SupportED Learning Podcast
On a mission to speak with global education experts on how we can revolutionize the education system, especially in the dawn of AI.
SupportED Learning Podcast
Episode 86 - ex-UPenn Admissions Chair: Inside the Ivy League Selection Room - Elizabeth Heaton - Elizabeth Heaton
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the SupportED Learning Podcast, Dr. Joe sits down with Elizabeth Heaton, former admissions officer at the University of Pennsylvania and former senior director of educational consulting at Bright Horizons College Coach, to break down what actually happens when an admissions committee reads your kid’s application and why most families are preparing for the wrong game.
Dr. Joe and Elizabeth discuss why each application file gets roughly 15 minutes and what survives that read, the piccolo problem and why what schools need changes year to year in ways families can’t predict, why chasing last year’s admissions trends is always a losing strategy, what it actually looks like inside a selection committee when two applicants look identical on paper, why applying to more than 12 schools produces diminishing returns, and the single most important thing families can do tonight after listening.
This episode is especially useful for parents of competitive high schoolers applying to selective or Ivy League schools, families wondering whether early decision actually gives an edge, students who feel pressure to do everything perfectly but don’t know where to focus, and anyone who wants to understand the admissions process from someone who was in the room making the decisions.
📲 Connect with them: https://www.linkedin.com/in/elizabethaheaton/
College Coach: https://getintocollege.com/
Podcast: https://getintocollege.com/Resources/Getting-In-Podcast
📲 Learn more about us: https://supportedtutoring.com/
Facebook: Dr. Joe
Instagram: @dr_joe_ap_exams
Book a call: supportedtutoring.com/book-call-youtube
Thanks for tuning in to the SupportED Learning Podcast with Dr. Joe. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe for more insights on education, critical thinking, and AI integration in learning. Visit our website at supportedtutoring.com
Remember to share this podcast with fellow parents and educators who are passionate about reimagining education for tomorrow's world. Until next time, keep supporting learning!
You're listening to the Support Ed Learning Podcast, where we challenge the status quo of education and reimagine what learning should be. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian, and in every episode we dive into critical thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, educational innovation, and how AI is shaping the future of learning. Whether you're a teacher, parent, policymaker, or lifelong learner, you're in the right place to rethink, reshape, and revive education. She is a former vice president of educational consulting at Bright Horizons College Coach. But before that, she chaired admissions committees at the University of Pennsylvania for Warden and the School of Arts and Sciences. She was in the room where Ivy League Emissions actually happens, and she's taught other consultants at Penn Graduate School of Education and hosted a weekly podcast on the process. Elizabeth Heaton is here today. We're getting into what emissions officers actually see when they read applications, the biggest myths families believe, and how to survive the process without losing your mind. Welcome back to the Support Learning Podcast. I'm Dr. Joe Sebastian. Families often ask me how to navigate the maze of college emissions without wasting hours of time or spending thousands of dollars. And the answer usually involves finding the people that have figured out the rules of the game that schools aren't telling you. That's why I'm thrilled to have Elizabeth Heaton today. Again, she is a former VP of educational consulting at Bright Horizons College coach. And again, she was the regional director of emissions at the University of Pennsylvania. And she also hosted a podcast on this entire process. So we're going to dive into what actually happens into the emissions committee rooms and what kind of debunk what many families believe on the myths of the application process. Elizabeth, welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_01Thanks. Thank you. Thanks for having me, Dr. Jo.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Um, so yours you started your career in public relations and then jumped into emissions at Penn, where you reviewed, I think, over 1,300 files per year, and you shared the selection committee and evaluated athletic recruits as well. So that's an unusual pipeline. What was the connective tissue between PR and emissions that made the move make sense?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, uh PR is really just about getting eyes on your clients. And in many ways, admissions is that as well. I mean, families don't really think they think of admissions as people who are gatekeepers, but really, when you're doing admissions, you're out there, you are talking about an institution, you're promoting the institution, you're trying to get people interested in attending your school. So in many ways, it really is a public relations-related job, albeit one with different uh implications than, you know, when I was doing PR for Hilton, the goal there was to get more people to stay at Hilton's. And when I was working at Penn, we just wanted to get more students who made sense for Penn to apply and consider attending.
SPEAKER_00So you said one of the least favorite parts of the job was actually watching bright, passionate, probably really well qualified and engaged students to make bad choices, wrong essay topics, poor curriculum decisions that didn't tell a story. What was the specific moment that you cross over from the gatekeeping process to actually coaching this?
SPEAKER_01Well, the the having a baby was a big piece. Uh, admissions is uh it's a lot of time on the road, a lot of time away from your family. Um, it's kind of a relentless process. And uh I just decided to opt out of that piece of it. But I did really love the work that I was doing, and I thought I had a lot to offer to students and parents and helping them understand the process from the perspective of someone who had been in the room. And so uh, you know, really, if I'm gonna pinpoint the moment, it really was that. It was becoming a mom and and recognizing that an admissions lifestyle wasn't super sustainable for me. Um and that's when I decided to go into coaching. What I didn't factor in was how much I actually did enjoy the work. I was sort of thinking, well, this is like the admissions work I was doing. I think I will like it, but I was surprised by how much I did indeed like it. Love it, in fact.
SPEAKER_00So I guess like you founded, it says here you founded um getting in a college coach conversation in 2015. So that was the podcast, right?
SPEAKER_01Correct, yes.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And so in the the first episodes, you spent nearly a decade through that, that seems to March 2025, rotating hosting duties with a colleague. Looking back on the whole run, that's 10 years. Um in those 10 years, a lot has changed in college emissions. What has consistently happened to families that where they keep getting something wrong about elite college emissions that, you know, a single officer inside would never actually see?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I think um a couple of things. So we did a weekly podcast for 10 years, still going on today, every week. So if people are interested getting in a college coach conversation, it's really great. It's very um the goal is to provide practical information and advice to families so that they can hopefully come away with um a blueprint for going through the process on their own, especially if they don't have the resources to hire somebody. Um But, you know, when I that was my entire purpose behind when we decided to start it. I said we have this great group of people. We know so much about what goes on in admissions, we would really like to share that with others for free. And so that that was the entire impetus behind the podcast, uh, creation of the podcast. Um, it isn't so much, I do think that people have a vision that um admissions is trying to hide things. And I think the the reason that people have that impression is because in the US, the process is quite opaque. It isn't as straightforward. In China, you take an exam, depending on how you do with that exam, you get in, you don't get in, and if you don't score high enough, you may not be going to college at all. In the US, we obviously have so many more options. Um, and yes, in some cases the decisions can be entirely based on a test score and a GPA, but there's also so much more to it, especially the more selective that you get. And so our goal really was to try and make it less opaque. Um and I, while I I hear what you're saying about so much has changed. I mean, now colleges read online, they used to read a paper file. Um, now more schools accept the common application than used to accept the common application. You have more schools that are test optional. Um, but on the whole, the process really isn't fundamentally very different from when I applied to college. Um maybe, you know, even when I was applying to college, there was early decision, there was early action, there was regular decision, there were rolling admissions. That all still exists. Now there are a number of schools that have a second round of early decision, or there are variations on a theme with early action, you could have single choice. But the core of it all remains the same. And that is that these schools are simply looking for students who fit within their school, within that applicant pool in a given year. And that's one of the other pieces that's so difficult is that in one year you apply and you might be the most unique applicant that year. Um, or you might really stand out in that pool. Maybe, you know, I'm gonna steal a colleague's uh something that one of my colleagues at Penn used to say all the time, but you know, maybe you're applying in a year, you play the piccolo, the um orchestra has had no piccolos for a year or two, they're dying for a piccolo. Hey, if you see anyone in the applicant pool plays the piccolo and they are competitive, we want them. You you appear in the applicant pool, you play the piccolo, it's a perfect fit that year you're in. And then the next year, 20 piccolo's apply. The orchestra is no longer interested in piccolos, now they need um a viola. And, you know, they're short on violas. And now this year you would play the piccolo, and but what they need are violas. And that's kind of in essence, especially at the very selective level, what it can come down to, which is you're crafting a class, you're admitting a group of individuals, but you want them to kind of come together in a really diverse and interesting class. And um, you know, you just have no idea who's gonna be in the applicant pool alongside you, and you really don't know what the institutional priorities are that year. And yeah, that's the tricky part.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, SG Personal Priorities is interesting because they do change and they're a moving target. Like um, most recently, CMU's institutional priorities was to recruit more people that would stay local to Pittsburgh because a lot of people come in, get their degrees, and leave. Um, and so families don't actually understand that. And I think counter that, the families I'm talking to and that I hear, they're chasing last year's emission strategies or like global emission strategies. So, how do you educate families to counter that? Because like what worked last year is not necessarily going to work this year, which is why we have mass-produced passion projects or research papers or internships that look what like last year's emittance was. So, how does one navigate that process?
SPEAKER_01The most important piece of this entire process is for students to be authentic to who they are. If they are authentic to who they are and they follow their interests, that is going to be the way that they are most likely going to stand out. Like you say, they're chasing last year's trends. You can't turn your kid into that kid. If you've never picked up the piccolo before, you know, you can't because, oh, I heard that pen wanted piccolos, you need to learn how to play the piccolo, but I've been playing the viola. Well, now you need to switch to the piccolo. Now you switched to the piccolo, and now they needed what you used to do, but you're not doing that anymore, right? You you need to, it's becoming a tortured metaphor that I'm using here. But basically, if students would simply and parents allow the kids to really focus in on the things they're most interested in, they're going to be much more apt to be successful in those areas and to achieve at a level that might help them stand out. But you can't guess what is going to be important to an institution in a given year. So all you can really do is be true to who you are. And I would argue that that's the best path forward anyway, because you could do everything right and, you know, still not make the cut. When you're looking at schools that are admitting three, two, four percent of their applicant pools, the odds are stocked stacked against you anyway. So there's really nothing you can do to guarantee an admission to MIT or guarantee an admission to Stanford or to any number of very selective institutions. All you can really do is say, this is what I'm interested in, and I'm gonna pursue those interests in ways that are, I think, interesting, that are um quantifiable, so that I can put it down in my application in a meaningful way. Um and that's gonna, that's really the answer. You know, people are chasing a silver bullet, or I read this article and this kid did this, I want you to do that. And what they're doing is losing their authenticity in the process. And that's actually the thing that's gonna make them stand out the most.
SPEAKER_00Do you think one of the problems is that a lot of these kids that are trying to get in, some of the top kids aren't one, um probably driven vicariously from their parents wanting them to get in. More the more the desire actually stands on their parents more than the kid getting in. And number two, they don't even know how to be authentic or stand out. Um yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01No, sorry.
SPEAKER_00No, I was gonna say, so like, you know, some of the groups, some of the groups, especially with shared like ethnic or racial backgrounds, um, can potentially have a harder time standing out because they're all excellent academically. They do all these things, and it's basically driven by um parents and I think a culture and social norms that value education. But then when it comes time to standing out to an admissions officer, how does one do that? And you're talking about being authentic. Well, if a kid can't be authentic, how what else can they do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, this is obviously, we could probably do three podcasts about this, right? I I think, yes, it can be driven by parents. It can also be driven by students themselves, you know, who are very focused on prestige. I think that the first thing I would do is step back from saying it has to be this group of schools or nothing, and the prestige is what matters here. Um, because if you if you if that's all you're focused on, then I would agree it's almost impossible to be authentic because you're doing everything for that institution who and and you're not doing anything for yourself. So if you, you know, the way that you so MIT, there's a an admissions officer at MIT back in, I believe, 2013, wrote a wonderful um blog called Applying Sideways, where um he really goes into this whole concept of just follow your interests. If you can follow your interests in interesting ways, that is going to serve you in the long run. So one thing I think needs to happen is people need to stop looking at high school as purely you're just doing a bunch of things in high school in order to get into college. High school has its own set of benefits, and you need to embrace those. You know, you're learning new things. That is the goal in high school, right? It is to learn and then also hopefully to prepare you for the next level if you're going to go on to college for the next level of college. But it's not just a means to an end. It is actually an opportunity to learn, to grow, to follow some things that you're interested in, to get involved in those things. Um and, you know, there is no magic bullet. I can't, uh in terms of like um, you know, how do you, how can you be authentic? Well, for starters, I've worked with students where, and my colleagues have as well, where the kid is saying, I really want to be an English major. I love English. I want to read. I want to um, I want to read novels, I want to write literary criticism. These are the things I want to study in college. And the parent might be saying, Well, we think you need to be a pharmacist or you should be an accountant. And, you know, it's a college is expensive. It's not that I don't understand that, and it's certainly not up to me to make that decision for a family if you're going to spend that kind of money on a college education. And you may feel very strongly that it has to be something, you know, computer science, it has to lead to a law degree, it has to lead to a medical degree. But if those are not the things that the student is interested in, I would agree that it's almost impossible for them to be authentic. Um I I don't really know the answer. What I can tell you is that the students I have worked with who have been successful at getting into the most selective schools in the country or um, you know, the most rejective school in the country, if you've heard that terminology, um have been students who have, for the most part, been really interested in things and their parents have supported those interests. Um, they have done really well in school, but it's more internal metal motivation than external motivation. And same with the things that they've been involved in. And so the authenticity is just sort of a natural outcome of that. So what's the answer? There isn't. I wish there was an answer. If there was an answer to how do you how do you do this, how do you, you know, then every student could do it. And, you know, you probably wouldn't need podcasts or people doing the work that um that I've been doing for most of my career.
SPEAKER_00It's interesting because you actually helped out with athletics. And um I think some parents that actually understand how to read a common data set or have been told, oh, you know, UPenn has 99% of the kids get 3.75. But there's like this small percentage of kids that might be these outliers. That too applies, though they're not athletes, right? I think how do you, I guess, how do you help families understand, or how did you help families understand that like if you're looking for the minimal threshold, it might be some outlying circumstances where there was athletes being recruited, mostly football, basketball programs, that they got in because they met other criteria.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, we so one important thing to note about Ivy League athletic uh recruitment is that they cannot admit athletes that are more than two standard deviations away from the rest of the applicant pool, right? So the floor for the Ivy League athletes is quite a bit higher than the floor for athletes across um college sports. Um how do you, you know, when you look at, so may let's say a student goes to a school like uh where they use um, you know, a some type of a format to show what students have done in the past, you know, who've applied to that high school, who's gotten in, um, and it kind of can show you some norms. We always talk about, you know, you're the the person who doesn't seem like the rest is exactly that. They're an outlier. You need to be looking at the averages and where you fit with the averages. And don't worry about this person who's out there who seems like, oh, but I'm I'm in line with that person. Well, right, that person could have been um a recruited athlete, that person could have been um a development uh admit, that person, you know, that there could have been some personal story that that student had that explained maybe a lower test score or a lower GPA that you're not privy to. But what you what we do know is that they are an outlier. And while you could be an outlier, let's see, you're you're not a recruited athlete, you aren't a development student, there's nothing about your personal story that would um explain maybe a lower GPA or a lower test score in a way that is gonna get you over the hump. So we do spend a lot of time talking to students and who, you know, and parents about what does it mean to be an outlier and what are the chances that you will be an outlier? And, you know, it it is all what makes this more of an art than a science, right? If it was straightforward, you'd take a test and just like they do, like in China, and you would, they'd have cutoffs and you would know if you were in or you were out. And that's just not how this process works here.
SPEAKER_00Um can you speak a little bit about I think goalposts? I've had these conversations with other consultants and missions officers of I I think there is also a misconception, and a lot of people chasing the name, especially Ivy League. They're they're looking at the journey ending on admissions, on acceptance, right? Like I got my kid into Ivy League, and it seems like, from the people I've talked to, including you, Ivy League's looking for it's like, what are you gonna do once you're in and once you graduate? How are you gonna represent the university? What are you so that's a pretty big gap, right? How do we shift the conversation and make people understand Ivy Leagues don't really care that you really want to get into their school. They care about what you're gonna do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, we do, I do talk to students about this a lot. It's sort of um, you know, they're looking at that that selectivity level and as a way to continue to be that brand of choice, right? You're gonna be graduating people who go on to do great things. So they're looking for evidence that you might be that person when you are applying. And so, you know, I talk to students all the time about the types of students who tend to be successful in that applicant pool, um, they see a problem and they start working on fixing it, right? They're they're Already saying that that doesn't seem right. What can I do to help improve that? So, you know, I worked with this student who was really focused on, well, he was a sailor. He liked to be in the water. And so environmental causes were important to him because, you know, you don't want the water polluted. It will prevent you from doing a lot of the things he liked to do in the water. And so he got involved with his school's environmental group. But then he thought, well, what more can we do? So he got involved with a community organization that was testing water quality and, you know, trying to impact changes in the community and how the water was cared for and, you know, getting people or trying to get it less and less polluted. And then he went on to think about well, you know, I could see that they're putting up all of these buildings and environmental causes are important, not just related to the water, but also in everywhere we look, right? So he became a lead certified student. And he was the youngest person, I believe, if I'm remembering correctly, because it's been a while, to ever be lead certified. And so that he could help people who were, you know, architects who are putting up buildings know if they were making environmentally sound choices. And, you know, that was part of his goal when he got to college was to be ever more active in that area. So everything that he was doing was geared to how can I, you know, how can I help to improve the world in this way? As you and I know, there are a million different ways we could strive to improve the world. But that was his area of focus because that's what he was interested in. And so anytime a student can look at, you know, a problem in their school, in their local community, maybe it is even in the larger world, but I always encourage them to look a little bit more closer to home. And it aligns with something they're really interested in, and they look for a solution. Maybe they achieve a solution, or at least, you know, take practical steps towards starting to achieve a solution. That's going to show colleges, oh, like this is someone who, you know, sees an issue and starts to tackle it. They're not waiting to have the degree before they start to get involved in the world around them. They're already doing it. And so, you know, practically speaking, that is one way in which students can possibly stand out as potential. But, you know, the other thing we all have to keep in mind is that these schools graduate thousands of students, and most of them don't go on to change the world. But it, you know, it can feel like that is the expectation. And for in some cases, it kind of is that you at least have the potential to do that. You may not do it, but maybe you're already showing the potential that you might when you get to college or after college.
SPEAKER_00This episode is brought to you by Supported Tutoring, where we don't just help students get better grades, we help them become critical thinkers. Whether it's mastering AP exams, maximizing college applications, or building lifelong learning habits, our expert tutors focus on critical thinking, confidence, and real growth. Head to supportedtutoring.com to find the support your student deserves. As someone who sat on the chair of this, like and led these discussions, when you see, so let's just say hypothetically, in this situation, you have applicants that almost look identical on paper, great GPA, great test scores, activities, whole profiles, really good. What does it ultimately come down to? How do you decide who gets it?
SPEAKER_01Well, institutional priorities is a big one, right? What are we actually looking for? Where in the country or the world do they live? Do we need more students from that area? Um, what program? Uh, you know, Penn has four schools, and we did admissions for all four. So nursing, engineering, uh, Wharton, and uh the College of Arts and Sciences. Um, you know, how many spaces were we filling in each of those schools? And what was the students, what did they want to study? And have they made a compelling case for the fact that they really want to study it at this institution and why? Like why I think many students struggle with that part of it. They're so focused on often on the prestige and the name that all they want to talk about in the the essay that asks you why is how great the institution is. And I'm always telling my students, they already know they're great. Don't tell them they're great. Tell them why they're a good fit for you. Tell them how you're gonna take advantage of what's available to you there. So that can be one way in which a student might stand out is that they've done a really good job at articulating the match between their interests, what the school offers, and how they're gonna take advantage of that. So how those things are gonna come together for them. Um it's what they've done outside of the classroom. We, the example I was giving earlier, maybe, you know, in a given year they're doing something that is really unique, that we're not seeing a lot of other applicants are involved in. And then in a different year, it might be hundreds of other applicants are involved in some in similar things. So you're looking for students who are a little bit unique that year in the pool. And if you're not paying attention at this point, you'll know. Like the answer to the question is, well, how do you know? You don't. You really don't. You have no idea who you're gonna be up against in the pool. So the only thing you can do and control is how, you know, the things doing the things that are interesting to you, and then making sure you spend a proper amount of time working on your application. So a lot of students drop the ball when it comes to translating everything they've been doing, all their hard work. It's time to translate into the application. They leave it to the last minute, they present their activities in the wrong order. Um, they kind of lose the plot at the most important moment. So, you know, that's another thing that um can impact your, you know, you could be looking at the transcript. It looks great. You, you look, you're reading the letters of recommendation, they're wonderful. The student's personal presentation, you get to that and you're thinking, did they write this the day before they submitted the application? Did they proofread? Did they actually think about why they wanted our school versus a different school? Um, that could be the place where one student might really stand out and another might fall by the wayside, um, even if on paper they look similar.
SPEAKER_00And how does a family weigh um whether as an ED decision or early action? I mean, I think ED is a little bit more, obviously, pressure since you have to be super, but like um you have a list of schools, they all do early decision. How do you narrow that down? And furthermore, like being inside that that selection process, um how do you guys look at those ED applications? It's like what does it it it's obviously gives kids a little bit of an advantage because of the emissions rates, but what does that process look like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, certainly when you're looking at the most selective levels, right? You have either early decision or early action. At the most selective levels, usually if they have a early action, they make it a single choice early action or restrictive early action, um, which is not my favorite. But because you really don't get an advantage, but you also lose a potential advantage. If we're talking purely strategy, early decision does give you a little bit of an advantage because if you are admitted, you're committing to attending that school, and it's an almost 100% yield for the school, which is great. If they admit 700 students in early decision, that's 700 students that they have guaranteed in their class for the most part, right? You can get out of early decision for financial reasons, but generally speaking, that would be the only reason that you would. That said, there is because you are going to have, whether you're reading in early action or early decision, you're going to have thousands, tens of thousands more students applying in regular decision. So there's no reason for you to admit someone who isn't extraordinarily competitive and very interesting to you. So all it really does, the way I typically like to categorize this is let's say you have 7,000 applications in early decision and 60,000 in regular decision. It is a little bit easier to pop out of a group of 7,000 applicants to stand out in that group than it is to stand out in an applicant pool of 60,000. And it really, in many ways, kind of comes down to that. So, you know, you read those applications the same way you read them in regular decision, and you have the same deliberation process. Um, you just have fewer students that you're discussing for that particular period of time. But the process itself is really no different than it is in regular decision.
SPEAKER_00Gotcha. What's the one thing you want parents to know about the competitive emission process that we haven't already talked about?
SPEAKER_01Uh, I think, you know, I did mention that when the acceptance rate is in the single digits, and quite honestly, when it's in the, you know, the teens, you need to, it's unpredictable and it's virtually impossible to say what is going to happen. And so you have to go into it understanding that the likelihood is not high that the student is going to get in. I also think a big thing I wish people would understand is that more is not more in any way in this process, right? So more applications doesn't make improve the odds. I'm not a statistician, but I'm pretty sure that just because you're submitting more applications, you are not changing your odds at each individual school. Um and what happens when students do too many applications is they stretch themselves too thinly. They aren't able to give proper attention to all of them. And uh, you know, they end up, I see it every year, that the students who apply to, you know, too many schools, which I would say is more than 12, is too many. And if they apply to more than that, I see diminishing returns. And sometimes they're not even getting into schools that I think they have a really good shot at. And it's usually because they haven't had enough time to devote to getting to know the school, to showing demonstrated interest, to doing a good job on the application itself. And then in terms of the actual application, schools ask for what they want. And I find that students and parents can get really caught up in giving much more than they want. We're gonna send them in the idea that more is better. And actually, you know, when I was reading files, I had uh to read 30 files a day. And generally speaking, I had about 15 minutes per file to time to read each file. And so if I was looking at a file that was twice as thick as the rest of the stack, that wasn't a good thing. That was, you've already annoyed your admissions officer before they've even flipped open the cover of the file or clicked on the file to start reading. Um, you want to give them what they've asked for. You want to do as good a job as possible on what they ask for. And then you need to trust the process and know that they're gonna review those materials that you've sent. They're gonna do their best to make the best decision they can for the institution. And if you didn't get it, it's not because you didn't provide them with 10 copies of all the certificates that you won. It's simply because the odds already just aren't in your favor. And I the last thing I wish is that both parents and students would get excited about every school on their list and they absolutely have to have a balanced list. You can't just be applying to schools that are, even if you are a straight A student with a phenomenal record in every way, you you must have schools that are going to be more likely to admit you than schools where they're only going to admit 3% of the students who are applying.
SPEAKER_00Right. So having a nice robust list of ranges there, right?
SPEAKER_01Exactly. 12 schools, have some reaches, have some good matches, have some good probable options, and be excited about all of them. Feel like you could attend all of them. And the students I've worked with who've been happiest in the process, and ironically, in many cases, have gotten one of their top choices are students who have embraced that part of it, who've said, there are a lot of places I know that I can be happy. They have a good list, it's balanced. They have given each school the proper amount of attention. They haven't waited to the last minute, but they also haven't made themselves crazy. Um, you know, writing the essay and then rewriting it after it's done. Um, they've said this, I think this is as good a representation of me as I can make it. And now I'm gonna see what the institutions say.
SPEAKER_00All right, Elizabeth, let's uh let's shift gears and moving the lightning around, all right? Okay. Cool. So what's the most overrated thing families obsess over in college emissions?
SPEAKER_01Most overrated uh name, name brand. I mean, I like that's just it's almost too easy, but that. How about most underrated? Uh how many amazing institutions there are out there where you could get a great degree, and in many cases, where they might give you money so that it could be significantly less expensive. And really, you know, a student can go pay a lot less, be a big fish in a smaller pond. Um, you know, so those schools that often get overlooked because, oh, you know, they aren't turning away as many students as this school. They want me, therefore I don't want them. So I think those schools are so underrated. And if you visit lots of schools, as I have, I, you know, I'm just always struck by how frequently I say, this is such a great school. I mean, my son just graduated from college, but you know, how often I say, Oh, he could have gone here. I bet he would have really liked it. I say that more than I don't when I visit colleges.
SPEAKER_00How about most underrated?
SPEAKER_01Most underrated.
SPEAKER_00Like a thing families should obsess over, I guess.
SPEAKER_01Ah, yeah. Let's see. Something they should obsess over. I I think it's it's um finding the place where a student will actually be happy rather than the place that carries the most prestige. And there certainly are plenty of parents and students who do focus on that piece of it. Like, where am I, where do I feel like I fit? But I often see that the prestige comes first and the fit comes second. And if they could flip that, well, if they could put prestige way back down on the list and really focus more on where is the student feel comfortable? Um, where are they gonna find the thing, the people their people? Um, I think that is an underrated part of the process.
SPEAKER_00How about one thing parents overthink?
SPEAKER_01Uh I I think what do they overthink? They overthink, are they, is they, are they doing everything they can? Is their student, you know, doing everything they can? They overthink, oh my gosh, my kid has a B plus, they're not gonna get into college. So I think they get too caught up in the media narrative and instead forget that there are a lot of options out there and there's a place for every student, um, and there's a price point for every family also. And so I think sometimes they they I don't know if that's overthinking or overlooking or um getting too bogged down in minutiae that ultimately won't matter.
SPEAKER_00How about something that they underthink?
SPEAKER_01Boy. Uh that when the process starts. Um so I am not I'm not a big fan of students getting outside help as early as eighth or ninth grade, but it is really important to recognize that the decisions kids make early on in high school will ultimately impact um the options they're going to have. And I don't even know if it's parents that are underthinking this so much as students are because they're young and, you know, who can think about what's going to happen next week, let alone in four years. But um if if they could recognize just, you know, one thing that I encourage families to do when a student starts high school is, you know, do a plan for the coursework that the student might do throughout high school, you know, starting in ninth grade and ending up in 12th grade. You know what the goal would be for me, for every student, is to stick with all five major subjects, math, science, English, history, and foreign language or world language, all four years. And um, you know, how are they gonna do that? Can they plot it out? Doesn't mean you can't change, doesn't mean you can't pivot. But um, what's terrible is you get to junior year and now you really want to do, let's say, pre-calculus. But because the student opted, you know, to take a different math in freshman year, now they're not lined up and they they can't take the pre-calculus. If they recognize that the math they were placed into freshman year wasn't gonna get them there, um, you know, by the time they graduated, they might have been able to do something like double up or take it over the summer or get into a different math. Um, but if you don't think about it ahead of time and try to plot it out, you may not recognize that. Math is probably a bad example because a math path is fairly straightforward and set. But you know, something like a student who wants to take AP chemistry by the time they're a senior. And there's there could be a progression at their school where they, in order to do that, they have to take, you know, honors bio as a sophomore and honors chemistry as a junior, so they can then place into the AP chemistry. But maybe you're not paying attention and you didn't do that, and now you can't take that class. So I would love it if more families would just sit down freshman year, look at the course catalog, and plot it out, recognizing that that's not, you're not stuck doing that, but just having a sense of what you need to do.
SPEAKER_00What's the best thing a family should ask on a college tour?
SPEAKER_01Well, in a perfect world, the student would do the questions, would ask the questions. So I'd start there. But I also appreciate that, you know, not all students are going to ask questions. I, you know, sitting down before you go on these college trips and thinking about what is actually important to you about this college, um, or about what, you know, what it what are your non-negotiables? Notre Dame has a great question this year asking about what are your non-negotiables for your college experience? And I love that question. And I would encourage students to and parents to think about that. Like, what are your non-negotiables and why? And then if you don't get enough information about those non-negotiables in your visit, then you can ask questions about them. So if it's really important to you that um you have a dining hall in your dorm. Don't know why that would be a non-negotiable. Seems silly, but maybe that's really important to you. Maybe you can and no one talks about it. You could ask the question where are the dining halls? Is this a situation where you're gonna have to hike across campus to get something to eat? Or are dining halls in all the dorms? So you could go right downstairs. Maybe that's something that's important to you. I've I've singled out something that's a little silly, but you know, people have silly things that appeal to them. What I wouldn't ask about are things that you can find online easily, you know, average test scores, you know, what their how they um, you know, what their admissions deadlines are, things like that. I wouldn't waste time on something like that that you can easily find on the website. So ask opinion questions, I think are great, open-ended questions where the person who is doing the tour could um give their own opinions about what they like about a school or maybe dislike about a school, right? So you know, asking those kinds of questions that uh that a website can't answer for you.
SPEAKER_00Right. Um and finally, like if a parent could do one thing after listening to this, what should it be?
SPEAKER_01Take a deep breath uh would be the first thing. I think the second thing would be if if the parent is focused on the student going to college and the student is on the same page, recognize that, you know, it they will go to college, it will work out. Um, I I do think if you haven't done that that exercise I suggested of plotting out the the path through high school and what they want to take and you know, by when, I think that's something that um they could do tonight after they listen to this podcast. I also think um sitting down with the student and having them write out everything they've been involved in so far in high school, you know, in terms of their activities, sometimes students don't keep an accurate record of the things they've been doing. And then they sit down to fill out the common application and they're drawing a blank. Like they they played soccer all four years, but they've forgotten about, you know, the play that they did freshman year or um, you know, that March of Dimes walk they did as a sophomore. And they've got five things to add, but now they think they don't have anything else to add. But really, if they'd kept a list, they would have plenty of things to get to the 10 that the Common App is asking for. So start that list and and keep updating it as the student does more things.
SPEAKER_00All right, Elizabeth, thank you so much uh for sharing all that and information and the strategies. I do appreciate you joining us from uh well, it's not across the pond, I guess, in France, right? What is it? What do they call it?
SPEAKER_01Uh it's kind of across the pond, across the sea. There you go. So yeah, no, it's been great. I I've really enjoyed it, and I hope um there's been something helpful here for uh for your listeners.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for anyone that wants to maybe learn more about what you offer. I know you're kind of out of it right now. You've you've semi-retired from this. Where can where's best can they find you?
SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, I would um I'm not on the podcast anymore, but as I mentioned earlier, the Getting In a College Coach Conversation is a really great podcast for families going through the college process with lots of really helpful uh tips and information. Um and College Coach itself is also a really great resource, lots of amazing educators. I'm really not doing a whole lot, but if they're interested in, um I'm on LinkedIn, uh Elizabeth Heaton, and you can see me there. And every once in a while I post um about that. And you can always reach out on uh on LinkedIn if you're interested in something like having me review an application before you send it, or you know, taking a look at an essay that you think is in a good place, but maybe you'd like some additional feedback. Those are the types of projects I'm taking on these days. Um, so if they're interested in that, you can find me on LinkedIn, uh Elizabeth Heaton.
SPEAKER_00All right, we'll put all that information in the show notes in the YouTube description. And again, thank you for all for watching the Supported Learning Podcast. We'll see you next time. Thank you, Elizabeth. Thank you. Thanks for joining us on the Supported Learning Podcast. If today's conversation inspired you, challenged you, or sparked a new perspective, be sure to subscribe and share with a fellow change maker. We'll be back soon with more voices, more insight, and more ways to elevate the future of learning together. Until then, keep learning and keep pushing the conversation forward.