, but then they start going into admissions consulting. And, you know, the nature of a lot of admissions work is like it's like clerical, it's like bureaucratic, right? You're you're sorting through docs, you're looking for trends, you're getting them on a rubric. But when you switch over to the actual practice of being an admissions consultant, you're no longer just a repeater of patterns that you've seen in the office. The job really requires you to be a mentor, a coach, someone who can help a kid strategically write and strategize how to best present themselves to open doors. And that's a skill that most admissions professionals uh have never developed. If they have developed it, it's become, it's come kind of in addition to their work in the admissions office, but not because of the work in the admissions office. And so most of the critical things you'll hear people talk about, you know, online as to why a college coach may or not be worth it, might be they're telling me things I already know. Uh, I don't want to pay an overpriced librarian. I can use AI, I can use the, you know, uh, the knowledge bank myself and look up things online. Um, but at its core, you really want an admissions consultant to really be a guide on a student's right of passage and transform the kid in some way. And when you look at these exorbitant prices that a lot of firms pay, you know, a lot of families just do equate high prices to quality, especially yeah. And so you end up with a lot of predatory practices where people make the uh, you know, that's the halo effect. Oh, you worked in the admissions office, right? So you must know how it works. But they don't know that the Ivy League admissions officers, like a 23-year-old who maybe went to like Baylor or Iowa or you're serious, right? And and and and they don't they don't know anything about this, but now admissions and and the NACAC report literally said that most of the people who work in admissions are oftentimes falling into it happenstance. They worked as a tour guide, they worked as a a clerk in the admissions office, maybe they had, you know, didn't really have that many career prospects. So that's how they find their way into becoming an admissions officer. So it's it's wild, it's wild.
SPEAKER_02No, I I will I'll I'll give you some context. So if I'm a little long-winded, I apologize. Like I, you know, I've been in education for 17 years as an educator, teacher, administrator, and then you know, with this test prep company, um started in 21. I made it till 2023. I never heard what a I no idea what a college coach was. College consultant, never, never heard of it, never seen ads for it. Um, within two years, the knowledge of what I have, I've gone like it's probably come full circle. It's like I was like fascinated to like holy crap, this is a toxic industry. Like this is the information, the inundation of just buzzwords of things that don't make sense and the competition and the brand name drops and all these things. And I'm like, it's not even it's not even grounded in those educational practices. So I I've seen it, and maybe I don't I'm naive to the buckets, but I see it like this. I see the buckets as there is there are groups of former emissions officers that have started or signed on to companies, lended their credentials uh to form a company that that's their like their Ivy League because their person was an emissions officer at one of the Ivy League schools. Great. My all my pushback question is like well, for that school, it's like what of what about the other schools? Like, what about you know, like it's the stats. So, but that's gonna leverage high brand, high pricing, fear of there's a secret that you don't know on how to get into this Ivy League, and and by nature of them, they're no they're a former emissions officer, they have now lost the context of what they're currently looking for, I would assume. But that's called that's called that's called logic. So let's move on. Right? So, like then you have you have the big box brands that we've talked about that actually I've looked on their job uh in like they're I've seen their stuff on LinkedIn and then D. I think I could get hired as a college consultant for one of those companies. Like there's no, it's brand and mark, it's brand marketing sales and not really authentic requirements in educational space. And then I see the group, I think like I it's the independent consultants that have authentically learned this process, have credentials, and kind of live in both spaces of they understand the mentoring part of the team to navigate through the high school journey and match it with how to actually build that application in college missions. I think that's where the true value lies if you're gonna hire someone. Correct me if I'm wrong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, and I say if you look at the big firms, like just go to their Glassdoor reviews and you'll see like fire, fire, fire everywhere. Um, you know, I I would say this. Uh gosh, like I've nowhere to dive in with this, but uh oh god. I mean, you kind of like just blew my mind. Yes, it's a wild industry. And I'll tell you that there's there is one thing that's really interesting. Um, if you talk to most admissions officers, what they'll say is that they've moved maybe from one admissions office to the next. And a lot of times you'll hear ones who move in similar uh tiers of selectivity say, oh yeah, it was like really easy because like, you know, Stanford or Northwestern look for the exact same kind of kid, right? And you're like, okay, okay, tell me more. And then you hear, oh yeah, uh, I moved from USC to Boston College. It was really easy to look, they look for the exact same kind of kid. And right. And that's like the inside speak. But of course, on the outside, oh, every college wants something different. I have to curate. But I'm gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna break it down to you uh how it really is. I was a business major, right? So I I I I studied and understand organizational behavior and branding and marketing and all this stuff. If you understand the automobile market, you'll understand college admissions. Um and think of it this way colleges occupy college families within the education market, right? You'll have your SUVs, you got your pickup trucks, you got your Ferraris. But if I'm in the market for an SUV, maybe I'll look at a minivan, but I don't want a convertible coop, right? I don't want a sports car. So kids will actually self-select oftentimes into one or two college families within which they're looking for the same kind of kid, but it's the actual admit rate that changes how much luxury of choice the college has to be selective about the extent to which the student really embodies the virtues and qualities that they want to see in the class. And so over 17 years, I would say that the most phenomenal thing that I've seen, which is why I say the more the game changes, the more it stays the same, is that the actual college will not change in its virtues or principles, but when it starts to get more selective, like USC, going from, you know, an easy school to get into to being a hard one, UPen in the 80s being really easy. Now it's super hard. Um, you'll even see this now with Northeastern, right? Playing the early decision racket to like try to reduce its admit rate. They start to accept and attract a different caliber of student as their brand rises, right? And what happens is like UC Santa Barbara, for example, I went on a tour there in 2017, and it was a period within like four years, its admit rate dropped 10%. So it entered a whole new league, right, of um caliber of students of who it was able to attract. And I remember the tour guide there, she was remarking how it was wild because every class from freshmen, sophomores, juniors, and seniors at EC Santa Barbara was so like categorically different in just terms of who they were, how they operated. And I told her, I said, you know that why, right? Because the admit rate has dropped so fast that the admit rate being the like the controlling factor in who they're admitting, they're able to get a certain kind of kid. And of course, everyone likes to say, I'm more than a GPA, but what you'll find is that there are certain psychological profiles that correspond to a GPA. So when I myself was a 3.1 student in high school and later became a student in college, very different patterns of behavior and operating system in here, right? Um, and so when colleges use that GPA uh to thin out the preliminary pool of applicants, who's left over will be a different cut of applicant based on their admit rate. So it's really interesting. And when I tell families, like, you know, it's not the unique school because it's part of the larger college family in the market, but it's the admit rate that really sets the bar on where that bar of admissions is. Uh, a lot of them are like, I haven't heard that before, but it just makes so much sense once you really unpack it all.
SPEAKER_02This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supportedtutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. Yeah, so get into your method of like reverse engineering the scoring rubrics because that's a big claim. Um can you break it down on what a top school is really scoring for? And that's ultimately kind of bleeding into the admit rate.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes, yes. So um, what I would describe is this, and I'll tell you how I came up with this method because first I didn't have the actual rubrics in the admissions office. I I found those ones out later, which then perfectly mapped onto the uh statistical model that I created. So when I started out, um, I was still in college and I was doing a lot of primary interviews with admissions officers. I was just trying to figure out like, you know, how does this all work? And what really teed me off was I had classmates at USC Marshall who had like 2.8 GPAs, 3.2 GPAs, 3.4 GPAs, and they all gone to like this top 10 business program. I it just it blew my mind. Like I was like, right, these these weren't the students, by the way, of color who would benefit from affirmative action. These were like, you know, a white. From Nevada, right? Like, no donors, no, no, no secret connections. It it just on the surface, it made no sense. And then I would talk to admissions officers, right? And one of them would be like, you know, like uh, she's like, hey, uh, a kid needs to have like a 3.5 GPA at minimum, and then they can be competitive. And yeah, I'm like, well, but you just admitted kids with way below that, right? Didn't make sense. Another admissions officer, uh, oh I hey boyfriend essays, automatic rejection. Long story short, she ends up admitting a girl who wrote a boyfriend essay. And I was like, I was like, they're saying one thing and then they contradict each other. It's like, it none of it made sense. And I was like, how do I find this out? So through trying to reverse engineer with their decision-making process and using institutional data and data I got from high schools and all this, I basically deduced that there was a two-part process to the admissions process. Now, of course, every college handles it differently and there will be different mechanisms, but I like to oversimplify things for teenagers because they can grab the concept much easier when it's simple. And I describe it as a track and field analogy where there's a two-part test, I tell them. And I say the first test that you go through is an academic hurdle test. So, like in track and field, right? There's hurdle events where you have to hop over every single hurdle. And it doesn't matter whether you skim over that hurdle by the skin of your teeth or if you pull vault 20 feet over it, if you're over, you're over. And if you can hop over all the different academic hurdles, your unweighted GPA, your weighted GPA, your standardized test score if required, you can be in the next pool, right? And what most kids don't realize is that that skin of your teeth clearing the hurdle is the bottom 25th percentile of the admitted pool, right? And they'd think like, oh, like, you know, uh, I'm a value troan, like that's got to count for something. But actually, once you clear that hurdle, even though you're below average, you're on to the next game, the goalposts change. And now all the academic prowess you had above that, that can help you with scholarships and merit-based aid, but that doesn't carry over now to the second event, which is what most kids are blind to because it's more abstract. And the second test that fools a lot of people or surprises them, I like to analogize that to the long jump of income track and field, where now there are actual virtues and qualities that the school is gonna be looking for. And it's how far can you jump in being a strong embodiment of each of those qualities that define that campus's, you know, definition of fit. And the better you can demonstrate fit, no matter what your academic profile was, as long as it was passing, is gonna give you the best odds of being admitted. Now, of course, there is subjectivity because, like, you know, again, simplifying here, uh, it might be that the regional admissions officer has 50 kids, no fake numbers of 50 kids that they're excited about that, technically scored high enough to be admitted, right? And then the associate dean comes through and says, Hey, uh, I need you to cut it down to 20. And then they have to start deleting kids, you know, or putting them to the wait list, right? So that's where you start to see the variance of institutional goals come into play. But when it comes to just the bare bones, like, can I get myself a high enough score to be in the conversation? That model, you'll see the hurdle jump and then the long jump are really the best, you know, that's the best framework I've been able to come up with to be able to tell kids this is how that works. And if you want to be smart about how you spend your time, you know, whether it's how much of that is academic, how much of that is fit, that's where we can start. So you can understand like that you're playing two games, it's not just one.
SPEAKER_02So the in those games, like you like you said and said at the beginning, the you're against the checklist mentality, um that it does produce kind of indistinguishable applicants. What what do you mean by that? And what is the alternative?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so the checklist mentality, um what I would say is is this. Um I have a really good knowledge I use for medical school when we do med school, med school admissions. And I tell the kids that, you know, if I'm gonna again overgeneralize, there's two different kinds of people who tend to apply to med school. The first kind is barely able to get one med school acceptance offer, or they may have to retry in a future cycle. And the other kind of med school applicant has like three, four, five, six different offers, potentially with scholarship. And the difference is that the first kind of applicant is barely able to get one. They're taking biology because it has all the pre-med prerequisites, right, for their major already baked into the major. Or ironically, people don't know that history is the number one most popular major for pre-meds in America. Um, nothing to do with medicine, but because it's an easier major, they can spend all their time on the weeder classes like organic chemistry that are meant to, you know, mess up their pre-med GPA. So those kids who are going through a checklist mentality, they're doing what needs to be done. They're looking for cutting corners. They're just gonna, you know, write about, I want to be a doctor to help people. Someone in my family had a condition. This is what inspires me. It's like, it's like a filmmaker saying, the first time I saw Jurassic Park, the first time I saw Jaws, this first time I saw Avatar, it's a very predictable, like, I want, but what have I done, right? And the other kind of applicant who has multiple offers, they actually match the way that the institution wants them to solve problems. And I'll preface this by saying it's not just med school, but if you look at the top Ivy League, even the top 20 universities like UCLA, even even though the ECs are more of like a, you know, uh a number is just you you go and you go through like, you know, the process and get your degree, um, you'll find that all of them encode some form of interdisciplinary, lateral thinking, or liberal art style of education in their actual mission statement, right? And what you'll find is that when you actually think about like who the kids are who are racking up all these admissions offers, they're the ones who basically combine two different brains in one body. So for example, like an aspiring doctor, right? The first group only was I'm an aspiring doctor. That's my whole identity. The second group is I'm an aspiring doctor who also has the mind of an engineer, who also has the mind of a business person, or an aspiring doctor who's also like the mind of a lawyer or an anthropologist or a sociologist or whatever, right? And it's that ability to combine two different modalities of talent in one body, that number one is a wow factor, because you don't kind of expect that kind of depth in someone usually. But also when someone has that, they have such an eclectic mental toolkit of how to pull from to solve problems that you find that they tend to be much more motivated, they tend to be much more inspired, much more creative in how they go about solving problems, they tend to be much more invested. Um, because in order to be interdisciplinary at their core, there really has to be an authentic level of learning. I mean, every single kind of synonym or moniker that you've heard that admissions officers look for, you can basically find that attached to somebody who's authentically interdisciplinary and how they solve problems. And so um, you know, if you're just doing a checklist, you'll never be more than one-dimensional, one modality because all your focus is focused on one thing. And there's a concept called the um uh have you ever heard of Bloom's Taxonomy? Mm-hmm. We actually have it in our ads, yeah. Oh, perfect, perfect, perfect. Okay, cool. Well, the way I break it down for the families is I say, hey, there's this thing called Bloom's Taxonomy. It's the most famous education framework. Uh, and it's was used back in the day to help educators figure out, you know, how do you set benchmarks for levels of cognition. So if you're building a curriculum, if you're building, you know, a series of classes for certification, this is how you know how to level kids up, right? And at the bottom of Bloom's Taxonomy, you basically have um, you know, the I can remember, I can understand levels of cognition, which is which is where most of society actually sits. And what people what blows people away is that that's where you might have your starting quarterback. That's where you might have the first string violinist, that's where you might have the kid who's winning all the spelling bees or the science fairs or math competitions. Why? Because to be a competitor, like a like a star pianist, it's it's muscle memory, it's repetition, it's it's almost like an athletic event where you're training your timed reactions and your touch on the ball, and that's what makes you win the awards. But if you're gonna start going up Bloom's Taxonomy to the very top where you start seeing like interdisciplinary creativity, right, and innovation, you're able to take two different disciplines and combine them to solve a problem, it's the smallest part of the pyramid because very few people in society can authentically do that. They probably don't know how. My personal opinion is that when you have a parent who's been in the IB or you've been to a liberal arts college and they they raise a child with that liberal arts interdisciplinary mindset, they're just more likely to think that way than someone in a general population like myself who was never exposed to that kind of thinking at all, right? Especially when you come from like an Asian background like me. Like, you know, it's like the emperor's exam, right? Just scroll high on the emperor's exam, you're at the right hand of the emperor. It's a whole different checklist mentality. Um, but uh, but what you'll find is that if you go up Bloom's taxonomy, it's like an English paper where there's a lot of different ways you can earn an A on an English paper. Um, and there's a lot of different ways you can authentically climb up Bloom's taxonomy, but it's it's something that requires a lot of self-reflection. It's literally a rite of passage for the kid to get up that high, and there's no checklist because there's there's two different modalities you have to develop. So it's it's a complete fish out of the water experience for kids who are accustomed to checklists. But you know, most human nature is I do this, I get that. And in order to really go up Loom's taxonomy, you have to be much more creative, risk taking, you know, all the things that colleges say that they want, because that's really what defines the American education system and why we're so innovative as a country, as opposed to a country where it's more of a rote memorization style of education.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. We talk about that in the crossover for AP exams that are teaching the content and memorization and really all the exams do is measure application, analysis, evaluation. So it's much, much higher on loose taxonomy. So that's kind of like the college landscape and the business of landscape, but let's talk about the parents because the parents have been pre-programmed now with sales and marketing that we need passion projects, we need internships, we need research. So I probably have a lot of similar conversations as you do. Um, but you've been in the industry, you I respect your uh tenure and your your experience. Um the those buzzwords that I hear, I mean, I there are people that are inundated that they think they need this and that they're but it sounds like they don't. And why is the industry leaning on that? Because it's funny, because I think the Ivy Leagues are like, we don't we don't care that you do a pay-to-pay program. Like it's not, it doesn't help you at all.
SPEAKER_00So like where's the where's the disconnect there? Well, the disconnect is that a passion project, published research, all of it is I do this, I get that. And most kids, if they're gonna do this to get that, they do the bare minimum. So they'll start a nonprofit. What did the nonprofit do? Well, probably not much, right? I did a pay-to-play summer program. Okay, I went there and I sat in a lecture at UChicago. What did I do beyond that? That made me send out. Well, nothing, right? So um, you know, the reason why these buzzwords exist is because when people are confused and they want a solution, the more tangible the solution feels, the more right it feels. Uh and just as a quick aside, the reason why I started to incorporate um admissions office rubrics into my practice was because when I was a young guy and I had my uh statistical model with all the hurdle and long jump, I was just David, you know, a guy with a spreadsheet that showed all this different stuff. But like David says this, but my school counselor says this, and the guy on YouTube says this. So who's gonna trust David? And when I got my hands on my first admissions rubric, um I still I still try to keep it secret because I don't want to get sued. Right. But it came, it came through a knack at connection, right? Um, I was able to overlay it with my model and I was like, it's a perfect fit. And so I realized it's like I'm gonna present the rubric and all the know-how behind it, you know, I'll put that behind it to give it meaning. But if a kid can see the rubric and see their place on it, it becomes a game map. It's not just a, you know, an arbitrary or rating system. But most admissions officers, uh, most uh admissions consultants never think to actually use a rubric to actually baseline their clients and figure out what their gaps are and all that. So instead of having a tangible rubric that can then give a kid a container to be more creative or be or grow, um they go to the next tangible thing, which is the passion project, published research. It sounds smart, it sounds like it fits what the college is looking for. And when you see one kid do it, now all the kids at the high school are now chasing to be that kid. But you know, it's like if you're trying to, you know, get recruited for a college sport, and this year, oh, uh a football player got recruited. I gotta play, I gotta play football, right? Maybe my buy's not made for football, right? But now everyone's gonna join the football team thinking, oh, I could get recruited too, which is not how it works. And it sounds so, so ridiculous when we talk about with physical athletics because it's very tangible, you get it. It's obvious to see it. But with college admissions, you have kids who, like, like, for example, we talk about as the leadership archetype of every kid, right? A kid might at their core be a teacher at heart or an inventor or a promoter or a team bonder or a nurturer or a you know, whatever. And we explain that you have like in a video game, when you choose your character that you play as, are you the warrior or are you the wizard? You have to play the game with your natural leadership style, right? Because if you're gonna do anything, call it a passion project, call it published research. The game is how do you stand out from other people who have the exact same or equivalent activities and titles and roles as you do? And if you just, you know, try to topically stand out saying, ooh, I have a lot of like nonprofit experience. Well, that's great. Maybe it's unique for your school, but but not in the whole regional applicant pool. So the question is if you combine, for example, I'm a teacher at heart and I do the volunteering. And here's how I combine those two modalities, right, in an interdisciplinary way to add more value to the organization. Um, it doesn't have to be a passion project, doesn't have to be published research, but the kid goes on their own personal hero's journey to raise the bar from where they found it. And the more they can do that, they're gonna have to grow in the same kind of qualities that would actually raise their rating on an admissions rubric. So the reason why I think it's so hard is because if someone said, like, hey, I can like sell you a hero's journey for college, you'd think, right? What am I buying? What does that mean? It sounds like bullshit, right? But if someone says, hey, I can sell you a passion project or publish research, you know, and you can work with a professor and it will help you get into Stanford or Yale or whatever, um, it's a much easier sell. It's a much easier sell, right? It just, it just, it's intuitively, it just seems to make sense. Um but that's because it makes sense because nobody really understands the way that the rubrics are working to grade kids. Uh, in fact, I'll tell you one quick little aside. Um, if you ask any admissions officer, you know, how much do the rubrics and the ratings actually matter? What they'll actually tell you, especially if they've been on a committee, is that the rubrics and the ratings are not that important. And they'll say instead, they'll say it's the starting point for a much larger conversation about the applicant and their context. And, you know, while that will be true, you know, from their perspective, you know, the benefit of doing research is that you see these macro level trends that the people who are in the system may not be, you know, aware of. And when Harvard got sued and you know, through Discovery, the their rubric, all 10 years of admissions data from Harvard got dragged into federal court. That thing was picked apart from every single angle. And what the data actually showed was Harvard, for example, has a five-category rubric. Um, if some well, well, first of all, they had a category of applicants called multidimensionally excellent, right? Same thing as interdisciplinary excellence, but they called it multidimensionally excellent. And that was a kid who could score high in at least, I think it was um three or more categories. Of, by the way, these were kids who I think were like less than 7% of the um total Harvard applicant pool. It was either two or more, or three or more, uh, that were like 7% of the actual pool. If a kid could score high in three out of Harvard's five categories, they had a 43% chance of getting to Harvard. If they scored high in four out of five categories, 68% chance of getting to Harvard. So even though it was always the starting point of a much larger conversation, the rubrics were putting the kids into these buckets in which those conversations were taking place. And the kids who were more multidimensionally excellent were the ones who were uh had the best chances of securing those admissions offers.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. Interesting. So where do you see emissions going in the next five to ten years with how disruptive AI is just admitted to education in general?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, it it's interesting. Um what I've found um from talking to a lot of other practitioners in the field is that the do-it-yourself market is gonna be the most disruptive. Um these are people who were looking for uh a quick fix, anyways. They uh, you know, I I personally I think one of the biggest problems with the essay market is that the essay is just one to two pages of like a five to seven page application. So whenever you're looking at the essay to like make a difference for you, you're looking through your whole application through like a straw, uh, and you know, judging the whole strategy based on that. But, you know, again, those are the last-minute applicants who are just coming in for an essay. They're looking through the whole process through a straw. They're now writing essays with AI and then asking live people to actually humanize it, which is just as it's as ridiculous as it sounds, and it's making essay work a living hell for people who are purely essay, you know, practitioners. Um, so I see that part of the market getting really disrupted because um, you know, the AI is better than most of these kids who are coming in for help can actually write, but it's not good enough to actually get them to levels that they may actually need because the the AI is only as good as the human who's prompting it, right? And most kids who, like the Dunning Kruger effect who are prompting AI, you know, like I read a letter of recommendation that the state senator asked the kid to write, and it was like a North Korean propaganda piece. I was like, no state senator talks like this. What the hell is happening? He's like, oh, I was running this with AI. I was like, well, there you go, right? Um, but when it comes to um, you know, the the kind of counseling that I do, I've actually found that the AI has not disrupted as much as I thought it would. Because really what people need is like, you know, admission is a rite of passage. And in every rite of passage, you have a guide who's gonna mentor a young person through the three stages of a rite of passage, right? Stage one is a separation phase. You're you're a normal teenager, but you're gonna depart uh or depart on a different journey to try to prove something to a college that you want to get into. Stage two, liminality phase, that's your proving grounds. You know, you're just a kid with an underdeveloped prefrontal cortex. Um, kind of need a human there to emotionally regulate you and build up your confidence. You can take those steps to be more heroic in whatever it is you want to do. And of course, stage three, the induction phase of getting in and you know, moving out of home and going to college. Um, that is such a human process that when you think of like, you know, every rite of passion society, whether it's like a Catholic confirmation, a Jewish bar mitzvah, you know, a young person in a village learning how to go hunting from a, you know, a senior hunter, um, those are things that almost at a tribal sense at our core are necessary. And I think that what's happening is a lot of independent consultants who don't have the writing talent are using AI to do offline edits, which, you know, better than the kid would have come up with, better than they would have come up with. So now you almost have like everybody with their AI gen tech agent, you know, competing in a way, right? But in a way, it's um the comedy of it is that, you know, if you start going down the rabbit hole on YouTube of like, you know, AI trends, you'll find that the language models have these very peculiar ways of communicating and speaking. Like it's not this, it's that. And so I have a feeling that um the next trend will be trying to remove any sense of AI uh influence because you know, when you find uh a link to find language in an essay, like it's not this, it's that, or like I delved into like all these kind of like terms that are somehow showing up across the country, right? With all these kids' essays, um the admissions officers won't penalize the kids. It's all of them have additive review processes where they're trying to add reasons to admit the kid, not penalize them. But you you know, in the same reason why a boring essay might doom you, when I read an S and I see it's like AI, I stop thinking about the kid and I'm thinking AI. And so it diverts the attention. So I think that AI will become a tool that the industry as well as the consumers learn to use in a more mature way. But I think that as it gets more matured in use, I don't think kids will be so clever as to learn how to properly prompt and you know, prompt engineer AI, but it's going to be something that becomes more like a very high-end thesaurus. I want to say something, I'm not sure. Here's what I want to say, AI help me, right? Um that's where I find AI is probably coming in the most in our industry, not to the promise that it had when you know it first cracked on the scene and people were freaking out about, you know, it up ending everything.
SPEAKER_02You said that like those success rate claims from admission consultants are structurally misleading. So that's obviously a very heavy statement about your industry. Can you walk me through that?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. So check this out. Um, there was a company called College Vine that made it onto the scene in their like in the 2010s, and they were touted as the first like venture backed, truly scalable model for admissions consulting in America. And their business model was akin to like an Uber model, right? You would sign up for College Vine and they would match you with a current college student, like you know, through their app. And then you know it was like Uber for College Emergency Consulting. And initially, when the practice started, it was like a Harvard graduate and it was a very small, you know, IEC type practice. And they had a 90% plus success rate for their clientele. And as they started to incorporate the technology and this Uber style of working, of course, the quality in the workmanship went down. And they would keep on publishing their success rate and it would start dropping. And it dropped all the way to like 70%. And then they stopped talking about their top three choice success rate. It disappeared from all their material. And in the final years of the company, before it pivoted to like back-end AI for like institutions, um, they started to use a new term that was novel that had never been used before in admissions consulting, and that was the admit rate multiplier. What multiplier of acceptance, you know, advantage are their clients getting compared to the overall admit rate for the university. So they'll say something like, you know, the Stanford admit rate is 5%, but our clients get in at like 20%. That's a four times admit rate multiplier. And it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Can I tell you why? Um, just throwing some stats out there. At Yale University, for example, at a NACAC conference, um, the admissions director of Yale said that 40% of Yale's applicant pool does not even have the academics to be seriously considered dead on arrival, right? Uh there was a Vanderbilt admissions officer who explained that 50% of Vanderbilt's applicant pool pre-screened out based on academics alone. They're not even making it to the actual review of the essays and everything else. And if you consider that at these very elite universities, 40 to 50% of the applicant pool are completely just dead on arrival. And now you're saying that our clients who are signing up for private consulting are this, you know, these many times more accepted, it's a straw man argument. You're propping them up against this admit rate that's artificially low because all these kind of like, you know, non-serious applicants are just applying to spin the wheel of the lottery, not knowing how anything works. And um, and it's a very eye-popping number. And what you'll find if you look at all the major claims of these companies that use admit rate multipliers, the higher their success rate for a top three-choice college, the lower their actual admit rate admit rate multiplier. The higher their admit rate multiplier, the lower their success rate is for top choice schools. Um, and so you know, it's it's it's a it's an interesting statistic that seems to have a lot of, you know, uh, you know, power behind it. But when you realize how it's calculated, it just doesn't match up with how admissions operate as well. Because consider this, like when we talk about Yale fitting out 40% of its applicant pool or Vanderbilt fitting out 50% of its applicant pool within like 90 seconds per read, immediately poof, gone, right? Um, that's that hurdle test I talked about. Did they even clear the hurdle? Oh, they didn't. And there's no extenuating circumstance, there's no context as to know that might save them. Uh, gone, gone, gone, gone. So now what happens, right? The real admissions process is did you clear the hurdle or did you not? Uh admit rate multipliers don't acknowledge that. They're just like, oh, if you hire us, it'll be four times more uh competitive or 10 times more competitive or seven times more competitive for Harvard, right? But no, if you don't clear Harvard's bar of admission being that hurdle, uh your odds are zero. Uh in fact, when I talked about Harvard's um, you know, lawsuit and the data that came out, if a kid was not able to score high in any of Harvard's five categories, their admit rate over 10 years was 0.1%. I don't know whose whose nephew that was, right? Or what the situation was, but 0.1%, like that's that's your odds if you don't score high in any of the categories. Um, you know, it's so yeah, these admit rate multipliers are are are pure marketing fluff. It was used by a business that was cratering downhill to try to, you know, project that they were successful, even though their actual choice admit rate was dropping. And that's why all the big firms that are venture-backed locked onto that because they understand, again, if you look at the cluster reviews, you'll see like the way they operate, uh, you don't get quality at that level of scale. Uh, if anything, just like I said, there's a revolving door to admissions officers, uh, admissions offices. There's also a revolving door to these big companies where it's not uncommon for the consultants switch out two, three times during the actual admission season, right? As they, you know, underpaid, look for better work, whatever. Um it's kind of crazy. Uh so yeah, it's it's it's marketing fluff.
SPEAKER_02So as we close this out, we're gonna move into lightning rounds. So this will be just some rapid questions um with uh no explanation necessary unless you want to. Does that sound good? All right, you ready? Let's do it. All right, that type of year. All right, what's the most um overrated college emissions metric?
SPEAKER_00Oh Jesus.
SPEAKER_02Um published research. Um, how about the most underrated?
SPEAKER_00Underrated. Um I would say it's initiative to work beyond the official job duties of your title.
SPEAKER_02What's the one thing that parents overthink?
SPEAKER_00Everything. But if I had to say one, if I'd say one, I think it's uh summer programs. Uh one summer program is not going to make or break uh a profile when it's such a small part of the overall year. And how about the thing that they underthink? I would say the rubrics because no one even thinks about starting there. But if there's something that's more kind of top of mind if they underthink, uh, I would say this only at most 40% of the college application is the actual essays. Um the other 60% can be narrativized to pack in more narratives than the actual essays can. So if they can use 100% of the whole application to tell their stories, um, you can unload all the pressure of the college essay elsewhere, but no one ever thinks to do that.
SPEAKER_02Uh what's one book or resource every family should read?
SPEAKER_00Uh there is a blog article from Vanderbilt's Office of Admissions that talks about the middle 50% range and how they uh, you know, measure and uh view academic uh academics and applicants. And although that's not a bright line, like baseline, I think understanding the way that colleges assess competitiveness uh would surprise a lot of families who just assume that the highest rated, most accomplished, you know, academic successful kid should always get in, which is why this doesn't happen.
SPEAKER_02And then how about um if you had to give one piece of advice to a parent of a high schooler today, what would it be?
SPEAKER_00I would say like get a kid graded on a rubric. Um it doesn't have to be a rubric. I mean, we use that word in college Zoom, but um if a consultant actually has a method of baselining the kid tangibly to show, here's where you are, here's where you have to be, that's a sign of a well-thought-out process. Um, most of the time, these like evaluations are just shooting off the hip, very vague, or it's based on context that the giver has, but not the student. And of course, if a kid can see the rungs of the ladder, they can actually grab on to, they'll be so much more successful. Uh, but most of the time that's withheld from the student from understanding.
SPEAKER_02And what is the best question every family should ask a college?
SPEAKER_00You know, it that's a trick question because the answers that matter, the colleges will say I'm not able to give you precise advice. So what I would say is um, oh gosh, uh, and that's why there's a whole industry around independent consulting, because there's so much conflicting advice with the within the admissions office. So if there's one question you would want to ask a college that would actually give you some insight, um gosh, I would say, uh, you know, I I would say this. I would say, uh, and this is what's pragmatic, when you're writing your why us essay, I would actually just talk to the students who are at the St. Leaders Home campus. They have they live and breathe the experience so authentically that if you can understand how a kid who has like your major uh is living it up at that college, you'll have a much better case you can make for why you should go to that college and what you would do when you're actually there. Um everything else you're from you'll hear from the admissions office will always just be kind of shades of you know obscurity, and it might be this, it might be that, and it's it it it's it's uh it's a madhouse. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I hear you, man. I appreciate you, David, being on. Um, it's been great. Uh I hope you come back, share more insights. Um so for people who are interested in your authenticity and your experience and want to learn out more about you in College Zoom, where should they find you? CollegeZoom.com. All right. And what's uh one thing you want people to remember from this conversation?
SPEAKER_00Uh, you know, I would say this. Um, the institutions prevent a single reader's bias um from shaping the class by using these rubrics. I'll end on one last anecdote. One of the students we worked with was a junior at Stanford when he did his FERPA review. And for those who don't know, a FERPA review is like your admissions file, if you're admitted, is kind of like your medical file. You have certain rights to view it. And so you can actually file a request to review your admissions file afterwards. And then, you know, if you're a student there, they'll they'll have you sit down with the admissions officer and walk through it. And when he read his file, he was shocked because the first Stanford reviewer thought he was not a good fit, not intellectual enough for Stanford, and voted no. It's like, ouch. The second reviewer thought he'd be a great, wonderful addition to Stanford, and luckily the third person agreed. And what I want families to think about is like, what if the person you hire is the first reviewer or the second reviewer, right? Imagine how different those two consulting experiences would be. And a lot of families are not, you know, they're not kept up at night wondering, like, you know, is my kid gonna get in or not? But it's it's it's is this counseling gonna completely skew my kids' psychology and their mental health and kind of ruin their life, right? By by like overextending them, burning them out, all this kind of stuff. So I would say if you can get scored on a rubric, that's very honest. You can figure out what your kid is at their baseline, you can see what work is required to get to where they want to be. And then from that point, you can be honest with the kid is will you actually do the work? I joke with all the parents that I said, hey, if you're the client parent, uh you're you'll go to Harvard. You have a prefrontal cortex boy develop. You don't care what people think of you, you'll do the hard work. Your teenager is a teenager. So, you know, uh, you gotta remember that while you want your kid to go, uh, you need to make sure that the approach will actually motivate them and they'll actually follow through.
SPEAKER_01Amazing. David, thank you so much again for coming. And thank you all for yeah. Thank you for all for watching the Supported Learning Podcast, and uh, we'll see you next time.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.