SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 83 - Ivy League Admissions Expert: Your Kid’s Perfect Resume Is Making Them Invisible - Steve Gardner
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Steve Gardner, founder of the Ivy League Challenge, Harvard alumnus, and instructor for Leadership and Impact at Harvard Summer School, to break down why the standard “impressive résumé” approach to college admissions is producing invisible applicants and what actually gets students into the most selective schools.
Dr. Joe and Steve discuss the impressiveness trap and why doing more activities makes applications harder to distinguish, the three tiers of college applications from great student to real-world problem solver, why admissions officers label thousands of hard-working applicants as SAMO or same as many others, the story of a student who launched a double-blind medical study at a pediatric oncology hospital before finishing high school, why starting with core values instead of a checklist produces both healthier students and stronger applications, and what happened when a valedictorian with 28 AP classes was rejected from every school that accepted a classmate with a lower GPA.
This episode is especially useful for parents of ambitious high schoolers aiming at top-10 or Ivy League schools, families caught in the cycle of more APs and more activities and more pressure, students trying to figure out what makes them stand out from 30,000 other valedictorians, and anyone who senses the system is broken but doesn’t know what to do instead.
📲 Connect with them: https://www.theivyleaguechallenge.com/
Podcast: https://ivyleagueprepacademy.buzzsprout.com/
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Book a call: supportedtutoring.com/book-call-youtube
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, balloons taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. He is a Harvard alum. He teaches leadership and impact at Harvard Summer School. He's literally named his company Ivy League Prep. And his entire methodology pushes against resume padding, excessive AP loads, and the prestige-chasing burnout that dominates modern selective emissions. Steve Gardner has built a completely different model, character-first, values-driven, real-world impact. And today we're getting into what actually works at the top and what most families get wrong. Welcome back to the Supported Learning Podcast. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars in years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people who have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. And that's why I'm thrilled to have Steve Gardner here today. He is the founder of Ivy League Prep and the Ivy League Challenge, Harvard alum, instructor for leadership and impact at the Harvard Summer School, and hosts the Ivy League Prep Academy podcast and specializes in helping high schoolers navigate selective emissions through character, values, and real world impact instead of the standard resume padding grind. So we're going to dive into why manufactured achievements are hurting applications, why excessive AP loads might be a mistake, and how to prepare for kids for the AI-driven future and what every parent aiming for a selective school needs to hear.
SPEAKER_00Steve, welcome to the show. Oh my goodness. Thank you so much for having me. It's a it's an honor to be here. Yeah, awesome.
SPEAKER_01Awesome to have you, especially from across the globe, as we we talked about earlier. You're already said you're in Singapore, right? That's right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Uh this is where I'm based. I we we talked just before we hit record, and um I told you the the story, the reason why why we're here. I want to work in the mornings, and high school teens want to work at night. So I needed to be in a place geographically where my mornings are their nights. And I I told my wife she can choose the country, but I I choose the time zone. And so here we are. And it's it's working great. We so welcome from the future. I'm I'm just a few hours ahead of you and things are going great.
SPEAKER_01Is it like almost 11 a.m. there?
SPEAKER_0010 to 10 a.m. there? Uh it's exactly 12 hours ahead of Eastern time right now. But sometimes when when there's daylight savings, sometimes it's 13 hours ahead. So it does it does shift. But for now, right now when we're recording, it's it's 10, 15 a.m. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, because I mean, like, I've been running a prep company for like when I did a tutorial, I'll be up till like a midnight sometimes. So maybe I need to change my geography a little bit.
SPEAKER_00That's right. Well, and I I want to be available for kids in California and Washington as well. So Washington State. So that's 3 a.m. on the East Coast. Uh, by the time they're starting to, I mean, some of them are are starting calls at 3 a.m. East Coast time. And um, that's not, I mean, losing sleep to try to get ahead is really against my ethos. It's not something I encourage, but I recognize the reality. And I don't want to be up till 4 a.m. So I live in a part of the world where that works really well for me. And and so far it's been wonderful. I'm far more available than I would be if I was in the US.
SPEAKER_01So I guess that's a good place to start because your whole coaching practice is specifically to solve the burnout at the top problem. So if we can start there, uh, because that position is genuinely different. Take me back to like um, you know, maybe when you were in Harvard in terms of their the 15 years of cross-education, business, personal development. Um, you know, it's a big arc. Most emissions consultants um don't necessarily have like what did that mix teach you?
SPEAKER_00Oh, so interesting. What a what a great way to get started. So I I would say, look, the the one of the most frustrating things in the world is is the fact that we are we are pushing our most ambitious, our our our best resource. We're pushing, we're pushing the cream of the crop through this gauntlet that is not only unhealthy for them, uh it's demotivating. We are we are increasing the chances that our our best shot of of future breakthroughs are gonna burn out before they ever have the opportunity to have those breakthroughs. So the world is suffering by the way that we are handling or the way that we're dealing with preparing for college. And the irony is it's absolutely not necessary. I mean, if you if you begin this process by saying, man, just tell me what Yale is looking for, and then I'll go be that, right? The the the seemingly uh innocent question of well, well, what are what's impressive to admissions officers? What are impress what are admissions officers looking for? The hidden question, of course, behind that is tell me what they're looking for and I'll go be that person. And and the hidden, not not so hidden message there is let me put aside my my the things I wish I could be doing for a few short years. I'll put those aside for just a little while so I can become the person that Yale is looking for. Because if I can just get into Yale, then everything will be okay, right? Then I'll be happy, then I'll be successful. Just let me in and I promise I won't let you down, basically, is is the the the argument and and and from the posture of just begging and absolute desperation. But I mean, think about what you're doing here. Why why would Yale be excited about this really unhealthy, toxic relationship with a future student? Why do they want someone who's they don't want the pressure of having your entire future depend on them? Uh in instead, I mean, if you think about it like dating, who's gonna say, if you'll just marry me, then I'll be happy, then I'll be successful, then I won't let you down. I promise you, just marry me first and we'll be okay. That's of course the wrong approach. And in college admissions, it's a really serious relationship that you're you're forming with the college. Why would you add that level of desperation and that level of toxicity to the relationship? When instead you can say, look, I know who I am, I know what my core values are, I know what matters to me, I have a track record of solving real problems in the real world. I'm gonna be successful with or without Yale. I'm gonna be happy with or without Yale. I'll I'll be me. I'm gonna be fine. Yale looks like a great fit because a whole bunch of people that look like me are also there. But if I don't go to Yale, I'll go someplace else. I'll be fine either way, right? And when that's truly where you are, because you have been healthy and been productive throughout high school, you've been a happy, thriving high school student throughout this time, then that's when Yale becomes excited about you, right? Or Stanford or Harvard or whatever, pick your school. That's when the school becomes really excited. When you don't need them for your trajectory, you're gonna be successful without them. They want to hitch their wagon to you. They want to benefit from the breakthroughs that you're going to make in the company you form or the books that you write that become bestsellers, or however you're gonna change the world, they want to benefit from that. So they want to, you know, hitch their wagon to you. And uh, if we're burning you out before you even get started, or if you think that this whole, this whole game is a race to use your self-discipline and your willpower to outlast everyone else who is also doing miserable stuff endlessly, um, but you have greater willpower and that's why you can outlast them. And you think that's the way that you make yourself more, I don't know, attractive to a school like Yale or Stanford or Harvard. Um, all you're doing is is cutting your legs out from under you before you even get started. It's it's just it's a Yale doesn't want that, Stanford doesn't want that, and to be honest, you don't want the repercussions. And we talk about in my program, we talk about what we call the impressiveness trap, which is really kind of what you're getting to here. The idea that if you spend all your time doing what you think impresses an admissions officer, you make yourself invisible. There are 30,000 high schools in North America. Every single one of them has a valedictorian. Every single one of them has, you know, captains of multiple teams and student body presidents and a most impressive student. And so what we really want to do is tell your story in a way that only you can tell it. Live your values so completely. And by the way, continue to re-energize and recharge your batteries as you go, because you're living your values in a meaningful way, but do it in a way that makes you uh one of one, not one of 30,000.
SPEAKER_01There's not even 30,000 spots across the eight Ivy Leagues, right, for every Val Victorian. So like there's so and they don't all take Val Victorians, obviously. Um That's right.
SPEAKER_00Drew, Drew Faust was the dean of uh the president of Harvard, Dean of Admissions for a while. She famously talked about look, we could fill multiple, more than one class with just the valedictorians who apply here. We we are not just taking grades. I mean, she was really outspoken about this. Uh, but if you open your eyes and you pay attention, actually, a lot of people who know what they're talking about, admissions officers, deans of admissions, they try hard to say, no, live, you know, live your values, show your character, be you, and then help us, you know, help us know who you are, not who you think we wish you would be. So yeah.
SPEAKER_01Steve, I'm really glad you started with that because like you're a Harvard alum. So obviously those credentials are gonna follow you everywhere. But you know, a lot of the things that I've said to parents are very similar in nature because it's really ultimately where the goalposts are. So I guess I'm gonna ask you a chicken or egg question. Do you think it comes more from students, or do you think it comes from more on the parents putting that on the students? Because a lot of kids that I have at least interacted with that say they want to go Ivy League have a very surface level understanding of what it takes to be there. And ultimately what you just described of I just have to get in and then I'll be successful. Where it's like the inverse, it's literally Tony Robbins' philosophy is like, I'm successful. I am already successful. I do not need a condition to be met to be happy, right? And Harvard, and I assume all the other Ivy Leagues, they're not, they're they're recruiting you to what you will become for them, not to get in. Their goalposts, their goal is not to get you in, their goalpost is to create future presidents or future CEOs or those kind of things. And so I it was said really well, really well is like doing it just to impress is probably the fastest way to get rejected.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Right. So if you think about what Harvard's perspective is or any perspective, which by the way, you're right. Um anyone, I think, who gets a degree anywhere in the many different graduate schools or or the college at Harvard, uh, I think knows by the time you graduate that eight U.S. presidents went through Harvard and that the second most presidents for any school was Yale with three. And I think everyone knows that because Harvard cares. Like there, we, you know, you hear it, and you hear about all the senators and you hear about all the Supreme Court justices and the Nobel Prize winners and all the different people who did great things after experiencing Harvard. And um, it's clear that Harvard cares, that their alumni are going out and making a meaningful impact in the world. I can tell you that there is a sense of reverence on campus for Harvard's place in the world. And people take it very seriously. And so considering who is going to play a part of that, you know, that that place in the world, it's a it's a decision that is not taken lightly. And the other schools, absolutely, they want to find are you going to be the next New York Times bestselling author? Are you going to start a company that makes the world better? Because if you are, we want you on our campus. We want you coming from our campus so we can have that honor and glory, you know, from there. Um, meanwhile, your your deeper question, is this coming from the students? Is it coming from the parents? Who's really the most ambitious element here? And I don't know that it always matters. Sometimes it does. If the if there's a big disconnect, if one side or the other truly doesn't care, and there's, you know, it's, it's, it's really that can matter. But as long as there's at least some alignment between parents and child, sometimes the parents take the lead, sometimes the child takes the lead. And uh what I am excited about is the fact that there's ambition in there, because when you want to do great things, even if you don't fully appreciate, you know, even just among the eight Ivy League schools, they're they're so dramatically different. And what they focus on and how they how they value students and value interactions, some are similar. Harvard and Yale are obviously very similar. Um, but the difference between, you know, uh Cornell and um and Brown uh is pretty, pretty dramatic. Um and so it's okay if someone doesn't really fully understand all of those details when they get started and all they're saying is, I want to have high standards. I've always pushed myself to be the best, and it seems like going to the best school possible is a great idea. That's enough. Uh and it's okay if that starts with parents having high standards and the teen adopts them along the way. What is a struggle, I think, is if there's an imbalance, if either the parents don't care, but the teen cares a lot, or vice versa, and then it's it is hard to hard to provide the support that they need.
SPEAKER_01So, not to overly generalize or stereotype or like that, but what do Ivy League or top 10 students have in common? What are those commonalities that are getting kids consistently into these schools? And what are the commonalities of kids getting rejected to those schools?
SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness. What a cool question. Yeah. Understanding that anytime anyone gives you a rule uh about college applications, uh at college admissions, whether it's never do your personal statement about this or always do this or that, someone has broken that rule and gotten into Harvard and MIT. All right. So understanding that this is just broad strokes and we're talking broad strokes here. I love the question. So I would say a couple of things. First of all, um, let's start with the people who are getting rejected. Even though they worked really, really hard, these are people who might have become the valedictorian. Um, they certainly have, uh, when they find out that there's only 10 spots on the activities list, they're really bummed because they've been working hard to get 25 activities and they're frustrated that they can only do 10. And so they ask questions like, well, in the additional information section, can I add an addendum that has all 34 publications and all, you know, whatever else that just shows how relentless I've been for all these years? That is kind of the ethos of this person who's in what I call the bottom tier of college applications. At of course, we're talking about a very small percentage because we're talking about the tippy top schools here, right? Not the bottom tier of college applications, but the bottom tier of students who worked really hard and are applying and think they have a really good chance of getting into a top 10 school or a top 25 school. That bottom tier is I'm a great student. And all of the evidence that they produce is around that mindset. I'm a great student. Look, I joined debate and I rocked it. I became a, you know, regional champion, state champion. I made it to nationals, I qualified, or whatever. Um, I do math and science Olympiads. And look, I don't just do them, I win. Look at how far I've gotten. Um, I don't just join the club, I became the president of the club. I don't just join the team, I became the captain of the team. And I've taken the most rigorous classes possible, and then I've done this research and yada, yada, yada. Okay. And everything that you're doing says, you know, all that stuff that was available to high school students? I did it. I did the best of anyone in my whole school. I am the most impressive student in my whole school. That is the bottom tier. The next tier, the kind of the middle tier, is I've not just spent time in these activities that were created by someone else specifically for high school students to do, right? Realize that debate and math and science Olympiad and all the sports, all those things, those were organizations and activities created by adults for high school students to play with, right? It's like a big sandbox that the adults created. And it's like, do your best to make this the coolest sandcastle possible inside the sandbox. But you're still inside the sandbox. Even if you win, even if you're the captain, even if you're the founder of the club, you're still inside the club is for high school students inside of a high school, and you're probably filling out all sorts of documents and jumping through hoops so that you can get an advisor from a from faculty or whatever else, you're in the sandbox, right? You're being, you're being led by adults as a teenager. The second tier says, you know, that messy, complex world outside of education? I have experience there too. I have experience in a world where uh if I get this wrong, there are real consequences for real stakeholders. There are people who suffer because of my decision making, or there are people whose lives improve because of my decision making. In a school setting, what happens? At the most, you win the competition or you don't, right? Um you win the thing, you become the president, you get the thing, or you don't. And that's that's the extent of the consequences. But you step into the messy world and you say, look, I care deeply ever since my grandmother passed away, and I regret how little time I spent with her. I've been visiting the assisted living center. And then that led to learning more about dementia. And then I realized holy cow, all these people who are struggling with dementia and their family members who have no idea how that transition looks and what they should be expecting. And then I looked at the materials that these family members are getting. And it's really not helpful. And so I worked with professionals and I worked with the hospital and I worked with the clinic and I worked with the assisted living center to provide better materials so I can help families of people who have, you know, grandparents transitioning into memory loss and into new challenges that they don't know how to face. Now I'm providing materials and filling a gap that never existed before. And I'm discovering that, man, if I communicate this the wrong way, I add extra stress to these families. If I communicate it the right way, then it makes things better for everyone. And the stakes are real and the stakeholders are real people. And I'm navigating the complexity of the world outside of the education bubble. Right? That's that middle tier. And the top tier is I've been navigating that complexity for a little while now, and I've become a bit of an expert. Maybe I've become a legitimate expert, but even if I'm just a bit of an expert, that's pretty good. Right. If I can show that I'm navigating this complexity in a way that that shows I'm not just comfortable with it, navigating ambiguity, I've become pretty good at it. And that's going to have to be something niche, something where, you know, I'm the only one who understands from my perspective, from this particular perspective, how these policies are influencing these people. And I'm navigating or I'm advocating for these changes. And I know exactly why the changes haven't happened, because I've talked to the three people who are the decision makers. And at some point, you become the authority on fixing this problem, whether it's big or small, you can become the expert on this. And that's kind of the top tier of stories that we can tell. So one thing that we're seeing is that students move out of the bottom tier into those top tiers if they're getting in. The second thing is they are authentic to themselves. So the entire application, even in the context of getting out of high school box and into the messy world boxes, it is aligned with who they really are. And so everything we do begins with clarifying your core values and deciding what kind of impact you want to make in the world that aligns with those core values. Everything begins with that self awareness. What truly matters to you and why? Why do these things issue? Why do these issues matter more than those issues, et cetera? So you clarify what your core values are and what kind of impact you want to make. And then you start making that impact in complex environments that have real stakes for real people. And the final thing I would say with people, that that difference between people who worked really, really hard but still get rejected and people who don't is there's a, and I'll summarize this in just a second because I realized this was a little bit of a winding answer. But uh there's there's this sense of exceeding expectations, right? Where given the your parents, your zip code, your socioeconomic status, your teachers, your opportunities at your school, et cetera, et cetera, given all the resources that you have available to you, would we expect someone else to come in who had those same resources and perform about the same as you? Or did you far exceed your expectations given what you had available to you? Because if you really exceeded expectations with not that many resources, imagine what you could do on our campus with our resources. And that gets an admissions officer really excited. So three things. The difference between two people who work equally hard, and in many cases, the rejected person works harder, right? But two people working hard enough to get admitted. The person who is uh who is getting rejected and waitlisted is someone who started with what are admissions officers looking for? How do I impress them? How do I do more? How do I scale this? How do I make it bigger? Uh, more, more, more, more, more. And and that seems to be kind of the thing that they're endlessly pursuing. Versus the person who gets accepted is saying, let's start with who I am and why that matters. What is my unique contribution to this planet because I have the values that I have that care about the things that I care about, and I am me. And I am in this community that I'm already in. So what does that mean? Who am I? Why does that matter? That's the beginning point. As we're answering that question, how do I transition from the bottom tier of I'm a great student into those second and third tiers of, or middle and top tiers, of I can handle complexity and ambiguity and I can handle it really, really well. Right. And finally, we should see that my story is a story of exceeding expectations, that given the resources that I had available to me, I stepped outside of what would be normally accepted. So if I'm at an elite private school, I'm going to be expected to test really well and take lots of APs and do well. I've got to do something where I'm navigating complexity, um, either inside or outside of that private school in order to kind of exceed expectations that are already very, very high. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, it really kind of doubles down on what I've already known, but it's very hard to convey to parents that are set in their minds that their kids should be doing a passion project or an insert internship or research because that a research project, because that's what Ivy leagues are looking for. And your entire what you I mean, like what you went into is completely the opposite. It's it is we talk about putting the why before the what of like, why do you even want to go to these schools? Like, what, like, why do you need to go to an Ivy League school for that? Um, so we still, you know, we kind of still Simon Sinek saying starting with the why. But it's like you're you it's it's manufactured results versus like I versus actual authenticity. Um in a way, it's like dating. The harder you chase it, the probably the more you're gonna push it away, right? In terms of these competitive things.
SPEAKER_00It's like in in many ways, yeah. If if you work on yourself, let me let me be the best future boyfriend, girlfriend possible, right? And then I'll I'll find lots of opportunities. Or I just gotta chase this one person relentlessly, no matter what, and that becomes toxic and desperate and tons of icky energy. Um, schools, you know, I don't know that very many, you know, 14 or 15-year-olds know why they want to go, why they have high standards, why they want to go to a top school instead of a another great option. Um, they just know that they want to have high standards and they know that other people think it's cool if you go to one of these name brand schools. And I think that's enough to get started. But what I think is important is that desire to be great, to have high standards and to hold yourself to a high standard actually pushes you to do the work that um is the healthy work anyway, the work that's going to make you more successful long term. And I really feel like college applications and college admissions, this whole preparation journey is a gift if you use it correctly. It's the gift that keeps giving, actually. Because if you don't stop and say, what are my core values? What matters to me? Like what kind of legacy do I want to leave behind? Who do I really want to grow into? If you don't stop and ask those questions when you have a really clear reason to do so for college applications, when you look at the college application, if you've guided people through this, you know, man, how much easier it is to answer these supplemental essays and even the personal statement if you've done deep thinking about your core values and why those things matter to you. So if you're not doing that thinking work in order to prepare for college, when are you going to do it? It's going to be when there's some midlife crisis or some death in the family, some tragedy that occurs that causes you to question all of your life choices. And then maybe you're going to start thinking about what really matters to you, what kind of values you have. So that's the first gift that college application, this whole college prep process gives us. And then along the way, the cool thing is the healthiest approach to life, like starting to develop the skills you need in order to make the impact you want to make because you want to live your values more fully, that's actually the more compelling path for an admissions officer. If they see you saying, look, you I value this thing so much because of this or that thing that happened to me. And so I am uh I am I am working on these, developing these skills so I can make this kind of impact. And I have a real story to tell about this. That's what gets an admissions officer real excited. Maybe I can, would it be helpful to share an example of this? Yeah. That's right. Let me share an example of someone who I mean, this just came to mind as I was describing this, and I thought an example would make this come to life. So there was a student in my uh online course, right? Where the whole point of the online course is to first clarify your core values and then uh figure out what kind of impact you want to make in your community that aligns with those values. And then the last thing we do is figure out how to tell that story in your college applications. And when he started the course, he was he wanted to be a doctor. Really normal among ambitious teens. Lots of them want to become doctors. That's great. And and what I didn't know at the beginning of the course is that he wanted to be a doctor because a couple of years earlier, his best friend died of cancer. And for two years, he watched his friend deteriorate. And at first, when he first got sick, um, this student, my student's name is Corey. Corey would bring him his homework and his friend, they would do their homework together in the hospital, in his room, and then Corey would deliver his homework to the teacher. And uh, so he was kind of this liaison. And as his friend got sicker and sicker and sicker, he wasn't doing homework anymore. They would just talk. And then he got too sick to talk, and they would just sit together and he watched this whole process happen. And when he watched this happen, he noticed that the doctors were really, really caring and really great. And they would talk about what's happening biologically in his body and why they were doing this test or that test and why they were doing this procedure or that procedure. But never once in two years did he see a doctor ask about his friend's mental health. And he was asking, he was following up, and he thought, that's man, that's a that's a that's a gap, right? These doctors, I know they're loving, I know they're caring, I they're amazing. And they're not asking about his mental health. And he decided that he, when he was a doctor, he's gonna fix that. So that's what he decided. Then he starts my class. And about three or four weeks into the class, or it was longer than that, five or six weeks into the class, he says, you know what, I've always wanted to be a doctor so I can fix this. And now you're telling me that there are advantages to starting now rather than waiting until I'm quote unquote qualified to go make my impact. The impact that I always wanted to make anyway. But I'm not a doctor. How on earth do I change medicine, right? How do I change medical practices? But he began. And we use design thinking in the course, we use all these, you know, iterative thinking, and you you start taking small steps and you build momentum and you try to reach out to people. There's all these kind of things that you do. But the point is, he he should be developing the same skills that he thinks he's going to need later on to make the impact that he wants to make. And so he starts writing emails to the doctors that he already knew. And he says, Here's my thought, here's what I noticed. I always wanted when I become a doctor to change this, but now I want to change it now. Can you help me? And uh, and pretty soon he has the CEO of this oncology hospital, right? Uh, the three or four doctors that he became closest to, a psychologist that he's checking in on to see if his ideas about mental health checkups are right or wrong. He has all of these people in the same room in a meeting that he is leading. And he says, I think we should do this. And uh, and he fills out the internal review board form. Um, he uh needs some help with that, obviously, but he gets a double-blind study set up to test his ideas around how doctors could be spending an extra 30 seconds at the beginning of their of their uh intakes or the beginning of their uh interactions um checking in on mental health. And there's a decision tree. If there's some red flags, here's who they need to talk to. Not that we need to train doctors to become mental health experts. That's another issue that when you're managing complexity, right, they're they're not uh prepared for this. But we can train them quickly to ask the right questions and then get a trained mental health expert in. And so all these things uh he is learning how to do. And here's the cool part. Here's what I want your audience to think about for a second. What happens if Corey waits until he finishes medical school, finishes residency, becomes a doctor, and then he begins this project? There's a very good chance, I know we're not interactive right now, but in my Harvard Summer School class, I would actually be asking the class for answers on this. And they would be saying things like, well, actually, we humans forget stuff over time. The memories become vague, and he might actually lose his passion around this because we're talking about a 20-year gap by the time he becomes quote unquote qualified. That's a real possibility. Another real possibility is that he remembers the process wrong, or he gets trained as a doctor on how you're supposed to talk to people, and he feels like that's more logical. And so he doesn't fight for this change because by that time the sting is gone, the memory has faded, and he's been trained and he's been trained out of his original ideas. Um, and then we probably 20 more examples of what might have happened if he waited 20 years. But here's the biggest one, in my opinion. His perspective is the perspective of a child. And that's the value that he brings to the story. There's a million doctors. All these doctors have the perspective of someone who's been trained through medical school about how they're supposed to interact with children who are sick, right? All of these doctors have been trained. We, that perspective is not valuable. What is valuable? The perspective of a 12-year-old or a recent 12-year-old, I mean, he's 15 by the time he gets started with all of this, but the perspective of an adolescent who just watched his friend go through this for two years, that's really valuable. And so ironically, the fact that he's not, air quotes here, qualified, quote unquote qualified, is exactly what makes him qualified. The fact that he is too young to be actually making decisions around this, but that he is in a position in life where he sees things differently than someone who is quote unquote qualified. And because of that, he can bring up the questions and he can talk to people who can guide that complexity and he can start managing that. And right now, as we speak, he is leading a double-blind study at a hospital, an oncology hospital, right, for pediatric cancer, um, and uh testing whether or not this intervention is going to help elevate the mental health of cancer patients, pediatric cancer patients. He's leading that double-blind study right now, and it is, they have already completed the IRB forms and everything else to get published in a medical journal that doesn't allow anyone to publish if you don't have a medical degree. But he's the lead researcher on this, on this, uh, on this account, right? On this research. And so, I mean, if you think about all the pieces that go into that story, first he clarified his core values and what really matters to him. And then he's challenged to go make a difference now that aligns with his core values rather than waiting until you're quote unquote qualified. And you're gonna run, you're gonna knock, you know, you're gonna get knocked over several times when you do stuff that you're not qualified to do. It's gonna feel like a gut punch. You're gonna make mistakes. And if you start small and build momentum and you generate a team, you develop a team that can support you through this process, guess what? You're gonna develop the kinds of skills that make it really, really clear, not just to admissions officers, to future employers, to the open market, that make it clear that you're the person that should be solving these problems and you're the one that should be paid appropriately to solve really big problems because you've got the experience, you've done, you've developed the skills, you've got the network of relationships, uh, the everything that you need, the mindset, et cetera, uh, to be a problem solver. And then an admissions officer is going to say, Holy cow, this kid's going places. They're gonna be solving big problems soon. We'd better attach our name to this wagon before he gets before someone else does.
SPEAKER_01This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supported tutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. Steve, that is a deeply I mean that that story is really, really awesome that you shared. Um, I guess what I take away from it is it's funny because it's parallel to kind of things that I've talked to teachers about. It it's reflective practice, like there had to be some kind of reflect and reflection in that to get that story out to ultimately tie it to a greater thing, to a bigger thing, like without the actual skill of reflecting on and making sure that connections. And so, how how does that happen? I guess how do we do that for kids or how parents listening right now? How do you get your kid to actually be reflective when the entire world is designed to not do that and just to consume and move on, right? Like we're just like it's snip it, snip it, snip it, where it's like to actually have that deep connection on the why, right? Of why I want to do this. Um, you know, you you explained it pretty eloquently, but like, how do you, if I'm a parent listen, like how the heck do I get my kid to do that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that's a really important question. There's a reason why the uh course that I do is in a cohort environment. It's with uh, you know, other teens on Zoom at the same time so that I can teach for 15 minutes and then put them in breakout rooms. Because the real breakthroughs happen when two teens are both ambitious, they both have the same fears, same concerns, they don't know what they don't know, but they don't want to talk about it in school because not everyone is is as ambitious or whatever. There's a million different reasons why this doesn't happen. But they get into a breakout room and they start talking through that and they say, Oh, wait, you have the same fear as me? You're like the star of this whole thing. You're also afraid of this. Maybe, maybe I'm maybe I'm okay. Right. And and you start to have those breakthroughs. But let me let me give you just some of the exercises. Um, we have uh over a dozen exercises that we do over the course of four weeks. Um, and uh one of the first things that we do is we ask the students, and I guide them through this visualization. Like I literally ask them to close their eyes and visualize all of this, but I guide them through a visualization of arriving at their own funeral and thinking back on the life that they've lived, the impact that they've made, the legacy that they leave behind, what people are saying at their funeral, what they're talking about. Um, and I ask them to write their own eulogy. So they write a eulogy that says, you know, this person was known for uh her kindness, her expertise, her ability to solve any problem, whatever. And they write out the legacy that they want to have left behind. And that's kind of one of the first things that we do. Um, we also have a class where I'm asking, there are a dozen questions, but I can give you uh many of them, uh just kind of rapid fire here. But I ask the question, and then everyone's on mute for several minutes until I ask the next question. And you get into this deeper reflective state, and that's a 40-minute exercise of just every few minutes there's a new question, and you're just writing, writing, writing, writing, writing. Um, and so questions like, what makes you angry, right? Or what breaks your heart? These are things that violate your values. So you may not know what your values are, but you know what is unusually painful for you. It breaks your heart or it makes you angry. You feel like the world just shouldn't be this way. Those are issues that violate your values. Uh, the things on the opposite that bring you joy, the communities that you wish you could spend more time with. These are things that align with your values. Um, how you, you know, the people that you admire, um, the the ways that you define success. Again, how you what you want your legacy to be. These are all questions that kind of get the student to be thinking about that. And then again, the key is you finish that and they're right back into a breakout room. All right, talk about what was most impactful, talk about what was most meaningful. And as they hear each other being vulnerable and they hear each other, you know, other teens that are the same age talking about, and also the in these, in these cohorts, there's someone's in eighth grade, someone else is in 11th grade. And so um, they, you know, they're at different stages, and the 11th grader can kind of be a little bit of a mentor in these breakout rooms, and and that also has an incredible value all to itself when you're when you're the one that you know they're looking up to. And it's really helpful to be an eighth grader and see an 11th grader that you have that you can look up to, talking about their fears and talking about their vulnerabilities and talking about their values and how they want to live them. Um, we also I recommend uh creating a bucket list. Come up with 50 things to do before you die. It should be fun. It shouldn't be a stressful assignment, it should be really exciting. When you come up with that list, that's gonna point to things that charge you, that give you energy. And that is data that you can use to kind of help understand uh what your values are. Um, we ask the students to uh interview five people, not really interview. You're just asking them to give you words that they would use to describe you. And then we go through an exercise where this where the students evaluate those words that they've received from five people or more. Um, so at least 15 of these adjectives, 15 words that describe you. And then what are you taking from this? What do you understand about this? What three words would you use to describe yourself? What about the three words you would use to describe yourself at your best? Um, and so on. There's just a number of exercises like this that slowly unlock this kind of this side of you that's underneath that drives ultimately why you care about the things you do. And kind of the overarching, if you're a parent listening in, what you're looking for is not just what is exciting for the teen, what they want to do, how they want to spend their time. You're looking for why they are driven to do that. Um, and it could be, I just want to be the best. All right, well, why does it matter to you to be the best? Um, and if you just ask it like that, you're not gonna get very far. But if you keep probing with all these different exercises and then you keep asking, you do start to find, oh, there's this connects to that and this connects to that. That totally makes sense. And once you find it and it just feels right, it feels like everything starts to make sense now within this context, you know you found these kind of core values that drive your behavior. And if you align, here's the thing: if you depend on self discipline and willpower to outwork someone else, that is not a fair fight. If you are, if you're depending on self discipline and willpower against someone else who has their core values that they're recharging every time they go make a difference in the world, they're recharging their own batteries, even if they're tired, they're feeling energized by this, right? Even if calorically they're using up energy. They're still recharging their batteries at the same time. That is not a fair fight. The person who's aligned with their core values is going to win every single time.
SPEAKER_01Love it. Love it. Steve, what do you want families to take away from this conversation in closing?
SPEAKER_00Man, I feel like we're just getting started.
SPEAKER_01Well, speaking of the day for you. I definitely want to have you back on, man. If it works out, I I we could definitely we could have more conversation. You want to have me on your podcast, would love to love to carry on the conversation. Um I uh Yeah, no, I mean it's it's it's definitely a whole different take than what I've I've interviewed a lot of college coaches, and it's it's definitely uh aligned. I will say that it's a lot deeper than I think you've hear from most people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I mean, we have uh I'll I'll give you maybe a uh one more representative example to kind of tie some of this together. I had a student last year. Um he applied to lots of great schools and he got into them. I he got into all the UCs, he got into Yale and Caltech and Stanford. Um, and he was not the only student from his school who got into those three, let's call Yale, Caltech, Stanford, right? Um and he applied early action to Yale. So he didn't apply to a bunch of schools that he probably would have gotten into also. He only, once that was done, he only, once he got his results back from Yale, he only applied to a couple other schools. But um, lots of students in his in his school applied to all three of those schools. And he's the only uh his high school applied to all three of those colleges. And he's the only one from his high school that got into any of those three colleges. And he was not the valedictorian or the salutatorian. Um, he was a great student, but not the best of the best in that way. And he didn't learn until the graduation ceremony. He didn't learn that the valedictorian of the school um who applied to all three, Yale, Stanford, and Caltech, did not get into any of those three. Uh, that student is going to be going to UC Berkeley this year, which is a great school. But from what I understand, he's disappointed in his results and a little bit, you know, upset that who's this kid that didn't perform as well as me, but got into better, you know, schools that I wish I could have gotten into. Um, and and my student learned at this high school graduation ceremony where the valedictorian spoke that he had a secret agreement with the school to take seven AP classes every year, starting his freshman year. And so he had 20 plus, you know, I don't know if he kept that up and actually had 28 uh APs or or what, but he had 20 plus AP um classes over his four years of high school. And uh, I don't know, uh every single year I get multiple stories from my students about how they are not the valedictorian in their school, but they're friends with the valedictorian. And the valedictorian got rejected to the same schools that they got into. It happens so consistently that it's not a one-off, it's not an exception. Uh, a university that is looking at thousands, tens of thousands of applications, when they get what I call an impressiveness trap application, they use a different term for it. They might call it a SAMO, which is same as many others. That's the, you know, admissions officers, if you're talking about college applications all day for months at a time, thousands of applications, you learn shorthand to get big ideas across very quickly. And so one of those shorthands is this idea of SAMO, SAMO, same as many others. And this is a really ambitious, hardworking student, but we can't tell who they are or why that matters. So we can't figure out where they might fit into this rich, diverse class of students that we're creating, right? We're trying to shape this rich, diverse class. This is a obviously very hardworking student, 20 plus APs, maybe 28 AP classes, harder than almost anyone we've ever seen, but we don't know who they are. We don't know how they might fit into the class. We don't know what their values are. We don't know, you know, we just don't know who they are. And so what do we do with the SAMO application? Oh, well, let's put it in the SAMO pile. And it just turns out that that SAMO pile is tens of thousands of applications deep. Because if you become the valedictorian in your school, it's not impossible to also align with your values. People do it all the time, but you're far less likely to align with your core values if you have to work so hard to outrun everyone else, right? It's it's much harder to develop a story where you're navigating complexity because you care about solving this problem that aligns with, that matters to you because you know what your values are, right? It's much less likely that you spend your time that way if you're spending so much of your time becoming the most impressive student in the school. And so while you're in high school, it appears that no one else could possibly be a better choice than you. You're clearly the most impressive in your whole school, but that's the impressiveness trap. You're getting cheered on, you're being applauded. Everyone is sure that you're going to get into every school that you apply to. And then you don't because your application, well, you worked very, very hard for it, it's become invisible. Instead, you want to clarify what really matters to you and build a story around that, a story of how you are making the world a little bit better. Even if your world is tiny, even if we're talking about just your neighborhood, just your group of 10 people that also love this thing, whatever. Even if that world is tiny, you, because you are living your values, you are making that world a better place. And as you do that, you're doing it in a way that navigates complexity, that navigates ambiguity, that takes into account different stakeholders and the fact that different people have different ideas about even just what it means to win or lose in this game. And by winning over here, you might be causing other people to lose. And do you understand how complex this can be? Do you understand what it's like to solve real problems in the real world? Even if your problems are small, just showing that you have navigated this complexity, you've navigated this ambiguity well, that makes admissions officers really hopeful. Um, because you're much more likely to go on and make a difference in the big, bad complex world after you graduate from college. That becomes really exciting for them.
SPEAKER_01Well, Steve, I do appreciate your time and coming on and sharing all those insights. Um, where's the best place for people to find you and learn more about what you guys do?
SPEAKER_00Oh, thank you. Well, I appreciate you mentioned uh my podcast. That is by far the best uh place, the Ivy League Prep Academy podcast. Um, from what I understand, if you just type Ivy League into Spotify or uh Apple Podcasts, mine will be at the top. Um, my website is the Ivyleague Challenge.com. And you can look for me. I write articles for Business Insider, for other publications, but principally Business Insider. You can find me there as well. Um and as is happening more and more every year, come say hi to me at uh a Harvard Summer School. I couldn't believe how many students this last term uh recognized me from the podcast or from my articles and and came up and said hi. And I I love to meet people um just either through LinkedIn or on campus or wherever. Um, when when you found my work helpful, uh, I'd love to hear about that. But I would say primarily the podcast, the Ivy League Prep Academy Podcast or my website, uh the IvyLeagueCallenge.com.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. We'll put all those uh the show notes in the YouTube description. And I want to thank you all for tuning in to the Supported Learning Podcast, and I'll see you next time. Steve, thank you so much. Thank you. It's been wonderful. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.