SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 84 - Ex-Admissions Director: Your Kid Evaluates College Backwards - Chuck Erickson
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Chuck Erickson, independent educational consultant at College Connectors and former associate director of admissions, to break down why most families evaluate colleges completely backwards and what actually determines whether a student will thrive.
Dr. Joe and Chuck discuss why rankings and social media are the worst way to choose a college, how institutional priorities quietly shape who gets admitted and who gets scholarship money, why campus climate including weather, location, dorm quality, and cultural vibe is the most undervalued factor in the college decision, why California students are the most recruited by private colleges nationwide, the fastest growing enrollment trend in the country right now, and why families should be starting this process in eighth grade rather than waiting until junior year.
This episode is especially useful for parents beginning the college search who feel overwhelmed by brand names and rankings, families looking for hidden gems and affordable paths that don’t sacrifice quality, students who picked a dream school from social media without visiting, and anyone wondering whether the traditional four-year path is still the right move.
📲 Connect with them: https://collegeconnectors.com/team-members/chuck-erickson-m-ed/
Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/dont-chuck-it-up-college
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@DontChuckItUp
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chuckerickson/
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Book a call: supportedtutoring.com/book-call-youtube
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, balloons taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. He has spent uh nearly two decades in higher education inside University Missions and on the independent consulting side. And he works for College Connectors. He also helps fellow counselors at two major national organizations, IECA and HECA. He also uh is involved in a podcast on college emissions, and he's specifically one of the most consultants uh that avoids the topic of he talks about campus climate evaluation and advocacy for underrepresented students and the actual work of figuring out whether a school will let a student thrive, not just admit them. Chuck Erickson is here today, and we're getting to why most families evaluate college backwards and how to actually measure campus fits and how AI is reshaping that process. Welcome back to the Support Learning Podcast. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college prep without wasting thousands of dollars and years of time. And the answer usually involves finding the people that figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. That's why I'm thrilled to have Chuck Erickson here today. Chuck is an independent educational consultant at College Connectors based in Appleton, Wisconsin. He holds a master's in higher education administration, has spent over two decades in post-secondary education, including prior leadership in university admissions, and helps fellow counselors across IECA and HECA, the two national professional associations in the industry. Especially his holistic college guidance with focus on campus climate evaluation, advocacy for underrepresented students. And he also uh contributes to a podcast on college admissions. So we're gonna dive into what actually measures campus fit and why most families evaluate colleges the completely wrong way, what financial aid strategies families miss and how AI is reshaping this whole process. Chuck, welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_00Dr. Joe, thank you so much for having me. It's really a pleasure to be here. And I'm really excited to chat with you today.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I mean, we just chatted beforehand too, just found out that your wife's the Steeler fan. So we'll have to we'll have to forgive you for that. But um, yeah, uh, so from Wisconsin, uh, you know, I've given them the highlight reel. You said you're the senior most product consultant for your company. Um, and I've given them kind of the 60-second version, or I've given them the highlight reel. But if you can this in your own words, like who are you and what specific problem are you solving for families?
SPEAKER_00As you said, I'm an independent educational consultant. I don't work for a specific high school or a specific college. I work with families directly and I help them navigate the college search and the application process. And I work for College Connectors. We are one of the oldest private educational firms in the Midwest. We've been around for over 25 years. And as you said, we really focus on finding fit. We want to make sure that students are fitting the college academically, socially, and of course also financially. And we really focus on doing a student-centered approach to make sure that those are the characteristics that we are looking for rather than some of the other metrics that we're going to talk about today.
SPEAKER_01So take me back about 20 or so years ago, you were inside college admissions, right? And you made the jump to the independent coaching and consulting side. What were you seeing uh that made you make that jump? And what were most families getting wrong that made you think, like, I need to help out in this area?
SPEAKER_00There was so much. So my last official role was associate director of admissions, transfer coordinator, and the diversity outreach and inclusion uh admissions counselor for the institution that I was working at last. And what I was really noticing is that students and families are so unbelievably confused by the college search and the application process. It is typically the first time that they are going through it, obviously. And it uses a lot of vocabulary, timelines, and just a lot of lingo that people are unfamiliar with. And I was spending a lot of my time helping students and families, you know, really peel the layers back, pull the curtain back, and help them understand how this all works. And I kind of said, wow, there's a space for this where I could be working separate from an institution and helping families directly. So about 12 plus years ago, I made the jump from working for a higher education institution to being an independent educational consultant. And now I work with students virtually all around the United States, and it's been a real joy to help students figure this out and not stress as much.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, your specialty and your essential lies in the Midwest. Uh, Wisconsin would definitely be categorized as Midwest. And, you know, it's interesting uh just reading your background and the approach to it. What are most consultants at the national level um like basically getting wrong about the college admissions from your perspective and how a lot of the big brands and and like a lot of the beliefs out there are stigmatizing and getting people to think college admissions works this way that you've actually experienced on the ground level, they don't and they work this way.
SPEAKER_00Well, one thing is even though I'm based in Wisconsin, I have toured over 250 colleges and universities all across the country. I have been into colleges and universities in, I believe, over 30 states now. And I think the hard part for many students and families, as well as consultants, too many people are focusing on the really easy information to grab, which would be the rankings that are out there and what people are catching on social media. And the hard part is that rankings only tell one side of the story and there are lots of metrics as to how rankings are put together. And social media is really pushed by our algorithm and who has a really good marketing budget to push their social media out there. So obviously, if you're an ESPN school, uh students and families are gonna see those colleges a whole lot more. Does that make them any better? I don't think so. I think it just means that you get to watch the football game uh on TV every weekend. I don't know if it makes the college experience that much more better, but people are more familiar. And in the United States, people tend to gravitate towards things that they are familiar with and that they have heard about uh via social media or online.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's tough because some of the biggest names in the in in the field right now in colleges, they really don't have to do any marketing, right? Their grads or their marketing form, everyone's heard of Harvard, everyone's heard of Stanford. Um, but you've actually said families evaluate that process and college backwards. They look at those rankings, the prestige before they look at whether a student will actually thrive there. Can you break that down for us?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so what they're looking at is the familiarity. As you said, Harvard and Stanford and institutions like those don't have to advertise. They're not looking at what actually happens within the institution. One of my role models, uh, Lauren Pope, who's a former educational writer for the New York Times, once said, we should be judging colleges the way we judge hospitals. When you look at a hospital, you want to see how do people look like coming out of the hospital, not looking like what they go into a hospital. And too many of the metrics and rankings look at what do students like look like when they go into a college or university and not what do they look like coming out of a college or university. And that's where I really think that students need to think beyond the name brand and figure out what is happening to a student academically, socially, uh, location-wise, that helps prepare them for their next step after college.
SPEAKER_01But how hard of that is how hard is it to have that conversation with parents? Because oftentimes I'm sure, and I'm not sure how much you you do on the acquisition side of things, but but parents are coming to us already with those preconceived notions kind of saying, Yep, this is what I want from my kid. And the kid necessarily hasn't done that exploratory search, they're just being told by the parents. Are you finding that an increase or a decrease in recent years?
SPEAKER_00I I think it's a mixed bag. And I really think that parents are coming to us saying, I have heard these schools are the best, or from when I went to look at college 25, 30 years ago, these were the best schools and the best processes. Yeah, a lot of the colleges that students have heard about and parents talk about were much easier to get admitted to 30 years ago, and the process has changed. This is not the same, even as it was last year. Every year I have to update myself as to what changes are happening in order to help students navigate this process in a better way. So it is really hard. And I have to have students and parents really think about okay, what is your goal? And for most parents, the goal is I want my student to be happy and I want my student to be successful in some way, shape, or form. So if that is the route as to what we are trying to get to, wouldn't you want to find the college that is going to best make them happy academically and socially and set them on a path for success? In the United States, we mostly look at where a person goes to their final institution. So where did they get their law degree from, their business degree from, their medical degree from? We don't typically think about where do they start when they were 17. You know, a lot of people change paths and a lot of people change institutions. So again, we need to be thinking about what is the long-range goal, not exactly particularly where are we starting with that, with that journey.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's great. I feel I feel like I'm listening to uh my conversations I've had with many families, kind of in reverse. Of we talk about starting with the why, even why do you want to go to college? And it's funny, I don't know if your company's experienced this too of how like this have so many families that think the BSMD is the only way to become a doctor or that they have to go to Harvard to be a doctor. I'm like, listen, medical school's expensive enough. I would go undergrad as cheap as possible.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. And I I get that question often. And I'll say if you look, Harvard Medical doesn't typically list what colleges that they recruit from because when you apply to med school, the biggest factor is things like recommendations from your professors, your MCAT score, and the factors that are not directly connected to what is the name of the institution that you went to. So it is really hard to do that. The BSMD, I have parents that went through the BSMD when they were in college, and they have flat out told me, like, please don't recommend this to your students. It is a lot of work, it is a lot of stress, it's a lot of money. And uh I did it, but I if I was to go back and do it again, I would not do the BSMD program. And now that's not true for everyone, but I've definitely had some parents say, caution your students, because it's it's really a grind and a drive.
SPEAKER_01Well, and I think even staying with the doctor route, too, of like it's like having those honest conversations of like, well, why does your kid want to be a doctor? And I know a lot of our families, I'm sure, are similar, they want the prestige and the name of a doctor. But there's also the, well, I view that as a sure path to making six figures, maybe multiple six figures, and a definition of successful, even though I know plenty of doctors that are miserable and then buried in debt. But like, you know, even now, just in how sh different the workforce looks, where medical systems and healthcare providers, because of the rising cost of insurance, they're looking to expand their nursing practitioners, their uh physicians' assistants, their nurse anesthesists versus anesthesiologists. There's actually a better pathway, an easier pathway, still with the same level of prestige and successful in income. And I think there that's a missing link, especially in high schools in terms of career guidance, of like actually doing that exploratory search of why, getting back to that as well. Um not to get too off track. And of course, I can't pull it up because I don't subscribe to the Wall Street Street Journal. I just have news. But I don't know if you saw that college enrollment of like coming for bigger schools in the Wall Street Journal. Um, it kind of talks about uh, I just the mission trends have plummeted, not just in the last 30 years, 20, 10 years, uh, for those top schools, where even if like you got to Harvard, you went to Harvard, and maybe as a legacy, like even that you probably went to Harvard when the acceptance rate was above 30%, and now it's like three. So like it's it's changed completely in that ending, in that indicator.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and I get that a lot. I get parents that went to you know, UC Berkeley, UCLA, UPenn, Duke, Princeton, Harvard, Stanford. They go, Well, my kid is smarter than I was when I was in high school, and I went to this, you know, very well-known school. So my kids should be able to get there. And I said, Well, the landscape has drastically changed, the admissions process, and especially the acceptance rate, has drastically changed. And getting back to your thought about career exploration, I'm a huge advocate of parents and schools talking with students about what it takes for a career path and a career direction. We should be talking about that in middle school, to be honest. And the vast majority of students that come to see me have not done any thought or reflection as to what type of career they want or why they want it. To your point, the doctor, it's like, well, I can make a lot of money and you know, those types of things. Actually, there are many other medical fields that you probably can make money faster. If remember, if you're gonna be a doctor, you're probably not gonna get your first paycheck until you're in your 30s. Uh, so you're gonna be living on some serious ramen and mac and cheese for a while until you actually get a paycheck. So, yeah, we need to have some conversations about career paths and opportunities. Again, that could be four-year college, two-year college. You know, there's lots of different paths out there, but students and parents are just not aware of what all is available.
SPEAKER_01And that it is really a moving target year to year. I think we, and there's so many different ways we can go with it. Like the chase of, well, I heard my neighbor, my friend, my her older brother, so-and-so did this and this and this and got into this prestigious school. Therefore, I will do the same, but now, like basically more generic. It's like, well, if the college took, it'll understand that if they already took that, they're looking for something different the next time around. They're not looking for the same.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's where I have to fight uh social media a lot. There are students who have been admitted to some of the most selective colleges who then get on social media and say, Well, this is what I did to get into X, Y, Z institution. Pay me money and I will help you do the exact same thing. And to your point, exactly. Colleges are recruiting communities. They want a wide variety of people and thinkers and doers. And so just because that one student was admitted, and we don't ultimately know why that one particular kid was admitted, doesn't mean the same process is going to work. You can't rinse and repeat and have it work for the next kid the next year.
SPEAKER_01I like that you focus on campus climate evaluation. I know we kind of got sidetracked on it, but I think that's a really good point to come back to because a student we have helped, excuse me, last year, uh, Mila, shout out to her. She got basically equivalent of two full rides offers, one to the University of Chicago, which a lot of kids or their dream school want to go. There was hers too. And she also got a full ride University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign, with the PayPal scholarship where she got to meet the CEO of the PayPal of PayPal. And she actually never set foot on UC or University Urbana Champaign, but she did go to University of Chicago for the summer program, and she did not like the campus. So thinking she would like it, she's like, I do not want to go here. So when she even got accepted there, she's like, I'm good. And it's so funny of how many, how much conversations I have, especially in our like in our programs, of kids on the West Coast that are like want to go to the Northeast. And I'm like, listen, I'm from Pittsburgh. Like, I I've seen so many kids come for CMU and Pit, and they're and listen, I'm a graduate of Pitt, so I'm not gonna talk back about, but like it's gray here, it snows. Harvard is really cold in the winter, like, and you're from San Diego, California. So, like, do you know what it, you know, and it's like that's that's real, like, and it's also the dorms. I mean, I know it's there's a big push now to modernize a lot of things, but sometimes your dorm is literally the 1800s in some cases.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there are some very prestigious colleges that have not updated their residence halls in probably 50 to 75 years. Uh, yeah, but that campus climate is important. And this this generation doesn't think about weather or climate, literal climate at all. I have a client right now in Southern California who was really excited about Dartmouth. And I was like, Do you know where Dartmouth is? You are located in Orange County, and life in Dartmouth is drastically different than life in Orange County. And so we had to have this big, and it's like I literally had to pull it up on YouTube and we did uh an aerial tour, basically, and and she was like, Oh, that's that's like the middle of nowhere up there. I was like, Yeah, this is this is not a major city. This is a small town that happens to have a really great college located in it. But yeah, you need to find the fit for not only the school, but the location. And I talk about my own journey. I got a full tuition scholarship to a university, and I ultimately chose not to take it because I did not think the location and the vibe of the campus was the right fit for me. And it was a really good university. This is one that students apply to now and go, wow, that's a great school. And I did not take it because when I visited, I just was, I just was not feeling it. And I checked it out in multiple directions. I always caution families. Sometimes one visit isn't the best visit. The weather could suck, the tour guide could be horrible, and you just could not have a great time. So you may want to view a college from multiple viewpoints online tours, virtual conversations, presentations, connecting with admissions, and then also in-person stuff. But yeah, it you need to check it out. Students don't know about location, uh, weather, climate, city, uh, political vibe, all of those things are factors as to if you're going to enjoy your college experience.
SPEAKER_01I'm just I'm laughing because I'm gonna give a shout-out to one of my friends and former colleagues, Rob Fleischer. If he's ever watching this, shout out to you. Because I used to teach with him in a DC charter school, and we went, there wasn't enough classrooms, so we actually had to share an office and we floated into classrooms. And we our running joke was listen, because it was a DC charter school, it was unbelievable, like a lot of lot of issues. Let's just say that, without going too deep into it. We're like, look at they put out an amazing brochure. Like their brochure, like it's yeah, everyone's college is sunny.
SPEAKER_00It's there's no like it's oh, oh my gosh, right? Oh my gosh, yeah. The amount of colleges, especially in the Midwest and the Northeast where snow is normal, that have absolutely zero pictures of snow on their website. Well, with exception of places like University of Vermont, because there's a ski hill right there and they want to promote the ski hill, but the vast majority of these places don't show it. Also, you know, Seattle area, which is one of the rainiest parts of the country, never shows a picture where it's raining. It's always sunny in Seattle. I'm like, my friends in Seattle will definitely tell me that it is not sunny that often in Seattle.
SPEAKER_01My sister's dream school, I still remember my parents taking the 14-hour drive to Minnesota. Her dream school was University of Minnesota for journalism originally. And but they visited in July. And they're like, listen, oh the rest of the year that people use the tunnels because we have so much snow. Like, it's like Yes, what? That's that's that's a crazy thing to say. Um, but that being said, like, I it's crazy because again, going back to the college emissions versus your career path, because I I go around, I talk to students, like see them in the cafeteria or whatever, at schools, and uh, you know, that I'm I'm working at and I have conversations, and I'm like, listen, if I had to do it all over again and I'm getting an education degree, I would have left Pennsylvania. Like, I there is a beautiful campus, no one's virtually heard about it, and it's one mile from the beach. Most people think it's coastal Carolina, it's actually University of North Carolina at Wilmington. Beautiful campus, and like it's I mean, like, it's every literally a mile away from what I think one of the best beaches on the East Coast, Rightsville Beach, but like you don't hear about it, and so like there's other places like that that have that. Um, and so that that is also an aspect of like getting out of the bubble because I do see people not, you know, they heard of the prestige and then they hear about their like regional, and they don't actually explore the vast majority of colleges in between, right?
SPEAKER_00And It's not even just regional, it's getting away from the familiarity of of what you hear online and again on social media. You know, I I shout out to UNC Wilmington, beautiful campus. I've toured there. Uh, I did it in July. It was a little warm, but it was a great campus visit. But I had a student that went to Eckard College in St. Petersburg, Florida, and it is literally on the beach. Like they have Sea Turtle Rescue as part of their campus. You know, like, and students always tell me, like, oh, I'd love to play with sea turtles. I said, I got a college for you that where they do sea turtle rescue right on the campus. Let me let me tell you about it. But there's again, we go back to what we talked about at the top of the show, is that a lot of parents are thinking it has to be a certain brand name. You know, people will go to places like Starbucks and Target and other brand names because they're familiar with it and they know that it has a history of doing well. So they do the same thing with colleges and universities. And there are nearly 4,000 institutions, over 2,700 four-year institutions. It is impossible for parents and students to be familiar with what is good and what is not. And the vast majority of colleges are great schools. Because if they weren't great, they wouldn't stay open. They would be closed. If they ended up doing a really horrible job, they would close. So if if they've been around for a long time, they're probably doing pretty well.
SPEAKER_01Let me ask you about your thoughts on this, because now that I've had conversations, um schools that weren't necessarily prestigious or super selective that are. So I'm gonna give you three um because I like I personally experienced one of them. I've heard about the other one. I haven't actually looked into it as much. And then one is a pretty, pretty well-known one. So I have a friend down is in is our EP program, the dad's in our EP program, him and his wife both went to NYU. He's like, NYU is super selective. When I was in school, it was a commuter school. Like it was like it was, you know, like 30, 30 years ago. Um, I feel the same way of case western. Case Western has become increasingly prestigious out of Cleveland and uh High Point, where they're like, and like all this change all of a sudden, where High Point's this like super desirable school to go to. What's that all about? I mean, now it's a the three different examples, right? But I am sure there's more there, you know. But like there's these is that mostly due to the early decision, decision prestige? Is that due to how they shifted their campus schools? Like, can you talk a little bit about what you're seeing having visited so many schools as a professional IEC?
SPEAKER_00And I have been to all three of those. So um NYU, they are one of the highest social media schools out there. Their social media process is insane. On my platforms, on my TikTok, Instagram, and other ways that students can connect with me, it is the college that students ask me about the most, literally, because they have so much social media out there that students are doing it. And it's New York University. That is, you know, I don't have to advertise New York because everyone knows what New York City is. And so they go, I want to go to college in New York City. What do you think pops up SEO-wise at the highest level? It's NYU. Uh, so that's why it's become more selective. And uh volume of applications means more selective. It does not always mean a better education, it just means more selective. More students are trying to get in the door, and there are only limited spots inside the door. So that's where that comes from. Ace Western is a very interesting one because they used to be much more well known and actually ranked significantly higher. Again, I'm not a huge thing on the rankings, but they were much more well known and things shifted. Also, the ranking culture changed. Rankings are now promoting more of the big public universities and less of the small research institutions. So Case Western kind of fell away from the view of people. I've got a student that's heading is probably in his first year right now, listening, uh, at Case Western Reserve University because there's an amazing medical program and connected to a hospital right there where they can get engaged with medical work as an undergraduate student. So I do see that Case Western is probably going to become more popular over the next few years as again, it increases its social media profile and gets his viewpoint out there. High Point University is a completely different place. It used to be High Point College, uh, used to be a very small regional institution in North Carolina. And then when its current president took over and uh it changed to High Point University, again, marketing took off. Uh, it is another one of those colleges that students will contact me about because the social media presence is huge and they revolutionized the campus. The campus looks nothing like it did when it was High Point College. Uh, almost everything on that university is brand new. And for many students, it's kind of the Instagram campus. There's lots of places that are a great place to take a picture. It offers great education, but it is a very visible brand new type feel of a college. It has that new college smell, shall we say?
SPEAKER_01This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focused on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supportedtutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. It's interesting because I'm not sure how familiar you are with the PSAC schools here in Pennsylvania, Division II. Like I went to Claring University for my undergrad. Um and my wife graduated from Slipper Rock. And when I was in school, they were very competitive with each other. And I still remember get on the football field. I I there was a lot of um players there from the Pittsburgh region. We actually used to take crazy hour trips down the Pittsburgh and like, you know, things like that to go see the steel, see like uh Steelers' talk shows and things like that. Um but one president with a strategic vision at Slipper Rock looked to expand their campus to be basically a regional school of Pittsburgh for kids in Pittsburgh to get out. Their campus grew exponentially from like four or five thousand to over 10,000, and they attracted some programs that feed into UPMC and the health systems there. Meanwhile, Clarion, their president, took them in a direction they were they were trying to build up to 10,000, and they took them in a direction of we want to stay local. And if you know anything about Pennsylvania, that entire middle part of the state has hollowed out people left. Right. Um, and it's it's interesting because the thing that I think parents have no idea about is the changing institutional priorities of schools and that they're looking for things different. Case in point, CMU kids are so you know, and they juggle with MIT with their rankings and uh engineering programs every year. But like CMU changed their institutional priorities. They're they're actually like sick of people coming in from out of state, getting a degree and bouncing, and they were looking for people to contribute to the Pittsburgh job market. So we've actually coached kids through that of like, you want to show that you want to be in the area long term, not just short term, to help as that too. What have you noticed in that trend of the institutional priorities like across the across the country?
SPEAKER_00Well, I even think the idea of institutional priorities doesn't cross most parents or students' minds. Yeah. Remember, as we talked about earlier, they're trying to build communities on these campuses. And so they're looking for students from a wide variety of areas. I tell my California students, you are one of the most desirable students outside of California. Okay, yeah. Like get out of California, and uh every college is like, yes, send us Californians, and but a lot of Californians never want to leave California. Uh a lot of the private colleges, to your point with CMU, don't get a whole lot of students from their own backyard. And I think it's partially because it's a campus that kids might go to summer camp on or they drive by often. And a lot of students will be like, I need to leave my home area to go to college. Sometimes the best option for college is literally in your own backyard. I have a student right now who can walk from her home to her private college. She's chosen to live on campus to really have the immersive experience, but she literally could walk if she wanted to. And so institutional priorities is something that I really focus on with my students and families, is helping them understand what is your value to an institution in possibly a different state or a different part of the country, um, or even in your own state. You know, for example, Texas is so massive and so big. A student from one part of Texas is actually very recruitable to a college in another part of Texas because you bring a different background and a different perspective.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I've noticed that too. So the answer to the Pittsburgh question, because we're like, I'm a boomerang person too. I left and I came back. And like people want pit, Penn State, you know, CMU is a lot less, but it's becoming more and more, especially with the engineering. And they're and CMU, I will say, has done an extremely well job of dealing that. I mean, they're especially they're beefing up their soccer programs to recruit kids. Um, so it's very interesting. But to your point of like you are actually more desirable out of state than you are in-state. Uh, a lot of people that I know are former graduates, now they're in the workforce. Uh, the big school a couple of years ago, a couple of my friends, their daughter, went to UK. And UK was they gave their her more money, basically made almost, I think, less than equal to or less than in-state tuition. Whereas Pitt Penn State, those ones didn't give her anything, and she got a fantastic degree there. And I see a lot of the SEC schools recruiting, giving tons of money to northern folk, and the same thing with California. And I don't understand this of like, it's so we're so ingrained to want the UC system. And it's like literally Arizona, Arizona State will give you exponentially more money to go there and virtually get a similar.
SPEAKER_00We're seeing some shifts. So both Arizona and Africa.
SPEAKER_01Now it's becoming now they're like, hold on, we you're I I heard that from South Carolina and from Georgia, like, we need to put a brakes on these out of out of staters here.
SPEAKER_00Right. So we so several years ago, the University of Alabama really launched this whole as a flagship school, we need to start recruiting kids from outside of our state. And the University of Alabama was the first one out of the gate to do this. And then we saw many of the other SEC schools, and then we saw places like Arizona, Arizona State start recruiting heavily out of state. And what happened was, and even here in my own state of Wisconsin, the state legislatures and parents got mad. They were like, what about my kids that are in my state? Would they want to go to Alabama or Old Miss or Arizona or here in Wisconsin, UW Madison? And we've now seen in the last couple of years a shift to, all right, we need to have programs that help our students stay in state for publics. I think that that is happening uh with the exception of underenrolled states. So if you want to go to the University of North Dakota, uh, if you want to go to the University of Maine, there are lots of scholarship opportunities to go there because they need kids. Now, what I think we were talking about a little bit earlier is more in connection to private colleges and universities because they're really trying to come up with the community that represents the entire country. So if you're looking to go to a private institution, you might have a higher uh value to a college that is farther away because they're really trying to check off the box and say we have a kid from all 50 states. Shout out to kids in North Dakota and Wyoming because every college wants you. Every college wants to say that they have someone from North Dakota or Wyoming. So if you're from those states, you're highly recruitable.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I have a girl on our program, her uh, the mom, her sister, they're in um yeah, they're in the Dakotas. And that's why I was like, it's actually that's a I was like, listen, geographically perfect position for Ivy League. Because they're because you're not competing against millions of kids from California or from New York. You're there, it's it's it's interesting. That's a it's funny. So okay. Um, but that goes back to the point of like this battle is gonna be continuing to shift. Um, God knows where we're gonna be in five, 10 years from now. Um as and I'm I'm saying this respectfully because I'm been in education for 16, 17 years, and I have three daughters, and I and my oldest is 10. And I'm first off, they're not gonna go through this process without someone, third party, not me, helping them. But if they want to go to college, and I that's a real conversation with AI right now. Like, do you need to go to school to get is it worth it at this point? Especially for the kid that has no idea what they want to do, because when I went to school, you could afford to go in undecided and discover yourself through that college process. But even if you didn't, you're making maybe an $18,000 to $24,000 total gamble. Now schools cost an insane amount of money, almost more than a mortgage in a lot of cases. You really can't do that. So, how do you help honestly kids and parents navigate that when you're like, do you even want to go to school? Should you go to school?
SPEAKER_00Well, one point first is there are still a lot of institutions where you can only pay 18 to 20,000 and get a great education. Again, it's getting away from some of the big brand names that you have heard of and you know, looking at the hidden gems. One of my favorite facts is over 50% of my students ended up going to a college that they had never heard of prior to working with me. So it's really discovering those types of places. The other thing, and we're seeing the numbers to support this, the National Association for College Admissions Counseling reported that enrollment at community colleges is the fastest growing enrollment right now in the country. And I think that is a great option for students who are worried about the cost. This generation is very fixated about the cost of college, and rightfully so. So maybe it is going to a community college and starting somewhere there or a regional public. You know, a lot of students in your state focus on Penn State, the main campus, but there are many of their regional sites that are awesome and have great opportunities. And you still get to go to the Penn State football games if you so choose, and those regional locations and be more cost-effective and more affordable for families. So there are ways to go about this. I still go back to we need to help students think about what are majors, what are careers, what are opportunities out there much earlier in the game. So, parents, if you are listening, please talk to your kids about what are majors, what are careers, go explore, because there's more jobs than just doctor, engineer, teacher, uh, and a couple others, business, you know, those are kind of probably the popular ones that are out there.
SPEAKER_01Do you think we'll see some negative economic pressure on the cost of emissions to help correct it? Or do you think that has to be at this point a federal intervention of like capping the maximum amount of money a person can borrow? Because like college has exponentially increased its cost over the past two decades. It has not exponentially gotten better. It's just more expensive. So see that going.
SPEAKER_00It has gotten more expensive for those that don't qualify for financial aid. And one thing that we are seeing is that the parameters of qualifying for financial aid have changed. And if parents are pissed about that, and you should be, financial aid is something that is put together by the U.S. Congress. So talk to your elected officials about how FAFSA works. FAFSA, the free application for federal student aid, that is all done through the federal government. So talk to your elected officials and say, hey, this is not working right. We've also seen the federal government change the loan qualifications in this past year or so. And this is going to be a huge change. And I am concerned about this. I'm concerned about the affordability, especially for higher-level degrees, uh, because of the change in loans. And so students may have to strategize and change paths. They may have to switch to more part-time type enrollment and being able to work on the side to make some of these things work, or come up with alternative paths. There are some colleges that are now providing co-op opportunities where you can get college credit for working and getting that career experience that way. That could be a way to do it. So there are ways to go about it. I think we're going to see a big deviation from the standard graduate from high school, you go to a four-year college, you then go out into the workforce, and it's very cut and dry that way. I think we're going to see some very different paths that come up. And that's fine. And it totally works. And there are many successful people that have taken alternative paths. We need to normalize that and say, yep, if you need to take five or six years because you decided to do part-time and work while you're going to college, that is a possibility.
SPEAKER_01What um what is the appropriate amount of time or what is the best amount of time for a family to start this process in figuring out just this in terms of like you said, potentially the middle school, but like where I guess where is the sweet spot where you know a lot of families might not think that? I get a lot of like, we're not even worried about college masters until junior year. Like, where is this? Oh, dude. Yeah. Where, where, where is the appropriate timeline for families out there?
SPEAKER_00It's way earlier than what people think. Uh, one of my most popular podcast episodes right now is planning for college in eighth grade. And I really do think that parents need to think about this earlier because it's also what courses you take in high school. So I have to intervene a lot with students where they're wanting to apply. I'll give a perfect example. They want to apply to the University of California, pick your campus, doesn't matter. They have specific requirements, such as you need to take a fine and performing arts class for at least one full year. And here in the Midwest, that is not a requirement to graduate from high school. So now I have to help them quickly come up with a way to fill that entrance requirement that the University of California has that they were not ready for. Had I started with that family earlier in eighth or ninth or even tenth grade, I would have been able to solve that problem a whole lot faster. Too many families come to me late. I can still help them. I don't want to, you know, totally freak everyone out, but we need to be starting these conversations a whole lot earlier. Put it this way: would you rather have a long runway for a plane to take off, or would you rather have a 10-foot runway for a plane to take off?
SPEAKER_01Sure. To get an algae. So um, Chuck, as we close out, like what's one thing you want family to remember about this conversation?
SPEAKER_00I want families to know that it is possible to go to college. There's lots of great opportunities out there. I know it's scary. I know it's confusing. It looks expensive. It doesn't have to be. There are people like me and other independent educational consultants that are willing to help. There's also lots of free resources. So I always hope that people will check out my podcast. Uh, don't chuck it up, because I give out a lot of free advice about how to make this work. I want students and families to be less stressed, to have more control over this process, and to enjoy the college experience. This is a marathon, not a sprint, and I'm here to help people every step of the way.
SPEAKER_01Chuck, I appreciate it. This has been awesome to have a conversation with you. Uh, for families who want to go deeper with you or the organization you're with, where should they check out first?
SPEAKER_00You can find us at collegeconnectors.com uh or you can also search up Don't Chuck It Up Podcast. Uh, I'm on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, all the different things. They can reach out to me there and Don't Chuck It Up on all social media platforms. Uh, reach out to me, send me a DM. I'm happy to help you out. All right.
SPEAKER_01Hey, if you ever need someone to talk about APs, let me know. Be happy to come back.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01All right. Chuck, thank you. Thank you all for tuning in the Supported Learning Podcast. I will see you next time. Thanks, Chuck. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.