SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 82 - Award-Winning Researcher: The #1 Way to Actually Use AI Is to Learn - Dr. Torrey Trust
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Dr. Torrey Trust, professor of learning technology at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and award-winning researcher on how technology should be integrated into education, to break down what schools are getting right and wrong about AI and what parents need to understand right now.
Dr. Joe and Dr. Trust discuss why AI is a guessing machine and not true intelligence, the Augment Framework for distinguishing helpful AI use from harmful automation, why banning AI in schools widens the digital divide rather than protecting students, what research actually shows about whether students are cheating more since ChatGPT launched, the digital native myth and why growing up with TikTok doesn’t mean your kid understands technology, and why billions spent on edtech have not translated into learning gains.
This episode is especially useful for parents wondering whether their kids should be using AI for schoolwork, educators trying to figure out how to integrate AI without going all-in or banning it, school administrators evaluating edtech purchases and AI policies, and anyone who wants to understand the research behind the AI-in-education debate.
📲 Connect with them: https://www.torreytrust.com/
EdTech Books: https://edtechbooks.org/
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Book a call: supportedtutoring.com/book-call-youtube
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. Welcome back to the Supported Learning Podcast. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars and years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people who have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. And that's why I'm thrilled to have Dr. Tori Trust here today. Dr. Tori is a professor of learning technology at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, an award-winning researcher, author, and one of the leading voices on how technology and especially generative AI should actually be integrated into education. We're going to dive into what schools are getting right and wrong about AI, how parents should think about their kids using these tools, and what evidence-based digital learning actually looks like. Dr. Torrey, welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. I'm delighted to be here and talk about education, technology, AI, and all the likes.
SPEAKER_00I am I am glad to have you here. I didn't mention where I'm from. I'm from Pittsburgh, so we're not going to talk about the Patriots stealing three Super Bowls from the Steelers at all. I'll leave that off the table. But so I uh but I've given them the highlight reel. I want to hear from you. Give us the 60-second snapshot who you are and what is the specific problem you're helping families and educators in learning and education solve.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I'm a professor of learning technology. I used to teach in our learning media and technology master's program, which would prepare students to go work in fields of like instructional design or tech coaches in schools, but more recently with our new undergraduate program in the College of Education at UMass Amherst, which focuses on community education and social change with a tech focus built in. I've been teaching undergraduates who are future teachers to think deeply and critically about the role technology can, should, might play in their future classrooms. That's my teaching side, my research side. I've been examining the role of technology in both teacher learning and well as teachers' practice for more than a decade. And the thing with technology is you kind of have to follow the trends. And so I initially started looking at teachers' professional learning networks, how teachers use technology and social media to improve and support their ongoing professional learning. And then that shifted to 3D printing in makerspaces because our university had a grant for 50 new 3D printers. So we were studying that. Then it went on to open educational resources because we had a grant for that. And then AI came along. And it's now like you've I want to be out there helping teachers, parents, students think critically about these tools. And to do so requires engaging in research and learning as much as you can about these emerging trends, tools, technologies.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you've spent years on the research side of ed tech, right? Before AI became even part of the conversation. So let's start with how you got there. What pulled you into learning technology as research area in the first place? What were you seeing in education that you thought needed studying?
SPEAKER_01So well, I many, many years ago, more than a decade ago, I worked in Southeast Washington, DC, in one of the most under-resourced communities and lowest performing schools in the country. And I was working as a paraprofessional with a student with autism, and he would struggle in the classroom, so I'd pull him out to the library. And the library was where students who students just ran away from class. It was, it was chaos. It was a really challenging environment. And one day my husband gave me his iPod touch, that's how I'm gonna date myself at that point, filled with apps for um, you know, manipulating little geometric shapes and um, you know, uh little math fraction games and stuff. And I pulled out those apps and tools, and all of a sudden the library went silent. All of the kids gathered around me and watched my student with autism figure out how to manipulate them. And um, basically I was able to move him up a couple grade levels just by engaging him with the technology in a way that supported his learning. And the students were so fascinated. And so that's where I was like, this is it. I have figured out the solution to education. Uh, the silver bullet is technology solves all problems, which spoiler alert, it doesn't. But that was my initial thought of I need to go study this. What is happening here that um is shifting these students who are running away from class because they're struggling so much with it, who are now all of a sudden really interested in learning. And what role does technology play in that?
SPEAKER_00What uh what school was that in Southeast DC?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that was uh Stanton Elementary in Anacostia, Washington, D.C.
SPEAKER_00So I used to be at Friendship Charter School, which home base was in Anacostia, but I was in up on the Minnesota Avenue exits in Northeast where the high school was. So interesting. Yes. Very, very interesting uh experience there. So you've researched how teachers learn and adopt technology. What's the biggest gap you see between how administrators think teachers use tech and how they actually use it?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I think there's this kind of assumption that we give teachers or students technology and it makes learning better. It goes with this assumption that technology is always a positive force. It's not even neutral. It can be a negative force in many cases. And so I think a lot of administrators go out and buy the shiniest new tool, the new suite of tools, and give very little training for teachers and say, bring this into your classroom. Here's a new learning management system, here's a new grading system, here's some tools that we have licenses for. And teachers are um, you know, struggling to figure out how that actually fits into their teaching. And in many cases, like I saw in Washington, DC, like they bought tons of new technologies, interactive smartboards and um Chromebook carts that all just went to storage because there wasn't enough time and training and support to really learn how to use technology for teaching and for learning. It was just enough, like, here's a tool and here's a 30-minute webinar on how to use the tool, but not actually here's how to use the tool to transform learning. Um, and so I think there's a huge gap of just giving teachers the tool is not going to create real change.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that probably got exacerbated by the pandemic, right? It probably just blew up of like everyone's getting a device now, and oh, they're they're using 21st century skills, even though we're a quarter way into the 21st century and they're they're they're using them all correctly, and that's not necessarily true. But you know, why are you focused on high impact digital learning over just simple tool adoption? What's the distinction that matters there?
SPEAKER_01Well, the term learning, right, is is really key in there. I'm looking for high-impact digital learning. Is does learning actually happen? How can you use technology in meaningful and authentic ways to support learning rather than what's the latest new digital tool or app and how do we bring this into our classroom? Uh it's more about um does this technology break down barriers to learning, improve access, improve accessibility, support students' creative thinking, engage students in collaboration and innovation and design rather than here's a tool, let's use it.
SPEAKER_00That's the exact structural problem we talk about constantly. So you've been observing this for years, and now let's talk about the topic that's hijacked every conversation in education right now and just everywhere in the world, AI. Um, you know, generative AI has dropped into schools overnight. Uh literally ChatGPT what 2022 came out. We literally had like um a PD on AI coming, and people like teachers were talking about it, and like literally within a month, the first model of Chat GPT dropped. I think ChatGPT 3, right? Was it or ChatGPT 3 or 4? The first model.
SPEAKER_013.5 was the first one.
SPEAKER_00Gotcha. And then the kids, kids were already using this like within a within a month. And teachers, like, what is going on? I think we have our first case of cheating with AI. So, from your perspective, what is actually happening in classrooms right now? Are teachers using it, banning it, confused by it? Like, what's going on?
SPEAKER_01You know, you're right. It came out in 2022. We're three and a half years into when ChatGPT launched, and I've been asked to do trainings and keynote speeches uh all over New England and sometimes across the country. And even within the last couple of months, some of my keynote speeches, which just are a high-level overview of here's what generative AI really is, here are the ethical issues, here's ways to use it. Teachers just have no idea really how it works. And students, the same way, my 18-year-olds and my undergraduates, so my 18-year-olds in my first year seminar, my undergraduates are 18 to 21, they're future teachers. When I gave them a one-hour keynote in my class, uh, this was maybe two months ago, on how AI actually works, they had no idea that it's a guessing machine. That's the basically how I call it. Um, and so we're we're still actually the really early stages of figuring this all out in terms of like people still at this point don't really understand what it works or how it works. And that's causing a lot of problems because AI has come out, these developers of AI, with these promises of more productivity, more efficiency. Uh, you could be a better teacher, a faster teacher, spend more time on what you really like in teaching rather than uh wasting it on lesson planning or administrative tasks. When if you understand that these tools are predictability or guessing machines that are using a large data set to guess which words go together to make the most human-sounding response, using a tool like that to automate tasks to make things better, faster, more efficient is probably one of the worst and most harmful uses of these tools. And that's what I'm seeing most commonly right now when it is being adopted by students and by teachers.
SPEAKER_00I watched, I mean, I listen to a lot of podcasts. I have a pretty long drive, and um, you know, I was watching a segment, I think it was on um breaking points of a guy. He's very and very negative in AI, saying that AI, what we're being sold is not AI, the large language data sets is not, it's just it's a lot, it's becoming more sloped that it is useful. It's predicted, it's predicted data sets, like you said, it's not truly artificial intelligence, but it's being used to over-inflate values and drive up all these all this potential um you know revenue and stock prices and things like that. But interesting you say that because you know, is it really is it really intelligent or is it just basing off of all collective knowledge that we've already given it, right? And you know, we're we're talking about something meta here. If we just went to basics, what is the difference between using AI well in education or large language models, right? And using it badly.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I want to go back to your point about is it intelligent? And it's something that some colleagues in my uh uh across the university have been thinking about talking about and exploring the role of intelligence and what that means. You know, AI is considered intelligent because it can mimic the way humans write or design, you know, images. Um but and it can score well on, you know, uh standardized tests that students take. That's kind of how we're measuring artificial intelligence as intelligent. When I give my uh keynote speeches, my main point is artificial intelligence, um, while designed to mimic human intelligence is not human and it's not intelligent, right? It comes back to it's simply a predictability machine. Um and so I think that's a really important point to get across is that if you understand that these tools cannot think, they do not understand, they don't know context, uh, they don't know people or or experiences or emotions, then there are ways that you can use these tools effectively. And one model that I've been working on with some colleagues is a new framework called the Augment Framework. One of the things I've been seeing across the board is this kind of dichotomy of automate versus augment. Uh, will AI replace or automate your thinking, your job, your communication, or will it augment your abilities? And so right now we're in the automate state. That's what I'm seeing across the board. But I do think, like, if you know that AI has been trained on the entirety of English written text posted on the internet, that's generally more than a single person can hold in their head. There's potential that AI might come up with ideas that humans hadn't come up with. So for creative thinking, there's research to show humans plus AI is more creative than humans alone or AI alone. Um, I've also seen it being used to break down barriers to learning, like students will upload a text and have Google Notebook LM create a podcast so that they can listen to a summary of the text. You know, so I think there's ways that these tools, if you understand how they work um and what their features are, can augment abilities rather than automate thinking and learning.
SPEAKER_00So I actually think in the K-12 space, schools are grossly behind, at least a lot of them that I'm experiencing and where they're at, because we're still talking about like we're we're talking about things that probably is two years old already, but a lot of schools are responding to AI by trying to ban it as making it the new social media. Like, what does your research say about that approach?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, what was the New York school system first banned ChatGPT when it came out in early 2023? And then they have since said, well, that was actually um not a great idea. There uh let me let me step back a little bit. Last summer, Google announced at the International Society for Tech and Education conference that they were putting Gemini into the entire workspace and classroom suite, whether teachers or students wanted it or not. And a lot of schools and IT staff and uh professionals who make decisions around that immediately shut off all access to Gemini for students, but kept it on for teachers. Or in some cases, they shut it off for both. Uh, but I've gone into a lot of schools where that's the case where teachers get really interested in AI and they create things with Google Notebook LM or they create a Gemini gem, and then their students are banned from using the tool. And the thing you need to think about is the digital divide. There are students who are gonna go home and have access to a wide range of AI tools, even the free versions that they can access. But the students in more affluent communities might have upgraded versions. And so if you ban AI in schools, then the students who do not have access to, you know, um uh high-speed internet access devices that they can quickly check it, like try out AI at home versus those who do, you're just exacerbating a divide that this tool is not only being used in most careers at this point, but employers in a Microsoft survey basically said we'd rather hire a less experienced person with more AI skills than a more experienced person with less AI skills. And so if you ban AI, then the students who don't have the access to AI or the learning opportunities with AI outside of school are going to continue to fall further behind.
SPEAKER_00This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supportedtutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. So for a parent listening right now, and maybe their 16-year-old or 17-year-old is using ChatGPT to draft essays or even their college admissions essay or they're not using Chat GPT and they're using Claude, right? Summarizing chapters, working through math problems. How should their parent, how should that parent be thinking about it?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I think the key is asking students, asking their kids why they're using it. You know, there's a lot of reasons. I think there's this big assumption that all students are using AI to cheat. There was a big Stanford study to show that cheating has not changed over time ever since the launch of Chat GPT. The thing is, cheating was very, very high before ChatGPT, and it continues to remain very high because students are disengaged in school, they're disconnected, they're not interested. Uh if I saw my kiddo using Chat GPT to do their work for them, I'd sit down and be like, what's going on? Are you struggling with the first sentence, a transition between sentences, finding the right words? Is this topic or assignment just not interesting to you? How do we make it more interesting? Do you have, you know, three sports games this week and you don't have time to write this paper? Like, what is causing you to go to this tool to do your work for you? If I'm noticing they're using it that way. If they're just trying to like look at the tool and figure out how it can be useful, AI actually, I mean, one of the most common uses of generative AI technologies by students right now is for learning, for breaking down barriers to learning, not for cheating. And this is high school students, this is college students. They're going to AI to say, hey, give me an infographic that better explains this topic that my teacher did not explain well, or create this podcast of this reading that I'm really struggling through and I have no other sources to turn to, or give me feedback. Did I solve this math problem right? What else can I think about? And so I do think that there's really interested uses of AI to augment learning or break down barriers to learning. Um and, you know, I would sit down with my kid and and watch how they're using it and see if there are ways that it could augment their abilities, it could support their learning and have those conversations rather than this immediate assumption that they're just cheating.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, it's interesting because social media, the promise of social media was to make us more connected as a society than ever. And that partially became true, but it also led to just a complete withdrawal from like human-to-human interaction. So when you look at AI, I think one of the big pushbacks right now is the fear of a replacing critical thinking. I agree with you. I think AI um presents a unique opportunity to completely personalize learning experience for kids if they know how to use it and what to ask. Like the I think the bigger problem is if they're actually they're, you know, they're they're novice to it and they're just having it think for them, outsource that entirely. So that is something that I don't think schools are equipped to fight right now, just like we weren't equipped to fight social media. So with social media, same thing. It's gonna be a responsibility of the parents. How do parents and even teachers actually build critical thinking when the temptation for a tool is to do it for them? And kids, let's just face it, are gonna go the easiest form of resistance. How do we solve that problem?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I think that's an assumption that key kids will go to the easiest form of resistance. I, you know, I have seen students who really struggle with math, but all of a sudden get into graphic novels that math is built into, or I a really advanced game where they're learning uh math and statistics techniques and will learn it because they're really intrinsically motivated to learn. Um, you know, I think uh school is not designed to engage or interest students. So there's there's yeah, that's a that's a huge issue at hand. It's I mean, it's it's to be honest, like the there's a very standard curriculum that everyone generally has to follow. And um, in some schools, teachers have to stick exactly to the curriculum, and others they have more opportunities to, you know. To be more creative in their teaching. But I don't know. When I see these conversations that students are just going to AI because it's easy, I would want to sit down with them on that why, right? Like, is it, and in many cases, you're right. Like I did just say that automation is the main way we're using it right now. Teachers, students, people in their jobs is because it does seem to make things easier. It reduces the productive struggle because people don't know how to use these tools. I want to go back to my colleague, Dr. Robert Molloy, who likes to kind of quote Seymour Papert and one of the founding thinkers about computer programming, who talked about do you want the computer to program the child or the child to program the computer? When you think about AI, do you want AI to control the child? Do you want AI to do the thinking of the child, the student, or do you want the student to control AI to improve their thinking? And when I adapt that to AI, are you prompting AI to help expand your thinking, or are you prompting AI to do your thinking for you? And so, but again, as you mentioned, schools don't have the capacity to keep up with this technology. Parents don't. And so, like, students need actual training on how are you using these tools? Because there's like, I've created some prompts on like turning AI into simulations. You're teaching like tax literacy, for example, which is a pretty abstract topic for high school students. Um, and I have like created a very basic one-paragraphed text prompt that will turn Chat GPT into a choose your own adventure storybook, where you are the mayor of a town having to determine what to do when various like scenarios hit like a natural disaster or the fire department has run out of funding. Do you levy taxes? Do you think through things? And the whole way it's prompting you to think, you're making a decision, providing your thoughts, and it's giving you immediate feedback and you're driving this nonlinear learning process. That's super cool. Does a student know how to write a prompt to engage themselves and choose your own adventure style thinking? No, right now they're just going to go to AI and say, give me this information. And so that's where I'm like, we really need AI literacy in every grade level and every subject, critical AI literacy, not just how to use these tools, but how they actually work and how they can um, you know, improve your critical thinking, creative thinking rather than replace it.
SPEAKER_00So what is the digital native myth? The idea that kids are automatically good at using technology. What is what is your research actually showing here?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I hear that myth a lot uh from um teacher education standpoint. There is an assumption that, like my students who are 18 to 21 year olds, because they grew up with technology, when they go into the classroom, they immediately know how to use technology to teach. But when you think about what these students grew up with, it is YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, uh games on their phones, right? There, it wasn't necessarily that they were learning how to use Canva to create collaborative projects with people around the world. Uh, it was often using technology for entertainment purposes. So, yeah, there there is this myth that because students are growing up in this digital world, they know how to use these tools, but really they know how to use tech like social media for entertainment purposes. Sure, they're learning, they're figuring that out. And right now, one of the biggest ways that students are learning how to use AI is through social media because they're not getting support from parents or teachers or schools on that. Um, so I think that the myth of the digital native is um is super problematic in just assuming, oh, students know what they're doing with AI. I don't think that's true.
SPEAKER_00So I guess what is the role of the teachers as AI becomes more capable? Some people are saying AI will potentially replace teachers. I don't think that's gonna happen anytime soon, but it does, I think, pose maybe a necessary threat to who owns the content, who owns the knowledge. All that knowledge is already accessible, um, but a lot of it has to come from the single point of the teacher. Um, what is what is your evidence-based view?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, anyone who says that AI will replace teachers really is seeking to delegitimize the teaching profession. Uh, you know, teaching is one of the most complex professions in the entire world. The number of decisions that teachers have to make on a daily basis based on the context of their classrooms, their schools, the ecological systems that they work within, their students' backgrounds and experiences. To think that a guessing machine or predictability model could replace what a teacher do does is naive and worrisome. But that doesn't mean it's not happening. There's what alpha school in Texas that they got rid of teachers. Students are on AI for two hours a day. There's kind of teachers as guides in the background. Um, you know, so there is that thought there is that AI is this magical tool that will save everyone money, that will make teaching better because it can be personalized and stuff. And that's not, I don't think you have a solid sense of what education really is if that's your assumption that it's just about getting information to students or information retrieval. You know, there's so much more to schooling in terms of the social aspects we which we realized during the pandemic when that was lost. Um, the relationship building, the the motivation building, the identifying students' needs and barriers and helping them, you know, you know, learn. So I don't think AI will replace teachers. I don't think it should. Um, but I think I think there's definitely people trying to. And I think, you know, there's there's interesting ways that AI can serve as like a um a support or tutor when students don't have access to teachers outside of school. Like there's the study and learn modes within Gemini, guided learning mode, um, co-pilot. Chat GPT actually just disappeared their study mode uh without telling anyone. But it was designed to shift ChatGPT into a like a tutor rather than um giving you information right away. And I've been studying that with my students for the past year or so, and I can see why it was probably disappeared. It's not effective in that like replacing a teacher, but it is helpful in in studying like these tools, like the the study and learn modes um in basically chunk knowledge down, guide learning, um, provide a knowledge check, so like a multiple choice question or a thought-provoking question, students answer and they get immediate feedback. And when they don't have access to teachers outside of school, I would say that in general is is more supportive than just going to Google to look things up, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, we see that a lot. Um, technology isn't some magic pill, like the pedagogy is the most important thing, right? The human code sheet is there. Like even with a lot of AI tools, we still want it to be humans at the center. Um, let's talk about like what that looks like in practice and maybe what families and schools are potentially doing wrong, right? So, what's the the biggest mistake schools are making in how they handle AI right now?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the first mistake is, as you mentioned, just banning it, right? Uh I mean there's there's those who ban it, there's those who just kind of ignore it. And those are both problematic because AI is in your face. It is at the top of Google search results, it is at the top of Snapchat, it is in Gmail right now, whether you want it to or not. It's now in the Google Workspace Suite. Like it is everywhere. So banning these tools or just pretending AI doesn't exist. Um, I have some colleagues who like to do that, um, is problematic because students is it's in their faces. How do you prepare them? You know, your role as an educator to prepare them for society where AI is kind of deeply entrenched in the tools they interact with. Um, banning or ignore these tools is not helpful. On the other hand, forcing the use of AI to prepare all students for the future, I also find to be problematic. There is this kind of narrative that AI is inevitable and that uh to succeed in the future, you have to absolutely use AI as a teacher in all of your classes. Students absolutely have to use AI and this kind of, you see the two ends of the spectrum, ban it, ignore it, or go all in. Uh, my colleague, Dr. Robert Malloy, likes to say it's kind of the all-in or all-out model of education. We've seen it with technology over time, right? One of the biggest issues right now is the tech lash. Like, let's get technology all out because we were all in. And that, you know, technology when used well and thoughtfully with the teacher as the pedagogical expert can really make a difference. But going either extreme of just banning it or diving in without thinking deeply and critically about the tool, um, both of those are causing some of the biggest problems in education.
SPEAKER_00What about parents? What's the number one well-intentioned thing parents are doing around AI and that and around tech that's actually backfiring?
SPEAKER_01I don't I don't do enough research on parents and families, I think, to answer that well. I think on the flip side uh not giving in to the fears and the myths that are surrounding technology right now that um screen time is ruining our youth, that social media is causing depression and anxiety, that smartphones are causing students to have short attention spans. I think there's a lot of parents right now who are actively advocating to get all technology out of schools. Um and I, you know, I have a three-year-old at home. I'm in some mom groups on social media, and there's a lot of uh conversation about screen time and how much it ruins kids. And that that is kind of that all-in or all-out model of, you know, not really realizing that there can be benefits. Like my kid, for example, he's three years old. He has his own fantasy baseball team with his dad. We wake up every morning, we look at the stats of all of the players in the major base, like major, like the major leagues. He for his first words like were basically like the Padres starting lineup, because I love the Padres. Um, and we watch we watch baseball in the background while we're playing. I don't have any issues with that, but a lot of parents are like, oh, screen time, it's ruining our youth, and they're, you know, they're not getting the experiences we did. Um it's the, you know, so I think where parents go at it um, you know, in not the most ideal way is giving into these myths and and believing them without looking at the evidence and looking more deeply. There was that big um study a couple of years ago that was, it was a huge study of like uh screen times cause all of these problems, like depression and anxiety and weight gain and all of these things that since has kind of been debunked because it was basically a correlational study. And future researchers who've looked at it basically said if you have a big enough data set, you can find any correlation. You can actually find the amount of potatoes that you eat correlates to depression and anxiety. But all the headlines came out of technology is ruining our youth, and parents just kind of agreed with that. And so I just um I'm not actively promoting technology, um, but I'm also saying we need to think more deeply about technology as a whole and when it might be beneficial. We talk about social media. Yeah, there's times that bans can be helpful, but there's also like LGBT youth, uh, youth in uh rural communities who don't have access to people in spaces that locally that they could globally through social media. If we ban these tools, do they lose their networks, their safety support? Um, you know, so it's it's how you use the tool rather than how much time or uh is spent on the tool is really key.
SPEAKER_00And there's a a lot of uh ed tech being sold to schools right now, AI tutors, graders, AI lesson planners. As a researcher, what's actually evidence-backed and what's marketing hype?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I would say nearly all of it is marketing hype. This is one of the biggest problems in education is that ed tech companies get a lot of money and they're really good at marketing. And I don't know, I just don't see enough research either from the companies themselves or from the schools. And so they just fall into this hype. You know, let's take, for example, um, like those um student monitoring tools like Gaggle and some of the other ones. They literally on their website say, we help um save students' lives, right? Because we're monitoring everything students do on their devices. And if they mention um, you know, something problematic, uh, then we flag them and it goes to the administrator or maybe even to the police, and we're saving their lives. When really what it turns out to be is that tool is entirely just a surveillance tool that's connecting students to the police in problematic ways. Same thing with Proctorio and all those online exam proctoring tools that came out during the pandemic. They're like, we're here to stop cheating, when yet again, they were also surveillance tools. So I think the ed tech industry is really good at marketing and hype, and people fall for that without asking, where's the data backing up that this tool actually creates real change in the classroom? And the thing is, ed tech companies don't have the time or capacity to engage in a year or two long research study to show their effectiveness. They want to get their products out into schools as fast as possible. And then if schools buy into that, they don't necessarily do their own research. And so that's why you're seeing right now a lot of frustration saying, hey, we've spent billions on ed tech and we haven't seen positive changes. And it's like, yeah, well, we've given into a lot of the hype and the marketing and not enough actual research of what happens when I bring this tool into my classroom. And should we keep this tool next year or should we uh get rid of it and find something more effective for what our needs are?
SPEAKER_00Where do you see AI in education going in the next three to five years?
SPEAKER_01Like what should parents be preparing for well, I'm starting to see more um schools wanting to bring AI into their classrooms and grade levels. Uh I saw there was kind of this, you know, uh, it was interesting. I could tell where a school was at in their progression of AI based on what they asked me to do a training on. And so early on it was all about how to teach because AI is out there, how to change your teaching. Then it quickly shifted to academic integrity and cheating, then it shifted to ethics and what do we do about the ethical issues. And now more recently, it's how do we teach with AI? And I'm getting a lot more requests from schools to say, how do we actually teach with these tools? Uh and so I I do think that there's a lot, and there's some schools that are going all in on where just every student's gonna use AI often to prepare them for the future. So that is my guess is that schools are gonna buy into this hype of AI more so than they should.
SPEAKER_00What about um, you know, you've done some research in equity in digital learning. You've spoken on a little bit earlier, but who is getting left behind in this transition and what would actually fix it? And I want to preface that with I think we made great strives during the pandemic, getting devices in the hands of a lot of learners who otherwise did not have access to it. But like we talked about earlier, that does not necessarily mean they know how to use it. So now the AI revolution is here, supposedly. Who's getting left behind and how do we get how do we maintain equitable access?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, the digital divide has like different components. And so access to the tools, the very lowest level, and then learning how to use the tool is the next level. And we rarely think about that. So yeah, maybe you do turn on Gemini for all students in your school and you think that you've now solved the digital divide in your district around AI literacy. But again, I'm talking most students don't really know how to interact with AI other than writing very basic prompts. There's definitely some students who are using AI to create really cool inventions and innovations and stuff, but those are more rare. I'd say on average, students generally don't really know how to interact with these tools other than writing basic prompts and seeing what comes out. So following the assumption that I just turned on Gemini for the whole school and now students will have AI literacy will then lead to more students continuing to be left out until you can engage students across the curriculum in thinking critically about these tools. I'm not saying students have to use these tools in every grade level and every subject, but I am saying critical AI literacy, engaging students in learning how these tools work, how they were designed, how they were disseminated, um, how they make money, the environmental and ethical impacts, intellectual property rights, data privacy, all of those issues. Students need opportunities to discuss, explore, and think deeply about. And then also like prompt writing is a really important skill. You can get a lot more out of AI. Teachers need to learn this as well from my research, um, from writing a more detailed prompt than you can from a basic prompt. And so again, this this kind of goes back to like if we if we want to make sure there's equitable opportunities with AI, then students uh across all grade levels and and subjects need those opportunities to learn how the tools work and how to use them and how to think critically about them.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Let's shift gears and move into lightning realm. All right, just rapid fire questions as we close this out, all right? All right. What's the most oh what's the most overrated ed tech tool right now?
SPEAKER_01Oh, um, am I gonna anger a tech company for saying this? The overrated tech tool right now. If this is lightning round, I have to say an answer really quickly. The one that's kind of driving me the the most wild is Magic School. Um, because that basically is just puns a whole bunch of wrappers on top of a large language model that teachers can click, make a lesson plan, make an infographic, make my slides, and it's all about automation rather than augmenting. I mean, it's not all about. They now have like, I don't know, 80 or 100 different things they can do. And there's probably, I haven't explored it enough, but my worry is that it's this hyped tool that will save teachers time and make education better. And when I have studied the lesson plans that Magic School creates, uh, I am they are, they are not, they don't make me happy. I guess is the easiest way to say that. Um, uh my other thought would be Kahoot. I know a lot of current and future teachers, like my students, as soon as they learn about Kahoot, they are all in. Like this is the tool. And there's nothing wrong with like gamification in the classroom, but thinking that that is the only technology you need to use ever when the tool itself, like if you're an English language learner, if you're a student with a disability, being in a competitive, you know, leaderboard style game really creates a barrier to learning. Uh, and only those who can successfully really quickly read the question, press a response are at the top. And and a lot of people are left out with that tool, and it's not thought about in that way because students think it's fun, but I don't know if they're really learning with that tool.
SPEAKER_00Okay, okay. Yeah, that the it is like but magic school is a good one.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, there's too long of a response to it.
SPEAKER_00You're fine. No, you're fine. No, you're good. I don't hold all of them at the rules. So uh one thing parents overthink about technology and learning.
SPEAKER_01That technology that giving students or kids technology will lead to learning.
SPEAKER_00How about something they underthink?
SPEAKER_01They underthink about technology. I think there is uh so much potential if you know the tools out there for technology to be used to support critical and creative thinking, uh, collaboration, civic action, uh analytical thinking. Uh and I my guess would be parents aren't as familiar with the possibilities of tech.
SPEAKER_00How about the best book or resource on the evidence? Behind learning.
SPEAKER_01Oh goodness. Uh the evidence behind learning. I would go back to a really old school book, which is called How People Learn. There's two versions. I think it was the National Academies Press. They're both open access online. Something I looked at in my graduate school. I haven't looked at it in a long time, but it's really about the effective practices when it comes to learning, right? It's it should be student-centered, it should be active, it should be hands-on, minds-on. It should be social, um, creative, engaging. So I think I all I would love parents to read that book and teachers to see the evidence. Uh, they're a little bit outdated in terms of they haven't been updated, but I think the the evidence in there still is true.
SPEAKER_00How about one way every parent should use AI with their kid this week?
SPEAKER_01I would go to the Gemini Gem Storybook feature and have Gemini create a storybook to help their students learn a topic they're struggling with. Storytelling is one of the most powerful ways for students to learn something, really for anyone to learn something. Uh it's just how how our brains work. And Google Gemini can make what looks like a children's book or novel uh within a matter of seconds with a simple prompt. And so you could say, for example, your students struggling with fourth grade fractions. You could say, create a book on fourth grade fractions with a character, and you can give the demographics that features Taylor Swift or K-pop demon hunters or whatever it is. And don't stop there with just reading the book to the kid, because I don't, that's still under automate. What I would have there is have the kid read it, but then create their own storybook or critique the storybook. Because what my students found in many cases, interestingly, like skin color or hair changes throughout the books, or there are things that are like text is written backwards, or in some cases, like when I did one on abfractions, like a kid ended up with three arms to hold all three objects. Um, you know, but like so not just saying let's let's all go out and create storybooks, but do it in a way where it is the start of a learning experience that then students either critique or then go build on and create their own.
SPEAKER_00And if you could whisper one piece of advice to a parent of a freshman navigating AI in school right now, what would it be?
SPEAKER_01Talk, talk with your kid. I like be open. I'm gonna be honest, there's gonna be a lot of parents who are using AI either personally or professionally, but then they tell their kid, you can't use AI. Um and it would be interesting if parents were open and honest and transparent, and then students and or I mean their kids felt safe to be open, honest, transparent about AI use. Um, because I think conversations need to happen rather than assumptions needing to be made about what kids are doing nowadays with technology.
SPEAKER_00Well, Dr. Tori, this has been incredibly valuable. I appreciate you coming on and lending your unique perspective as a researcher. Um, I know parents, educators might want to go deeper with this. What where's the best place to for them to find you and your work?
SPEAKER_01My work's on tori trust.com, t-o-r-e-i, t r-ust.com. I have a new open access free book. It's on the augment framework, and it's got more than like 30 different um detailed prompts that are what I consider to be effective uses of AI to improve learning. Um, and so that is linked on my website as well. Um it's we're it's on edtechbooks.org as a free open access book. And so um I think that would be a great place to start if you just want to get into figuring out when this this tool might be helpful and where to go from there. I'd probably start with that.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And before we wrap, what's one thing you want people to remember from this conversation?
SPEAKER_01That technology and learning is a really complex relationship. It's not about going all in or all out. It's really how it's being used.
SPEAKER_00All right, Dr. Torre, thank you again. Appreciate you spending some time with us. And for everyone, listen and remember you don't have to play the game the way the system is set up. You can find the foundation, build the skills, and get the results without the burnout. We will put everything we discussed in the show notes and the YouTube description. Want to thank you all for tuning in to the Supported Learning Podcast, and we'll see you next time. Thank you, Dr. Torrey. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.